26 Best Places To Buy Jewelry Online in 2024 for Mother’s Day
All products and services featured are independently chosen by editors. However, StyleCaster may receive a commission on orders placed through its retail links, and the retailer may receive certain auditable data for accounting purposes.
Today's Top Deals
Reviewers Say This Painless, Permanent Hair Removal Device Is a ‘Great Investment’—& It’s 25% Off RN
Here’s the thing: I love shoes and bags as much as the next gal, but I have a special place in my heart for jewelry, especially jewelry I can buy online. I am actually obsessed with my small collection. However, I also am constantly on the hunt for something new and shiny to wear, and we’re sure your mom is, too. If you want to figure out what to get the leading lady in your life, grabbing something sparkly can never hurt.
This year, Mother’s Day falls on Sunday May 12, 2024, so there’s still plenty of time to buy jewelry online and have it delivered in time. But where to start? That’s why we’ve rounded up a few of the best places to buy jewelry online so everyone can satisfy their inner magpie. Apologies in advance to your credit card balance!
The Best Online Jewelry Stores: Our Top 10 Picks in 2024
Best Overall: The Future Rocks
Best Minimalist: Mejuri
Best Affordable-ish Diamonds: VRAI
Best Lab-Created Diamonds: Pandora
Best for Personalized Jewelry: Gldn
Best Budget: Target
Best Designer Dupes: Quince
Best Gold Pieces: Arms of Eve
Best Earrings: Simone I. Smith
Best Classic Picks: Fred Meyer Jewelers
While I’m no true jewelry collector, I do keep a few, simple pieces in my collection that I wear every single day. On any given day, I’m wearing two simple gold chain necklaces (that won’t fade or tarnish) with a pair of small gold hoop earrings. While I don’t think I’ll ever grow tired of that necklace combo, I think I may need to update my usual rotation just a bit in 2024. Because the majority of my job is just browsing the web for the trendiest items ever, I feel that I have procured the best pieces from the best brands on the Internet—and now I’m sharing them with all of you.
I’m talking about everything from gorgeous lab-grown diamond pieces from Pandora, to luxe-feeling rings from Gldn. Oh—and a chain necklace from everyone’s go-to brand for gold pieces, Mejuri. Whatever your style, I can almost guarantee that you’ll find your new favorite bracelet, necklace or pair of earrings on this list.
How to Shop Jewelry Online, According to a Pro
We get that shopping for an investment piece online can be a bit intimidating, but Steven Singer, owner of Steven Singer Jewelers has a few tips.
Know the return and upgrade policy.
First, familiarize yourself with the return and upgrade policy.” Check out their return policy and upgrade policy. “You want a jeweler that is going to stand behind their merchandise, even if you are never going to return it. It says a lot about who you are buying from.”
Look for metal stamps.
“For precious metals, look out for the metal stamps,” he continues. “Pieces can be advertised as gold, but can vary in quality. The stamp on the jewelry should tell you the level of gold in the piece. 24k would denote that it is 100 percent gold, but this is not commonly used, because pure gold is not durable and is normally mixed with alloys for strength. 14k gold is standard for jewelry, but look out for 10k pieces as well, as it can be a more affordable option. There are gold-plated pieces, but they should be advertised and stamped as such.”
Read on to see a few of my faves and to find inspo for your next purchase. I can’t wait to see you rocking a bunch of these on the ‘Gram.
The Future Rocks
Alphabet LGD pendant necklace
On Sale 20% off
Our mission at STYLECASTER is to bring style to the people, and we only feature products we think you’ll love as much as we do. The Future Rocks is a STYLECASTER sponsor, however, all products in this article were independently selected by our editors. Please note that if you purchase something by clicking on a link within this story, we may receive a small commission of the sale.
If you’re totally stumped at what to get your mom for Mother’s Day, this initial pendant is the perfect gift that is both chic and personalized, so Mom will know you didn’t shop last-minute. The Future Rocks is a sustainable jewelry brand that focuses on creating individual pieces, instead of mass-producing. The result is that each piece is consciously created and reduces waste over time. You can shop stunning necklaces, bracelets, earrings, and more that are perfect for gifting or for keeping for yourself.
Shipping Policy: shipping fee based on location and items
Return Policy: returns accepted within 14 day of purchase
Standout reviews: no reviews (the site does not publish reviews)
Mejuri
Chain Necklace
If you’re on the hunt for jewelry that’s the perfect combination of on-trend and timeless, Mejuri should be your go-to. Their fine jewelry pieces can be a bit on the pricier side—this delicate gold chain is made from 14k yellow gold and retails for just under $300—but the investment is honestly worth it. While Mejuri is best known for their gold items, they also sell diamond, pearl and enamel options, as well.
Shipping Policy: Free shipping on all orders over $75.
Return Policy: Returns accepted for free within 30 days.
Standout reviews: “Beautiful, delicate piece. Get lots of compliments!”
Sevdalie
Cushion Portrait Horizontal Invisible Ring
Founded in Toronto, Canada, jewelry brand Sevdalie designs each of their pieces with sustainable luxury in mind. Sevdalie pieces are handmade, using lab-grown (mining-free) diamonds or moissanite for an elevated look without the hefty price tag. This is definitely the jewelry brand to go to for unique, visually-arresting designs. For example, we love this chain link ring that features a stunning moissanite stone and a 14k gold chain band. We also recommend taking a look at Sevdalie’s unisex line, which contains necklaces, bracelets, and rings that are versatile and aesthetically stunning.
Shipping Policy: Free shipping.
Return Policy: Exchanges accepted within 14 days
Standout reviews: none (the site doesn’t have shopper reviews)
Pandora
Pandora Nova Lab-grown Diamond Pendant Necklace
Pandora is known for its stunning, unique jewelry designs, and this diamond pendant necklace from its lab-grown diamond collection is a stand-out. Lab-grown diamonds are optically, chemically, and physically identical to natural-grown diamonds, but the price is a lot more accessible. What we love about this necklace: It’s delicate and dainty-looking, but thanks to the sturdy sterling silver and/or gold and high-quality design, you don’t have to worry about easy damage. This is truly an everyday, elevated necklace, and that goes for so many of Pandora’s designs (making it a top online jewelry pick in our opinion).
Shipping Policy: Free shipping on all orders over $75.
Return Policy: Returns accepted within 30 days for free.
Standout reviews: none (the site doesn’t have shopper reviews)
VRAI
VRAI V Solitaire Studs
Our mission at STYLECASTER is to bring style to the people, and we only feature products we think you’ll love as much as we do. VRAI is a STYLECASTER sponsor, however, all products in this article were independently selected by our editors. Please note that if you purchase something by clicking on a link within this story, we may receive a small commission of the sale.
Fourteen karat gold diamond earrings for under $250? How is it possible?! Thanks to VRAI’s lab-created diamonds, you can enjoy fine jewelry without breaking the bank. This unique design of V-shaped solitaire studs is so unique and is perfect for the fine jewelry lover who still loves a bit of edge in her designs (*raises hand*). In fact, VRAI exclusively works with lab-grown diamonds through its own zero-emission diamond foundry. Even climate activist Leonardo DiCaprio approves—in the form of being a direct investor in the company. I seriously just added these to my Christmas list.
Shipping Policy: A non-refundable shipping fee on all orders
Return Policy: Ready-to-ship, made-to-order jewelry and wedding/engagement pieces placed between October 25, 2023 through December 15, 2023, can be returned for a full return up until January 15, 2024. On December 16, orders will be eligible to be returned within 30 days. Loose diamonds are eligible for full return for 14 days.
Standout reviews: none (the site doesn’t have shopper reviews)
Gorjana
Parker Bracelet
So, you love classic jewelry but you’re looking for something new. Why not try Gorjana? They make both fashion and fine jewelry that is made to last. Much of their collection is priced under $100 (AKA: the perfect price point) but their more delicate come with a slightly higher price tag. Also, if you’re missing the charm bracelets that you had as a kid, Gorjana sells customizable options that don’t look childish at all.
Shipping Policy: Free standard shipping on all orders.
Return Policy: Accepted in full within 30 days.
Standout reviews: None
GLDN
Micro Signet Ring
Gldn has heirloom, bridal and on-trend jewelry pieces that you’ll have forever and that you can actually afford. This stunning micro signet ring is the perfect way to keep someone you love (or yourself!) close to your heart. The delicate initial punched into the thin band is about to become your new, everyday staple. Did we mention it’s 14k gold filled and just $70?
Shipping Policy: Free shipping on all orders over $125.
Return Policy: Returns accepted within 30 days with $8 handling fee.
Standout reviews: “I bought three to wear as a stack. My initial and my husband’s and GLDN was kind enough to make a bespoke one with a heart. Very comfortable. Beautiful craftsmanship and simple classic design. Wonderful experience ordering from GLDN.”
Quince
Croissant Ring
Quince — a direct-to-consumer (DTC) brand that offers clothing, accessories, and home goods — is home to some of the most gorgeous jewelry on the internet as a super reasonable price. I personally have this gold Croissant Ring (which is a dupe for Mejuri’s) and wear it all the time (even in the shower). Another Quince jewelry favorite which I’ve worn and tested for three years is this pair of hoop earrings in white gold.
Shipping Policy: Standard shipping is always free for all orders (no minimum).
Return Policy: Returns accepted within a year of purchase for a full reimbursement.
Standout reviews: “These [hoop earrings] look well-made, shiny, the closing mechanism works well and won’t fall out. I can tell no difference between these and the ones from an alternative more expensive brand that makes the same style. Highly recommend!”
Arms of Eve
Rose Heart Necklace
Our mission at STYLECASTER is to bring style to the people, and we only feature products we think you’ll love as much as we do. Fred Meyer Jewelers is a STYLECASTER sponsor, however, all products in this article were independently selected by our editors. Please note that if you purchase something by clicking on a link within this story, we may receive a small commission of the sale.
Arms of Eve is the brain child of Australian designer Kerryn Langer, who draws inspiration from her African heritage and her Australian home. The result is unique, bohemian-inspired designs that you can mix and match and wear for any occasion. We love this golden heart necklace as the perfect gift to yourself this Valentine’s Day. The puffy charm adds dimension to any stack of necklaces and is perfect for layering.
Shipping Policy: Free shipping on purchases over $200, free gift on purchases over $60
Return Policy: Returns or exchanges within 14 days of purchase.
Standout reviews: “This is a lovely piece of jewelry. Beautiful gold colour and just the right length. Gorgeous piece which I will wear often.”
Simone I. Smith
Simplicity Hoops
On Sale 50% off
Our mission at STYLECASTER is to bring style to the people, and we only feature products we think you’ll love as much as we do. Fred Meyer Jewelers is a STYLECASTER sponsor, however, all products in this article were independently selected by our editors. Please note that if you purchase something by clicking on a link within this story, we may receive a small commission of the sale.
Simone I. Smith is a designer, 19-year cancer survivor, philanthropist, and the wife of LL COOL J. In 2011, she launched her jewelry brand and through her partnership with the American Cancer Society, donates a portion of proceeds from each sale to the ongoing fight against the disease.
These unique hoops feature a slight drop detail that has a mini branded hoop scooped underneath. The result is a stand-out pair of hoops that’ll soon become your everyday pair. Since they’re made with 18 carat yellow gold over sterling silver, they’re strong, durable, and ultra-polished.
Shipping Policy: A non-refundable shipping fee on all orders
Return Policy: Returns accepted within 30 days from order receipt with return authorization number
Standout reviews: none (the site doesn’t have shopper reviews)
Target
3 Row Chunky Chain Necklace
If you haven’t paid a visit to Target.com in a while, you’re about to be shocked. The retailer has seriously upped its game over the past few years and you can find the perfect piece of jewelry for any occasion, like this stacked layered necklace that takes the styling guesswork out of your morning routine.
Shipping Policy: Free shipping on all orders over $35.
Return Policy: Returns accepted for free within 90 days.
Standout reviews: “This is so cute! Good quality & price. It’s very on trend to wear layered necklaces. I’m very happy with this purchase.”
Ring Concierge
Scattered Diamond Stackable Ring
Ring Concierge specializes in fine jewelry and engagement rings that are meant to be both aspirational and attainable. You can find everyday jewelry for under $250 or gold and diamond pieces up to $5,000. The pieces are classic yet modern. This stackable ring would make for a great anniversary or Valentine’s Day gift.
Shipping Policy: Free shipping on all orders.
Return Policy: Returns accepted within 14 days.
Standout reviews: “Fast shipping, love the jewelry selection, quality, and discounts. Already purchased from them twice.”
Melinda Maria
Baby Grand Slam Tennis Necklace 16″
Celeb-approved brand Melinda Maria designs statement-making pieces that are cute enough to be worn on a daily basis. Whether you choose one of the colorful enamel rings or a pair of blingy hoop earrings, you’re all but guaranteed to find a piece that feels special (while still being totally affordable). Start with the necklace.
Shipping Policy: Free shipping on all orders.
Return Policy: Returns accepted within 15 days.
Standout reviews: “What a beauty! Shines bright like a diamond! The length is perfect to wear it high or low, The design is gorgeous and simple but elegant. I get so many compliments on how it sparkles. It looks legit expensive but its totally affordable. Get yours!”
Jennifer Behr
Lyla Earrings
If you want jewelry that will truly make a statement, look no further than Jennifer Behr’s range. While the brand became popular thanks to the success of its selection of gilded hair accessories, it now offers a complete range of stunning jewelry, too. The brand even designs a beautiful range of bridal accessories if you’re shopping for the perfect pieces to wear on your big day!
Shipping Policy: Free shipping on orders over $150
Return Policy: Returns accepted within 21 days.
Standout reviews: none
Stephanie Gottlieb
Diamond Bezel Chain Ring
I love to check Stephanie Gottlieb’s site to dream about my future engagement ring and gaze at the fun collection of fashion jewelry. Whether your price range is below $250 or all the way up to six figures, Stephanie Gottlieb will have something blingy that you’ll love.
Shipping Policy: Free shipping on orders over $500
Return Policy: Returns accepted for free for store credit/exchange within 7 days.
Standout reviews: none
Fred Meyer Jewelers
Puff Star Bead Chain 7.25″ Bracelet in 14K Yellow Gold
On Sale 50% off
Our mission at STYLECASTER is to bring style to the people, and we only feature products we think you’ll love as much as we do. Fred Meyer Jewelers is a STYLECASTER sponsor, however, all products in this article were independently selected by our editors. Please note that if you purchase something by clicking on a link within this story, we may receive a small commission of the sale.
Fred Meyer Jewelers has over 120 retail stores nation wide and you can just as easily shop its selection online with web-exclusives like this puff star chain bracelet that’s made of 14k yellow gold. The puff star detail puts a unique spin on the design and even comes with a lifetime guarantee. Fred Meyer is known for carrying designer brands like Effy Jewelry and Truly Zac Posen, while also carrying its stunning in-house designs. Take advantage of Fred Meyer Jewelers’ Black Friday sale, which runs through November 26.
Shipping Policy: Free two-day shipping
Return Policy: Free returns within 60 days of purchase.
Standout reviews: none (the site doesn’t have shopper reviews)
Daisy London
Mother of Pearl Necklace
If you don’t want to buy yet another gold chain necklace for your collection, consider checking out Daisy London. The brand incorporates stones like Mother of Pearl into its range to create glimmering necklaces, earrings and more that will stand the test of time. Daisy London even sells necklace layering kits that make the styling process feel super effortless.
Shipping Policy: $15 or free for orders over $180
Return Policy: Returns accepted for free for store credit/exchange.
Standout reviews: “Absolutely gorgeous, and packaged so beautifully too. A really special gift.”
Diamond Nexus
Heart Cut Petite Ring
On Sale 8% off
Marry yourself with this iconic petite heart-shaped diamond ring. Heart-shaped engagement rings were a massive trend a few years ago (remember Lady Gaga’s stunner?), and now they’re back in style, but modernized with the petite version that you can wear on any finger to show how much you love yourself on any given day. This ring gets its affordable price point thanks to the fact that it uses lab-grown diamonds
Shipping Policy: $15 or free for orders over $180
Return Policy: Returns accepted for free for store credit/exchange.
Standout reviews: site does not appear to post reviews.
Pamela Love
Dagger Earrings
New York-based brand Pamela Love makes stunning bracelets, earrings and necklaces that are classic and just a little bit unexpected. The prices vary, but they offer a few different types of jewelry including both on-trend fashion options and fine pieces for a little more coin. The brand’s pieces are often plated in 14k gold, which gives the look and feel of real gold but at a more affordable price.
Shipping Policy: Free standard shipping on all domestic orders.
Return Policy: Returns accepted for free for store credit/exchange.
Standout reviews: None
Frasier Sterling
Amalfi Baroque Pearl Necklace in Baby Pink
Frasier Sterling is your one-stop shop for any super-trendy jewelry you could possibly need. Candy name necklaces, customizable everything and so much color are just a few of the fun things you’ll see when you visit the site. Plus, Hailey Bieber, Justin Bieber and Bella Hadid are fans of the brand. This combination pearl and bead necklace is giving modern-day Bridgerton vibes.
Shipping Policy: Free shipping on orders $100+
Return Policy: Returns/exchanges within 30 days of ordering.
Standout reviews: “I love my necklace! It’s a very cute addition to a dressed up or casual outfit! It’s very pretty and dainty.”
BaubleBar
Mini Alidia Cubic Zirconia Ring
Come to BaubleBar for the bright pieces, stay for the selection of fine earrings, rings and much more. Most of their pieces are available for under 100 bucks but look like they should be way more expensive. From dazzling rings to blingy bracelets, this site has all of your bases covered. You might want to check out the rings Jennifer Aniston recently wore on The Ellen DeGeneres Show, especially the Mini Alidia Cubic Zirconia Ring.
Shipping Policy: Free shipping on orders $75+
Return Policy: This item/sale items are final sale.
Standout reviews: no reviews
Kendra Scott
Ari Silver Pave Crystal Heart Necklace
Kendra Scott designs feminine and sweet pieces for you to wear every single day without fail. They’ve become famous online for their selection of affordable and trendy fashion jewelry, but have since expanded into more delicate fine styles, too—you know, the kind that features real gold and actual diamonds.
Shipping Policy: $4.95 ground shipping
Return Policy: Unworn, non-engraved, non-personalized items are eligible for free returns within 30 days of purchase.
Standout reviews: “I bought this necklace and earring set and the Haven Gold Crystal bracelet matches it well! Necklace is sparkly and dainty. Very versatile- can wear it to work as well as after hours events and it goes with everything!”
Astrid & Miyu
Elemental Huggies
Astrid & Miyu was founded in 2012 by Connie Nam. Nam was born in Seoul, Korea, and was inspired by all of the different jewelers and pieces she encountered in her travels. Today the brand boasts a stunning range of huggie earrings, necklaces, anklets and more. Consider this your perfect brand if you love easy-to-style pieces that feel timeless season after season. Even better, most of the items are priced under $100!
Shipping Policy: Free shipping on orders over $100.
Return Policy: Returns and exchanges offered for items purchased within 28 days.
Standout reviews: “Perfect fit and style the detail is super cute. Will definitely be ordering more jewelry from Astrid and Miyu.”
Joey Baby
Sakura Necklace
If you’re sick of the same old gold and silver necklaces season after season, you need to check out NYC-based brand Joey Baby. Its selection of beaded necklaces, earrings and more is seriously to die for because all of the pieces have a DIY feel while still looking totally elevated. Plus, the line is mega affordable to boot—most pieces are priced at under $100 bucks.
Shipping Policy: Free shipping on orders over $35.
Return Policy: Hassle-free 30-day returns
Standout reviews: “Such a cute necklace and survived the summer with me in the sun and in the ocean! Didn’t tarnish at all.”
Aureum Collective
Thea Chain Necklace
Aureum Collective was founded by mega-influencer Cass Dimicco, so it’s safe to say that it knows a thing or two about designing Instagram-worthy pieces. While the entire site is chock-full of stunning options, the chunky chain necklaces are some of the brand’s best-selling items. Yes, the pieces can be a little up there in price, but everything is plated in 24k gold or silver, so it’s well worth the investment.
Shipping Policy: Free shipping on orders over $200.
Return Policy: Store credit offered for returns made within 30 days of order.
Standout reviews: none
John Hardy
John Hardy Carved Chain Small Oval Hoop Earring
John Hardy is a luxury jewelry brand that creates sustainable pieces handcrafted by Bali-based artisans through a process that honors heritage and community. Woven and carved chains are part of the John Hardy signature look and make for elevated everyday pieces. The brand also has a birthstone collection which is perfect for a thoughtful, high-quality gift.
Shipping Policy: Free shipping on orders over $2,000.
Return Policy: Full returns offered for returns made within 30 days of order.
Standout reviews: none
Best of StyleCaster
