Hamas war splits Israel's cabinet as defense minister balks at running Gaza

JERUSALEM − Israeli government splits over the war in Gaza broke open this week after the defense minister demanded a clear strategy from Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu as troops returned to battle Hamas fighters in areas the army had fought in months ago.

The comments from Defense Minister Yoav Gallant, who said he would not agree to setting up a military government in the Palestinian enclave, reflect growing unease in the security establishment at the lack of direction from Netanyahu over who will be left to run Gaza when the fighting stops.

They also brought out the sharp split between the two centrist former army generals in the cabinet, Benny Gantz and Gadi Eisenkot, who both backed Gallant's call, and the hard right nationalist religious parties led by Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich and Internal Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir, who condemned the comments.

More: U.S. military begins Gaza Strip aid deliveries from floating pier

"That's no way to run a war," the right-wing Israel Today tabloid headlined its Thursday edition over a photo of Netanyahu and Gallant facing in different directions.

Apart from dismantling Hamas and returning 130 hostages still held by the Islamist militant movement, Netanyahu has not articulated any clear strategic goal for the end of the campaign, which, according to the Hamas-run Gaza health ministry, has killed some 35,000 Palestinians and left Israel increasingly isolated.

More: Furious Israel ambassador shreds UN charter before vote on Palestine membership

However, backed by Ben-Gvir and Smotrich, both close to the West Bank settler movement, Netanyahu has rejected any role in running postwar Gaza by the Palestinian Authority, set up under the Oslo interim peace accords three decades ago and generally seen internationally as the most legitimate Palestinian governing body.

Netanyahu, struggling to hold his fractious coalition together, has so far stuck to his pledge of total victory over Hamas. Afterwards, Gaza could be run by a "non-Hamas civilian administration with an Israeli military responsibility, overall military responsibility", he told CNBC Wednesday.

More: President Biden sanctions West Bank settlers in a rebuke of Israeli violence

Israeli officials have said that Palestinian clan leaders or others may be recruited to fill the void but there has been no evidence that any such leaders have been identified and no friendly Arab countries have stepped forward to help.

"From Israel the options are either they end the war, and they withdraw, or they establish for all intents and purposes a military government there, and they control the entire territory for who knows how long, because once they leave an area, Hamas will reappear," said Yossi Mekelberg, an associate fellow with the Middle East and North Africa Programme at Chatham House.

Guerilla tactics

Gallant's refusal to contemplate any form of permanent military government reflects the costs of an operation that could stretch Israel's military and the economy, reviving memories of Israel's years-long occupation of southern Lebanon after a costly 1982 war.

Yedioth Ahronoth, Israel's biggest circulation newspaper, quoted a confidential assessment from the defense establishment on Friday that estimated the cost of maintaining a military government in the Gaza Strip at about 20 billion shekels, or $5.43 billion, a year − in addition to the costs of reconstruction. The additional troop requirements would draw forces away from the northern border with Lebanon as well as central Israel and mean a sharp increase in reserve duty requirements, it said.

More: Will US sanction Israeli battalion? Netanyahu will 'fight it with all my strength'

Taking full control of Gaza would require at least four divisions, or around 50,000 troops, said Michael Milshtein, a former intelligence officer and one of Israel's leading specialists on Hamas.

While thousands of Hamas fighters have been killed in the campaign and Israeli commanders say most of the movement's organised battalions have been broken down, smaller groups have popped up in areas the army left in the early stages of the war.

The likely cost to Israel of a prolonged insurgency was illustrated on Wednesday, when five Israeli soldiers were killed by an Israeli tank in "friendly fire" as Israeli troops fought in the Jabalia area north of Gaza City, where the army said in January that it had dismantled Hamas' military framework after weeks of fighting.

At the time, it said militants were still present in Jabalia but they were operating "without a framework and without commanders."

More: 30,000-plus lives lost: Visualizing the death and destruction of Israel's war in Gaza

On Friday, the army said it was conducting a "divisional level" offensive in Jabalia, where troops were fighting in the urban centre. It said forces had killed more than 60 fighters and had found dozens of long-range rockets.

Israel's military spokesman, Rear Admiral Daniel Hagari, said the military's job was to "break down those places where Hamas is returning and trying to reassemble itself." He said any question of an alternative government to Hamas would be a political decision.

Although most surveys show Israelis still broadly back the war, that support has been slipping, with more and more prioritising a return of the hostages over destroying Hamas.

A taste of the broader social divisions likely to be unleashed has been seen in the long-running dispute over conscripting ultra-Orthodox Torah students into the military, a move backed by Gantz and his allies as well as by many secular Israelis but fiercely resisted by the religious parties.

Netanyahu has so far managed to avoid a walk-out by either side that could potentially bring his government down.

But Gallant, who led a revolt against Netanyahu from within the cabinet over plans to cut the power of judges last year, has clashed repeatedly with Smotrich and Ben-Gvir and his latest challenge to the prime minister may not be his last.

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Gaza war splits Israel's cabinet as defense minister defies Netanyahu