Trump's Onstage Lurking Creeped People Out During Second Debate
The second presidential debate on Sunday, Oct. 9, between Republican nominee Donald Trump and Democratic nominee and former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton featured a town hall-style format in which both candidates could sit on high-back stools, surrounded by a circle of undecided voters who were there to pose questions to them.
While a more formal debate positions the candidates behind a podium or a desk, the town hall format puts candidates in the occasionally awkward position of having to assume a casual pose during a serious event.
On Sunday night, as many on the Internet pointed out, this resulted in Trump assuming a somewhat menacing and threatening pose.
Trump standing behind Mrs. Clintons in her space creeps me out. #debate
— Maria Shriver (@mariashriver) October 10, 2016
Trump standing behind Hillary is the creepiest moment of the debate so far #Debate pic.twitter.com/eNIQqdJnmC
— [J]ayJChillin (@JayJazzi) October 10, 2016
Trump was on his feet from the beginning, frequently pacing the stage behind his opponent as she spoke. Clinton, on the other hand, usually took a seat after she had finished speaking.
When asked about Trump’s onstage pacing by a reporter while boarding her plane after the debate, Clinton commented that “he was very present.”
Some found (dark) humor in Trump’s body language, quickly launching widely shared Internet memes.
You’ve met this clown before.
#LockerRoomTalkIn5Words pic.twitter.com/n2qALLORsQ— Vanessa Contessa (@DailyContessa) October 10, 2016
— BuzzFeed (@BuzzFeed) October 10, 2016
Scary Halloween costume idea: Dress up like Trump, go to a party, and stand 3-5 feet behind successful women. pic.twitter.com/tz6STpkccQ
— erin chack (@ErinChack) October 10, 2016
Many others pointed out that Trump’s stance was a classic way to convey intimidation.
Trump standing this close to Clinton while she talks is a man’s FAVORITE intimidation tactic and my god I am uncomfortable #debate
— Zach Stafford (@ZachStafford) October 10, 2016
#TRUMP, we saw you try to physically intimidate #Hillary…by standing/looming over her! You are a sexist ????????@realDonaldTrump #debate
— CoffieHouse Graphics (@chgraphics) October 10, 2016
Trump trying to intimidate Hillary by standing behind her while she’s answering a citizen is disgusting. Truly a bully. #debates
— michael brown (@boyinquestion) October 10, 2016
This is surreal. HRC breaking down health care issues in detail & Trump wandering around and menacing her by standing behind her
— Steve Phillips (@StevePtweets) October 10, 2016
And experts agreed.
“His body language spoke so clearly,” Susan Krauss Whitbourne, PhD, a professor of psychology at the University of Massachusetts at Amherst who has written on the psychology of body language, tells Yahoo Beauty. “This bullying stance and sniffling — that’s his telltale sign, definitely, the sniffles. It’s all bullying. The hulking, the glaring — he’s expressing the bullying overtly. It’s not even hidden.”
Krauss Whitbourne muses that such unbridled physical aggression might also reflect Trump’s now notorious inability to regulate what he says and does.
“One wonder how much of this is staged and how much of this is his ability to filter,” she says. “He’s leaking this communication all over the place. Is it intentional? Is it unintentional? Either way, the effect on viewers and the audience and Hillary — I assume — is: ‘I’m going to rough you up unless you’re careful.‘”
After the leak of the 2005 Access Hollywood tape in which Trump describes sexually assaulting women, and after his campaign’s pre-debate press event with women who have accused former President Bill Clinton of rape and unwanted sexual advances, his body language, some noted, read as as almost predatory.
A couple of times I’ve actually feared for Hillary’s physical safety based on Trump’s expression while standing behind her. #debate
— Rebecca Carroll (@rebel19) October 10, 2016
why is trump standing right behind her like that, his body language reminds me of every abuser i’ve ever encountered. #debate
— Elizabeth Plank (@feministabulous) October 10, 2016
No joke, if I saw a man standing behind a woman like Trump is hovering over HRC, I’d offer to walk her home. #debate
— Elie Mystal (@ElieNYC) October 10, 2016
.@NicolleDWallace just said it: if that was me on the street & a guy was standing behind me like #Trump behind Clinton I’d be dialing 911.
— (((CAT))) (@OneCopaceticCAT) October 10, 2016
Krauss Whitbourne also adds that Trump on Sunday night conveyed the impression of someone “backed into a corner, fighting, in the ring, saying, ‘I’m going to use my body to overpower you.'”
This expression of aggression, she says, comes not from a place of strength, but perhaps from the opposite.
“Underneath it all, it’s a basic sense of insecurity. If someone has to overstate this in their body language, you have to wonder why. Is he 5 and he’s on the playground, and has to show this harassing aggression?” Krauss Whitbourne asks.
Why so many viewers of last night’s debate feel such a visceral response to Trump’s body language?
“He got himself in the camera right around Hillary, right behind Hillary,” Krauss Whitbourne explains. “She’s small, he’s large. We identify with the victim, and she looked like the victim, even though she didn’t act like one. We, in her place, would feel victimized. We’ve all been there. We’ve all been targeted by bullies at some point in our lives, and that’s the primal element this brings out.”
Let’s keep in touch! Follow Yahoo Beauty on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and Pinterest.