Everyone Is Always So Shocked I Got This Fancy Cafe Chair Dupe for $130

West Elm Mella sofa in sitting room.
Credit: Margaret Rose Larson Credit: Margaret Rose Larson

There’s a small nook in my New York City apartment’s living room that’s big enough for a small round dining table, and it’s so nice to have somewhere to sit to eat that isn’t my sofa. In the fall, I worked with an upholsterer to create a beautiful custom dining bench that’s the star of this little corner in my home. However, I wanted to purchase some additional extra seating, too, so that things wouldn’t be too cramped when I have guests — usually just one person at a time — over for dinner or drinks.

Modway Eon Natural Elm Wood Kitchen and Dining Room Chair
Modway Eon Natural Elm Wood Kitchen and Dining Room Chair

Modway Eon Natural Elm Wood Kitchen and Dining Room Chair

$130.10 (was $174) at Amazon

The solution? A single black bistro-style chair that I found on Amazon. Designed to look like a vintage Viennese coffeehouse chair, it doesn’t have the hefty price tag associated with an authentic designer piece. Originals cost around $500, but this version only set me back $130. For that price, you’re not really sacrificing quality either, since it’s 100% solid elm wood and fairly sturdy.

Aside from the price, I chose this chair because I wanted something relatively compact (my floor space is limited), and I was drawn to its simple design with its elegantly curved backrest and vintage look. I knew it wouldn’t upstage the House of Hackney fabric I splurged on for my dining bench, particularly if I bought the black colorway. I find that the dark finish really goes with everything and doesn’t lean into any aesthetic. It could work equally well in an old-world European-inspired space or a more modern boho home. If you’re not into this color, though, you can choose one of the other two options, two natural-looking stains (note: Only the walnut is in stock right now).

Modway Eon Natural Elm Dining Room Chair at bistro table with small settee
Credit: Sarah Lyon Credit: Sarah Lyon

The piece is comfortable for sitting and has held up quite well over the past couple of months — it really has made it so much easier to host. And when I have large get-togethers in the “gathering” area of my living room by the sofa, the chair is usable then too. At just 8 pounds, it’s easy to pick up and move throughout my space as needed, which is a major perk.

Apartment living can be challenging. So many pieces that seem pretty and stylish are actually quite large in scale and would stick out like a sore thumb in a small space (or even worse, not be able to fit through the door in the first place!). A chair like this one is a safe bet for a small room but would shine in multiples in a larger space, too, if you wanted to outfit an entire dining or breakfast table with them. That makes this design a true winner in my book.