Tax Preparer vs. CPA: Everything You Need to Know
AI was used in the creation of this article. The article was reviewed, fact-checked and edited by a content review team. We might earn a commission if you make a purchase through one of the links. McClatchy newsrooms were not involved in the creation of this content.
In the evolving landscape of finance and taxation, making an informed decision between pursuing a career as a Certified Public Accountant (CPA) or a tax preparer is crucial for aspiring professionals. But how do these professional opportunities stack up against each other?
The Bureau of Labor Statistics projects a steady 4% growth for accountants and CPAs from 2022 to 2032, signaling a consistent demand in the coming decade. On the other hand, tax preparers are expected to see an average growth rate of 2% to 4% in the same period, suggesting a stable demand within the financial and taxation fields.
So, let’s explore each career path’s unique advantages, challenges, and potential. Whether you’re drawn to a CPA’s comprehensive financial expertise or a tax preparer’s specialized focus, understanding these dynamics is key to forging a path that aligns with your professional aspirations and goals.
Key Takeaways
Scope of Work: Tax preparers file tax returns and ensure compliance with tax laws. CPAs offer wider services, including auditing, financial planning, and business consulting.
Certification and Education: Tax preparers may earn certifications like the IRS Annual Filing Season Program or become enrolled agents. CPAs require a bachelor’s degree, 150 hours of education, passing the CPA exam, and meeting work experience requirements.
Client Representation: Both enrolled agents and CPAs can represent clients before the IRS, but only CPAs can audit financial statements and provide assurance services.
Career Opportunities: Tax preparers see seasonal work peaks, mainly during tax season. CPAs have year-round opportunities across various sectors, including public accounting and corporate finance.
Salary Potential: Tax preparers average $55,000 annually, with potential increases close to $100,000. CPAs average around $76,000, with mid-career professionals earning about $123,000 and senior roles exceeding $200,000.
What is a Tax Preparer?
A tax preparer is a tax professional specializing in preparing and filing tax returns for individuals and businesses. They ensure that clients comply with the tax code while working to optimize tax outcomes. Tax preparers must stay updated on the latest tax laws and regulations to provide accurate and effective service.
Key Attributes of a Tax Preparer
Tax Law and Preparation Expertise: Proficient in navigating the tax code and preparing various types of tax returns.
Certification: Many are certified through programs like the IRS Annual Filing Season Program or have obtained the EA designation, showcasing their commitment to professionalism in tax preparation.
Client Representation: An EA serves as a licensed tax preparer and can represent clients before the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) for audits, collections, and appeals, offering a significant level of service during tax disputes.
What is a Certified Public Accountant?
Certified Public Accountants represent the pinnacle of the accounting profession, with a broad knowledge base in accounting, tax, and financial planning. They are recognized for their expertise in auditing, tax preparation, and strategic advisory services, making them invaluable assets to their clients and employers.
Key Attributes of a Certified Public Accountant
Comprehensive Financial Expertise: Beyond tax preparation, CPAs provide auditing, financial planning, and business consulting services.
Auditing and Assurance: Unique authority to audit financial statements, ensuring compliance and accuracy in financial reporting.
Rigorous Certification Process: This involves completing a bachelor’s degree, 150 hours of education, passing the CPA exam, and fulfilling state-specific experience requirements.
Tax Preparer vs. CPA: Career Path Options
For Tax Preparers
Seasonal Tax Preparation: Specialize in helping individuals and businesses prepare tax returns during the primary tax season, with the potential for extended services for late filers or amendments.
Tax Consultancy: Provide advice on tax-saving strategies and planning for individuals and small businesses, focusing on optimizing tax outcomes.
Representation Services: As an enrolled agent, a professional can represent clients in disputes with the IRS, including audits, appeals, and collections.
For CPAs
Public Accounting: Work in audit, tax, and consulting services within public accounting firms, serving a diverse clientele from various industries.
Corporate Finance: Hold positions such as Controller, Chief Financial Officer (CFO), or finance manager within corporate entities, overseeing financial operations and strategic planning.
Government and Non-Profit Organizations: Serve in governmental agencies or non-profits, focusing on financial management, compliance, and reporting.
Independent Consulting: Establish a consultancy offering expertise in financial planning, business strategy, and tax planning for businesses and high-net-worth individuals.
Specialized Accounting Services: Focus on niche areas like forensic accounting, environmental accounting, or international tax, catering to specific market needs.
CPA vs. Tax Preparer Salary Comparison
When considering a career as a CPA and a tax preparer, understanding the potential earnings for tax preparers and CPAs can guide your decision. Although I considered doing tax prep work and even becoming an EA, the numbers persuaded me otherwise.
Here’s a breakdown of the salary expectations for each profession based on national estimates and industry data.
Tax Preparer Salaries
According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, most tax preparers earn an hourly wage of $26.85, up to $46.45. This translates to a mean annual salary of $55,000, with a higher salary range up to $96,000, with the lowest salaries at $27,000. The relatively low Employment RSE (Relative Standard Error) of 3.3% and Wage RSE of 1.4% indicate that these figures are consistent across the board for tax preparers in various locations and employment settings.
CPA Salaries
For those just beginning their careers as CPAs, the starting total compensation averages around $59,000. As they progress in their careers, CPAs can expect to earn an average salary of $76,000 per year, with salaries typically ranging between $54,000 and $123,000. For those who reach executive levels with extensive experience, earnings can soar to over $200,000 annually, reflecting the high earning potential within this profession.
Additionally, the level of expertise, specialization in high-demand areas, geographic location, and the size of their organization can significantly influence tax preparer and CPA salaries.
Insights from Accounting Professionals
Transitioning from CPA to a specialization in tax involves strategic planning and a commitment to continuous learning and professional development. Here’s a blend of advice, direct quotes, and summaries from finance professionals on navigating this path effectively.
Gain Real-World Experience: “Go start working at a public accounting firm,” suggests a user from r/taxpros, highlighting the importance of practical experience in a professional setting. Public accounting firms, especially those offering comprehensive tax services, provide an invaluable learning ground for CPAs aspiring to specialize in tax.
Volunteer for Tax Preparation Programs: Engaging in volunteer programs like VITA (Volunteer Income Tax Assistance) can offer hands-on experience in preparing tax returns. Although challenges may arise for those not based in the U.S., such as needing a U.S. mobile number for registration, the practical experience gained is invaluable.
Work in Smaller CPA Firms: Find a CPA firm on the smaller side where you’ll see a wide range of different things,” advises another user. Smaller firms often provide a broader scope of experiences and responsibilities, accelerating the learning process in tax preparation and planning.
Consider Becoming an Enrolled Agent (EA): For CPAs aiming to deepen their expertise in tax, obtaining the EA designation is a strategic move. “You can become an enrolled agent by taking the EA exam... Will be a big booster if you want to join US tax,” shares a user. The EA status enhances a CPA’s credentials and expands their representation rights before the IRS.
Conclusion
Deciding whether to pursue a career as a tax preparer or a CPA depends on your professional aspirations, desired level of education, and the type of impact you want to make in the financial world. If you are passionate about tax law and enjoy the detailed work of tax preparation, becoming a tax preparer or an EA might be the right path. If you seek a broader role in finance, wish to provide a wide range of accounting and tax services, and are prepared to undertake the necessary education and certification, then becoming a CPA could offer a fulfilling and lucrative career.
FAQs
What’s the primary difference between a tax preparer and a CPA?
The primary difference lies in their scope of work and qualifications. Tax preparers specialize in preparing and filing tax returns for individuals and businesses, focusing mainly on compliance with tax laws. CPAs have a broader range of expertise, including tax preparation, auditing financial statements, financial planning, and providing business advice. CPAs are required to have a bachelor’s degree, complete 150 hours of education, pass the CPA exam, and meet experience requirements.
Can tax preparers represent clients before the IRS?
Yes, but with limitations. Enrolled agents, whom the federal government licenses, can represent clients before the IRS for audits, collections, and appeals. Other tax preparers, especially those certified through the IRS Annual Filing Season Program, have limited representation rights, primarily for returns they have prepared and signed.
Do I need a CPA for my taxes, or can a tax preparer suffice?
It depends on your tax situation. A qualified tax preparer can suffice for most individuals with straightforward tax returns. However, a CPA might be more suitable if you have complex tax issues, own a business, or need specialized tax planning and financial advice due to their extensive training and a broader range of services.
How do I become a CPA or tax preparer?
To become a CPA, you must obtain a bachelor’s degree in accounting or a related field, complete 150 semester hours of education, pass the Uniform CPA Examination, and fulfill state-specific experience requirements. Requirements can vary to become a tax preparer. However, becoming an enrolled agent involves passing the IRS Special Enrollment Examination. Other tax preparers may obtain certification through various programs, including the IRS Annual Filing Season Program, which requires completing continuing education hours.
Which career path offers better salary and advancement opportunities, tax preparer or CPA?
Generally, CPAs have higher earning potential and broader career advancement opportunities due to their extensive education, certification, and the wide array of services they can offer. CPAs can hold high-level public accounting, corporate finance, and consultancy positions. Tax preparers, particularly EAs, also have good prospects, especially if they specialize or run their tax preparation businesses. Salary and advancement can vary based on location, experience, specialization, and the individual’s business acumen.
