Why Guilt Is an Unexpected Aspect of Caregiving

Elizabeth Yuko

Click here to read the full article.

The following essay was written in Fall 2018. 

When you first get the call letting you know that a loved one is ill, a million things go racing through your mind: What’s the prognosis? Should I drop everything and go to them right away? What will the treatment plan look like?

More from SheKnows

That was certainly true earlier this year when I found out my mother had leukemia. Immediately, I began to reshape my life around her diagnosis — taking trips from New York City to her home in Cleveland, reading as much as I could about the condition and getting to know her team of medical professionals. I always knew caregiving — especially from a distance — was going to be a challenge. But what I didn’t anticipate was the guilt that came along with it.

And no, I’m not referring to anyone in my family making me feel guilty that I don’t live in Cleveland and have the ability to be a local caregiver. I’m talking about the guilt that pops up every day when I’m doing seemingly normal things.

The feeling is two-fold. First, there’s the guilt I feel because my mother is sick and I’m not. If I’m enjoying myself somewhere, she’s back in Ohio probably not feeling very well. And there’s another layer specific to our situation: When I was 7 years old, I had a blood disorder that for all intents and purposes looked like leukemia but wasn’t a form of cancer. I recovered in a few months. My mother, on the other hand, also ended up with a blood disorder, but hers is cancer. I know this is nothing either of us can control, but it’s hard to wrap my head around.

Then there’s the guilt that comes from spending time or money doing something other than caring for her. To be clear, since her diagnosis, my mother has stressed that she wants me to do the things I’d normally do — including taking several trips I had planned before she got sick. In fact, when I mentioned the possibility of canceling them, she firmly told me she wanted me to go and would be upset with me if I didn’t. But despite having her blessing, I still felt guilty going on a vacation and spending my time away from work and New York doing something other than helping her.

The same thing goes for spending money. Any time I’m out to dinner with friends or doing any other sort of leisure activity, I’m constantly second-guessing my decision and thinking I should have probably saved the money for my next flight to Cleveland or to cover some of the mounting medical costs.

Given that I work in the health and wellness space, I’m very familiar with the concept and importance of self-care. I know that if we don’t care for ourselves, it makes caring for others much harder — but knowing this doesn’t make the guilt go away.

Why the guilt?

To understand how guilt plays a role in caregiving and get some tips for how to deal with it, I spoke with Karen Whitehead, a social worker specializing in helping overwhelmed and anxious adults and caregivers.

“Guilt can come into play with caregivers in many ways,” she tells SheKnows. “Caregivers may feel guilty that they’re not doing enough for their loved one or they may feel guilty that they make a choice to prioritize themselves or other family or friends.”

Generally, feelings of guilt implies that someone has intentionally done something wrong, Whitehead explains, but in a caregiving scenario when you’re spending time and energy helping another person, it may be hard to pinpoint why you feel like you’ve done something wrong.

“In caregiving, often what’s been done wrong is the caregiver has violated his/her own expectation of how he/she thinks things should be — what ‘should’ be done,” she says.

In other words, caregivers feel guilty because they think they should be doing more, but Whitehead points out that this “should” is often an opinion rather than the fact of the situation. “Most people who are being cared for want their family member or friend to have a life and take care of themselves,” she adds.

It’s also important to realize this guilt isn’t always a negative thing; in fact, Whitehead says it can be a motivator too, prompting us to be more engaged in caregiving than you might otherwise be. The downside of this, she notes, is that, unfortunately, when guilt is the motivator, it can often lead to resentment.

What are some ways to combat guilt?

Speaking from my own experience, juggling everything is hard enough without having to deal with the guilt, so I was eager to get some tips for how to work through it.

Whitehead says that to combat guilt, we should recognize we may be trying to achieve perfection or the unavailable option of “doing it all,” which just isn’t realistic.

“If you as the caregiver are burned out or trying to do it all, how much good can you do taking care of Mom or Dad?” she says. “Taking care of yourself will give you more energy to take care of and prioritize the tasks in your life.”

It’s also important to bear in mind that self-care means more than sleeping well, exercising or getting a massage every once in a while. It’s about finding a balance by nourishing yourself, not only physically, but emotionally, intellectually, socially and spiritually. That could mean going out with friends, attending a work function or making a choice to honor your own needs will help you sustain caregiving longer.

“Instead of saying, ‘I feel guilty,’ try ‘I regret…,’” Whitehead suggests. “’I regret that I can’t come see you today,’ rather than ‘I feel guilty I can’t come see you today.’ Regret acknowledges the sadness caregivers feel when they realize they can’t do it all.”

Honestly, she’s right. A lot of the guilt I feel is really sadness that I can’t do it all. It’s just easier to attach those feelings to something more tangible, like taking a vacation or going to a show, than coming to terms with the fact that it’s hard to do stuff for both my mother and myself. At this point, I’m not sure if that will alleviate these feelings, but at least it’s a start.

A version of this story was published October 2018.

Self-care is super important for caregivers. Here’s a few small, under $50 self-care gifts we’d recommend sending to the caregiver in your life to let them know you appreciate them: 

Launch Gallery: 24 Under-$50 Self-Care Gifts You'll Want to Keep for Yourself

Best of SheKnows

Sign up for SheKnows' Newsletter. For the latest news, follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.

More From

  • Are Any Schools Reopening Safely? Here Are the Facts & the Unknowns

    Making the decision to send your children back to school in August or September is starting to feel like the most complicated choice parents have ever made for their kids. As we watch the bad news pour in from the first districts to try reopening, the debate rages on in households, state capitals, school district […]

  • EXCLUSIVE: Rosie Huntington-Whiteley's Lifeline Is Her #MomSquad & It Includes Kylie Jenner

    Rosie Huntington-Whiteley is many things: an actress, an entrepreneur, a makeup obsessive, a former Victoria's Secret model. But when she's around a fellow mom like Kylie Jenner, she immediately melts down to the role that consumes her mind most these days: mom to 3-year-old Jack, the son she shares with fiancé Jason Statham. Huntington-Whiteley chatted […]

  • Kristen Wiig Has One Regret About Going Through IVF & Surrogacy

    When we hear about celebrities like Kristen Wiig having their babies through surrogacy in secret, sometimes our minds go to an uncharitable place: Here are women who can have it all because of their fame and money. That, of course, is not the real story with most parents. And as Kristen Wiig herself revealed in […]

  • Pink's 9-Year-Old Daughter Willow Is Mom's Lookalike in This Sweet New Picture

    Lookalike alert! Pink's Instagram is one of our favorite places to go if we want a smile, not just because of the singer's take-no-prisoners attitude, but also for all the adorable content that she shares of her 9-year-old daughter Willow. Pink gets the biggest smile on her face when she's with young Willow, and it's […]