Tyler Hynes Movies: 16 of His Best Hallmark Romances Guaranteed to Steal Your Heart

Tyler Hynes has been leaving his mark on the Hallmark channel since 2018, now acting in over 15 movies since his debut in Falling For You. But before he became known for his romantic leading roles on the network, he was making a name for himself in surprising places.

And with his smoldering good looks and biker-boy charm, it's no surprise that he made our list of Hallmark Hunks! Here, read more about the 37-year-old Toronto native, and the Tyler Hynes Hallmark movies we love.

Tyler Hynes' early career

Hynes' first shot at fame came for him at the age of 8, when he took part in a 72-performance run of A Christmas Carol, playing the role of Tiny Tim. Not long after came the role of 10-year-old Tommy in The Who's rock opera, Tommy, on its Canadian tour.

After Hynes' time on the stage, he began his transition into film and television, his earliest roles being in Little Men, Tales from the Neverending Story, Peter Benchley's Amazon and Tagged: The Jonathan Wamback Story. Before he got his Hallmark start, Hynes acted in numerous episodes of shows such as Valemont, The Firm, Heartland, Saving Hope, 19-2, and UnREAL.

His work with Hallmark

Since 2018, Tyler Hynes has become a fan favorite on Hallmark, one of his most recent movies being A Picture of Her (2023), with another on the way. “Everybody is absolutely lovely. And it seems like comparatively perhaps to other places, I think it's as close as you can come to feeling like a family that is supportive," he told UsWeekly on why he loves working for Hallmark.

“And that just sort of bookends what is an absolutely enormous pleasure, which is the people who watch these movies," Hynes continues. "I can't tell you enough about the human beings who watch these movies and how kind and lovely and wholesome and earnest and authentic they are. And I think it's a very unique place.”

16 Tyler Hynes movies

Here, take a look at his extensive career over the last few years with Hallmark, and the newest Tyler Hynes movies to come!

1. Falling For You (2018)

A local radio station manager (Taylor Cole) ropes in a visiting businessman to participate in a bachelor-bake off in an effort to save her station.

2. It's Christmas, Eve (2018)

LeAnn Rimes stars alongside Tyler Hynes as an interim superintendent who must trim budgets, directly affecting Liam, her handsome neighbor and local music teacher. But with the help of some friends and a little Christmas magic, things might just turn around.

3. Flip That Romance (2019)

Tyler Hynes and Julie Gonzalo play rival house flippers who each owns half a duplex. When a competition begins between the two of them and the editor of Innovation Designs catches wind, the winner is offered a magazine spread — but perhaps their feelings will flip as well.

4. My Boyfriend's Back: Wedding March 5 (2019)

Cindy Busby stars as wedding planner Annalise, who is in charge of a wedding at Mick and Olivia’s inn, only to learn that the best man is her ex.

5. The Mistletoe Secret (2019)

Aria (Kellie Pickler) finally gets a famous travel writer to come do a story on her hometown, but when he arrives, she finds herself torn and falling for both he and his ghostwriter that he brought along with him.

6. Winter in Vail (2020)

Chelsea (Lacey Chabert) inherits a chalet in Vail and when she makes the move, she begins an unlikely love affair with a handsome local.

7. On the 12th Date of Christmas (2020)

Mallory Jansen and Tyler Hynes star as two incompatible game designers who must come together to create a city-wide scavenger hunt.

8. It Was Always You (2021)

The brother of Elizabeth's (Erin Krakow) fiancée arrives home with her engagement party looming, causing her to start questioning what she thought she knew.

9. Sweet Carolina (2021)

When Josie (Lacey Chabert) returns home to become the guardian of her niece and nephew, she reconnects with her ex-boyfriend along the journey.

10. Roadhouse Romance (2021)

Lauren Alaina stars as a country music fan who wants to continue her grandfather's legacy, while TV director Luke teaches her an important lesson.

11. An Unexpected Christmas (2021)

A speech writer and his ex (Bethany Joy Lenz) fake a relationship through the holidays for the sake of his family's Christmas, but the act can only go on for so long.

(Read about our favorite Bethany Joy Lenz movies and TV shows here!)

12. Always Amore (2022)

Elizabeth (Autumn Reeser) must work with a consultant to save her late-husband's restaurant. Apparently

13. Time for Him to Come Home for Christmas (2022)

Elizabeth (Holland Roden) receives a mysterious voicemail four days before Christmas from a man she doesn't know, making one last plea for the love of his life.

14. Three Wise Men and a Baby (2022)

Tyler Hynes teams up with Andrew Walker and Paul Campbell to care for a baby together over the holidays.

(Read about the 23 best Andrew Walker movies here!)

15. A Picture of Her (2023)

Beth (Rhiannon Fish) becomes the subject of an award-winning magazine cover and must discover who it was who snapped the mysterious photo.

Bonus: Never Been Chris'd (2023)

Hynes plays Chris Silver, the high school crush of Naomi (Janel Parrish) and Liz (Pascal Lamothe-Kipnes). The trio find themselves in a complicated love triangle. See the premiere on the Hallmark Channel on November 4, 8/7c, a part of Countdown to Christmas 2023!

(See the lineup here for the Hallmark Countdown to Christmas 2023!)

Fore more Hallmark stories, read below!

Kevin McGarry: Harlequin Romance Cover Model to the Hallmark Leading Man

Peter Mooney: The Handsome New Hallmark Star You Don’t Want to Miss!

Swoon Alert! The Top 14 Ryan Paevey Hallmark Movies You *Must* See

From Hallmark Sweetheart to Special Ops — Get To Know Jill Wagner