All Our Theories on Who the Next Bachelorette Will Be

Gabby Windey and Rachel Recchia’s season of The Bachelorette came to an extremely dramatic close last September, so now it’s time to wildly speculate about who our next Bachelorette will be. Mostly so we can immediately form a prayer circle for them. :)

It’s early days yet (we still have the rest of this season of The Bachelor to get through, not to mention another season of the endless social experiment known as Bachelor in Paradise), but there are some contenders who we think could be on ABC’s radar. Just keep in mind that there's a whole new fleet of aspiring influencers contestants during the upcoming Bachelor season that we’ll be adding to this list also, depending on how that inevitable mess shakes out.

Tayshia Adams (Again)

Tayshia has already been Bachelorette (and pretty recently too), but a lot of fans would love to see her on the show for round two since she really only got a partial season. (Reminder: Clare Crawley quit her season because she fell so hard for Dale Moss, and Tayshia replaced her.) And while, yeah, Tayshia formed a solid relationship with Zac Clark, she didn’t exactly get a fair shot at reality TV love thanks to that abridged season. Plus, Tayshia and Zac have since broken up, and as far as we know, she is single? Maybe? That said, Tayshia told Entertainment Tonight she isn’t exactly down to date within Bachelor Nation again, saying, “I think I’m good, respectfully. Respectfully, I think I’m good. I think I’m good.”

Natasha Parker

Natasha had a lot of fans rooting for her to be Bachelorette after a ton of drama during her Bachelor in Paradise season (you know, when Brendan fully led her on while waiting for Pieper to arrive). And it sounds like she’d be down!

“Dating’s not easy for me. That’s one of the reasons why I went on a dating show, because it’s not easy for me,” she told Entertainment Tonight post-BiP. “If something happened in the future where I was single and I got a call, I would [do it] with bells and whistles.”

Kate Gallivan

Kay, this one is a bit of a wild card lol. Kate Gallivan (who’s from Clayton’s season and a member of the Oppenheim Group from Selling Sunset) was on the latest season of Bachelor in Paradise. And in case ya need a refresher, she and Logan Palmer (who was on Gabby and Rachel's season of The Bachelorette) were one of the final six couples. However, during the final rose ceremony, it seemed as though the bachelor was more confident about the 'ship than she was 👀.

After confessing his feelings, Logan asked for Kate to accept his rose, but she denied and criticized him for targeting her throughout their time on the season, saying, “We've had some unforgettable moments on the beach. But you also told me that I was critical, looked down on you, not warm enough, and stimulated by the drama—when in reality, these are projections that I feel from you.” She then added, “And when Jesse told us earlier to ask ourselves if we were happy or in love...the answer for those questions for me is no...I know what I want and this isn't it. So Logan, no, I will not accept this rose.” Talk about D-R-A-M-A!

Khloé Kardashian

I know, I know. This is a huge long shot that’s likely never going to happen, but fans have been rooting for Khloé to be Bachelorette ever since she and Tristan Thompson split, and honestly, she’d be perfect. Plus, Khloé’s already a reality TV star so...make it happen, Kris Jenner!

Anyway, the next Bachelorette likely won’t be announced until The Bachelor’s final episode (specifically during “After the Final Rose”) all the way through the next few months—so ABC still has a while to make its decision.Anyway! We’ll be updating this list as more potential contenders come to light, so def make sure to check back in.

You Might Also Like

• Here’s What NOT to Wear to a Wedding

• Meet the Laziest, Easiest Acne Routine You’ll Ever Try