Ranking Every Single Sketch From "I Think You Should Leave" Season 2
28.Little Buff Boys Commercial (Season 2, Episode 5)
The commercial for Little Buff Boys has its moments, but ultimately is not the best sketch out of the show's Season 2 run.
27.Detective Crashmore Trailer (Season 2, Episode 3)
The Detective Crashmore trailer is the prelude to the much more interesting interview that follows later in the episode. While not a terrible sketch, it is one of the weaker ones of the season.
26.Little Buff Boys (Season 2, Episode 1)
This is a sequel of sorts to the "Baby of the Year" sketch from Season 1, but does not do it as much justice.
25.Huge Dumps (Season 2, Episode 6)
Huge Dumps is hilarious. The idea that someone would go through all the trouble of hiring someone who looks like their fellow co-worker just so people would talk about them taking "huge dumps" is such a wild and amusing concept.
24.Detective Crashmore Interview (Season 2, Episode 3)
The interview for Detective Crashmore is very interesting with the subtext of Santa Claus being promised that they were not going to "bring up" his other profession that he does year-round. While funny, it does not really live up to the highs that Season 2 has to offer.
23.Carber Vacuum (Season 2, Episode 3)
A sequel to the Hot Dog sketch from earlier in the season. It's funny and gives fans of I Think one of the most memorable lines, even having the title of the episode named after it.
22.Tammy Craps (Season 2, Episode 6)
These next three sketches aren't bad by any means, they just all appear in the same episode and feel very distant from the other episodes, maybe minus "Big Wave." Tammy Craps is a good first watch, but once you know the ending, it kinda loses its touch.
21.Big Wave (Season 2, Episode 6)
Big Wave is your typical office sketch that happens throughout I Think with many of the same beats. It's not the best one out of the season, but it does give some notable highlights, such as Julie giving Russell a gag gift of "Chode Jeans" and her husband being a bit older, not good looking. Julie.
20.Claire's (Season 2, Episode 6)
The Claire's video is a wild trip and is one of the funniest things, especially the fact that the guy sitting in and watching the video is complaining about the video. Just absurd.
19.Credit Card Roulette (Season 2, Episode 5)
Credit Card Roulette is what all me and my friends play when we go to the bars nowadays, because no one wants to be that guy that's "not going to pay for it." It has its moments, and I believe it is one of the more underrated sketches of the season.
18.Space Restaurant (Season 2, Episode 5)
This is a spiritual successor of the "Game Night" episode from Season 1, even starring the same actor Tim Heidecker as another very funny character. It starts off simple with a date and a guy showing concern for his date's sister, while cracking some goofy jokes. Then the sketch hits the fan into overdrive with some of the most out-of-left field comments seen in an episode.
17.Parking Lot (Season 2, Episode 5)
You ever drive behind someone in a parking lot and think "can this person even drive?" Well, Parking Lot shows what happens when the person really doesn't know how to drive. It's a great intro to the episode and really sets the tone for the rest of the sketches.
16.Prank Show (Season 2, Episode 1)
Prank Show is the Impractical Jokers rip of I Think. It starts off tame but immediately turns into the host going through an existential crisis. By far one of the funnier sketches.
15.Shops at the Creek (Season 2, Episode 2)
Dan Flashes' part 2 sketch is quite honestly one of trippiest parts of the show as it just goes further and further into absurdity. As a commercial that devolves into a surreal part of the episode, this is a highlight of the season.
14.Blues Brother (Season 2, Episode 4)
Blues Brother is very different from the rest of the sketches in its absurdity. A guy wants to bring the party back to life by putting on a performance of the Blues Brothers (by himself) and it quickly devolves into madness as dogs are barking, kids are being scared, and a supportive girlfriend is there to watch it unfold.
13.You Can't Skip Lunch (Season 2, Episode 1)
The Hot Dog sketch is one of the funnier ones of the season in that, well, "you can't skip lunch." One man's lunch is more important than any work meeting.
12.Calico Cut Pants (Season 2, Episode 4)
The longest sketch of the season, and the series entirely. This sketch introduces the world to pairs of pants with purposely styled dots on the crotch area, which look, to many, as though they are piss stains. The secret though is that, they really are piss stains. A website, calicocutpants.com, is where you are able to purchase these pants, but, uh-oh, they are all sold out. Coincidence? Absolutely. But you can still help the website out! You just gotta give!
11.The Capital Room (Season 2, Episode 2)
The Shark Tank rip of the season is full of quotable moments. I'll be honest, after watching this sketch, I can't stop drinking wine.
10.Coffin Flop (Season 2, Episode 1)
Absolute absurdity. Pretty crazy that Spectrum would get rid of Corncob TV all because Coffin Flop featured so many dead bodies falling out of coffins. It was only 1-in-5 that were naked, I mean, c'mon!
9.Dan Flashes (Season 2, Episode 2)
One of the pinnacle office sketches of the season, Dan Flashes takes place in a meeting room where Mike (Tim Robinson) has been skipping lunch to save money so that he can purchase Dan Flashes shirts. But it's his exact style!
8.Insider Trading (Season 2, Episode 3)
A corporate scandal? Insider trading? Brian's fedora with safari flaps on the back? This sketch is hilarious. The more the sketch goes into the records of the insider trading allegations, the more we see how Brian's coworkers really feel about him and his stupid hat, oh, and his pair of dice.
7.Classic Cars (Season 2, Episode 2)
Bob Odenkirk makes a guest appearance in one of the most quotable sketches of the series. What starts as a simple way of not taking your daughter to an ice cream store, quickly devolves into a stranger talking about how amazing they are. Triples of the Barracuda, of the Road Runner, oh, and good news, now he's got triples of the Nova.
6.Jamie Taco (Season 2, Episode 4)
I'm serious about supportive women in this show, cause Episode 4 has some of the best examples. At a poker night where men as roasting their wives, one has a flashback to the time his wife helped him when he freaked out about his lines being stolen in a play by one man, Jamie Taco.
5.Johnny Carson Impersonator (Season 2, Episode 5)
Wild. This sketch starts off as one of the more tame ones. A friend brings a gag gift to a birthday party for his friend, a Johnny Carson impersonator from Stable of Stars. Wild. Until Johnny Carson smacks the shit out of one of the partygoers. Tim Robinson's character rushes in, out of breath, to deliver the iconic line "he can hit!" and "why?" you may be asking. Well, it's because they got the "low-low" price point.
4.I Should've Got That (Season 2, Episode 3)
What more can be said? Dylan's burger looked good! As three students reconnect with their professor, Professor Yurabay, he has other ideas in mind as Dylan's burger is all he wants. Quotable, absurd, hilarious, this is the best sketch of Episode 3.
3.Ghost Tour (Season 2, Episode 1)
The first episode ends with one of the least obscure ideas for a sketch, an adult haunted house tour. But what starts off as an inconspicuous idea quickly turns into one adult having too much fun and misunderstanding the rules.
2.Driver's Ed (Season 2, Episode 6)
TABLES! What does she do? TABLES! Eddie Munster, Freddy Kreuger, all of these people are just using this woman's tables with little care, do they not understand that those tables are like her corn?!
1.Sloppy Steaks (Season 2, Episode 2)
This is the peak for Season 2, in my friends and I's opinion and a great way to end the Episode 2, although, this should've been the ending musical number for the season. "I used to be a piece of shit" has become one of the most quotable lines from the series as a whole and the "Dangerous Nights" song is stuck on repeat in my head.
