Rachael Ray's Rumor-Filled Marriage Is Juicy

The two met at a mutual friend's party, and when Cusimano (frontman of rock band The Cringe) told Ray about his cooking skills, she assumed he was gay. "I was going to set him up with a friend of mine - another handsome Italian man," Ray told People. Instead, she stayed out Cusimano until 4 a.m. - what she considers their first date.