Fans Were Convinced Kelley Flanagan Won ‘The Bachelor,’ but the Evidence Doesn’t Add Up

From Cosmopolitan

• Fans thought there was evidence that Kelley Flanagan won The Bachelor. A reach, sure!

• Reality Steve later debunked the theory.

Update: 5:45 p.m.

Guess this Kelley theory doesn’t have legs after all. Today, Reality Steve wrote about all the truly wild DMs he got about Kelley being pregnant and expecting Peter’s child (LOL), and sorry to break it to the Kelley fans out there, but it ain’t happening.

In Reality Steve’s own words: “Stop it. Just stop. Save it. Peter is not with Kelley. Period. End of story.”

There you have it.

Original story: 7 a.m.

Another day, another wild theory about who won Peter Weber’s season of The Bachelor. To recap, there have already been several theories about how this whole thing ends, including (a) Hannah Ann won based on her Venmo, (b) Peter risked it all for his producer, (c) Victoria F. is back in the game, and (d) Madison self-eliminated and Peter went after her.

But allow me to present (e) The Kelley Flanagan Theory, which has been circling around fan forums, Instagram accounts, and YouTube. I know, I know, Kelley was eliminated ages ago and Peter definitely has stronger connections with other women on the show. But lemme just get through the evidence because some of it is kinda convincing.

First of all, Kelley wasn’t at “The Women Tell All.” But, um, she *was* in Los Angeles during filming, as is evidenced by this photo:

Kinda suspicious, and some fans think she was in town visiting Peter but couldn’t be on the show due to secretly winning this whole thing. I mean...it’s a little weak, but there’s more!

It’s also come to the world’s attention that Every. Single. Member of Peter’s family follows Kelley—including his mom, dad, and brother. And none of them follow Madison or Hannah Ann. Just Kelley.

I mean.......

I’m not convinced, but I’m intrigued!

You Might Also Like

• 16 Unexpected Fashion Rules That the Royal Family Follows

• The 8 Best Clarifying Shampoos for Getting Rid of Product Buildup

• Here's How to Flawlessly Conceal Your Acne