How to Tell if Leftover Paint Is Still Good And When to Toss It

How to Tell if Leftover Paint Is Still Good And When to Toss It

There's nothing that refreshes a space quite like a new coat of paint—just take it from Ree and all her recent DIY projects in her new home. Anything from a home library to your kitchen can be completely transformed if you know how to paint a room. But where do you start? With so many possible paint varieties, what’s the best paint for what project? And how long will it last, if you're thinking about future touch-ups and other projects down the road?

For starters, you should know that latex paint is used for almost everything nowadays, including interior and exterior applications such as walls, trim, and doors. And the good news is, it's also the easiest paint to clean. "Latex paint is water-based paint, which means it’s an easy water cleanup," says Rick Watson, director of product information and technical services at Sherwin-Williams. "Within the latex category, there are a number of different formulations, such as acrylic or vinyl acrylic."

Other types of latex finishes include chalk paint, which has a flat or matte appearance, and milk paint, which has a more historical, distressed look. "These paints are used for decorative projects such as crafts or re-doing an old thrift store find such as a dresser or nightstand, because they’re simply not durable enough for something like walls," says Watson. Another type of paint you may see is oil based, which must be cleaned up with a solvent such as mineral spirits. Oil-based paints are, well, rather stinky. And because they’re harder to clean up, this type of paint has lost popularity.

When it comes to painting projects, it's always better to have more paint than you need. But as mentioned above, you need to know how long paint lasts, and how to store it properly so it can actually be used again. So, grab your painter's tape and read on for everything you need to know.

how long does paint last
beaucroft - Getty Images

How long does paint last?

This depends on whether you’ve maintained the proper storage conditions. New, never-opened cans of latex or oil paint usually last three years. If you store a can of opened paint properly and don’t expose the paint to air, it may last up to a couple of years more than that. Of course, each brand will have its own guidelines for an opened or unopened can's shelf life. Check out the list below for broad estimates on how long different types of paint will be good for.

Latex paint: 2 to 10 years
Acrylic paint: 2 to 15 years
Oil-based paint: 5 to 15+ years
Chalk paint: 1 to 5 years
Milk paint, mixed from powder form: 1 to 7 days
Milk paint, premixed in can: 1 to 2 years

Can I use old paint?

Sometimes! If you open the can and the paint looks okay and smells like paint (meaning it doesn’t have a funky odor), try stirring it up. If there’s a lot of sludge or chunks that won’t incorporate once you start mixing, it’s probably not a good idea to use it, says Watson. But you can always take a trip to the paint store to get a professional’s opinion.

On the other hand, if you discover a layer of paint scum, this means that air has gotten into the can and the top layer of paint is drying. In this case, you can try to salvage it: Lift off the dried layer and toss it. Then stir the paint well and apply.

How can you tell if paint has gone bad?

There are a few pretty obvious signs that your paint has gone bad. If it smells sour or stinky, like rotten eggs, it’s definitely no longer okay to use. This is because bacteria is likely present, causing the odor. “It also will have poor adhesion, may not dry, and may retain the odor once you’ve applied it to a surface,” says Watson.

Save yourself the headache and just toss it! To get rid of it safely, check with your local municipality for proper disposal.

how long does paint last
MPKphoto - Getty Images

How do you store paint?

To make sure you get a long shelf life out of your paint, be sure the container is properly sealed, then stored in a dry, conditioned spot at the right temperature for the type of paint that you have. The thing you should really know is, no matter what kind of paint it is, you can always keep leftover paint. “The most important step is to keep air out of the can,” says Rick.

Wipe all the residue from the top groove of the paint can and around the edge of the lid, then put the lid back on. Place a block of wood on top of the lid, which will help you hammer the lid on more evenly, and then use a rubber mallet to tap it into place. Don’t forget to use a permanent marker to jot down where and when you used the paint on the lid or the bottom of the can so you’ll have it ready for touch-ups down the road.

Store leftover paint in a space that’s between 50 and 90 degrees F. You don’t want it to freeze (so no garage) or get too hot (so no attic). And keep it away from any sources of humidity and heat, such as a hot water heater, furnace, or direct sunlight. You'll also want to avoid areas with the possibility of freezing.

It's also important to keep your paint clean and bacteria-free. To do this, always pour the paint into a tray or cup before using it so you're not directly dipping paint brushes or rollers into the can. When you're finished, dispose of the remainder or store it separately from the rest of the can instead of pouring it back in.

If there’s only a teeny, tiny amount of paint left and you don’t have space to store the can, some people like to pour leftover paint into a smaller recycled plastic container with a screw-on lid. But be sure to keep the label and/or lid, which contain the product number, color formulation, and warranty info. Now, when the time comes for touch-ups or a whole new look, you'll be ready!

You Might Also Like