The June 2019 Allure Beauty Box: See All the Product Samples You Could Get This Month

A lot of brow pencils are so creamy, they can look fake. Not this one. It has the perfect waxy consistency for creating believable fullness that’s not too heavy or too uniform. I always focus more color on my arches than on the rest of my brows, which is a tried-and-true makeup artist trick for achieving natural-looking gradation — and avoiding the dreaded angry brow look.— Elizabeth Siegel, Deputy Beauty Director

Value: The BrowGal Skinny Eyebrow Pencil, $23.

Subscribe Now.