People Are Sharing Their Most Polarizing Food Opinions, And I've Gotta Say, Some Of These Are Really Valid

Part of being human is having opinions. But sometimes those opinions are hugely unpopular...especially when it comes to food preferences. So Redditor u/PairWorldly169 asked, "What is the most controversial food opinion you have?" Here's what people chimed in with.

1."I think egg yolks are gross when runny. Fully cooked yolks for me, please."

A soft poached egg spills its runny yolk onto the plate.
Getty Images

2."There’s no such thing as a 'special occasion' food. For example, cake is often associated with a party. But I’m a grown man and if I want cake because it’s Wednesday I’m going to go get myself a Wednesday cake."

NBC

u/MegaEmailman

3."No recipe is sacred. They're all eligible for reinterpretation regardless of your emotional attachment to them."

CBS

u/SevenTheTerrible

4."I think cilantro tastes like soap. It is very hard having this gene in a primarily Mexican community where people are constantly telling me I'm a picky eater. But no, I don't want my tacos to taste as if they were drenched in Fabuloso cleaner."

Squeezing lime on a seafood taco topped with slaw and cilantro.
Getty Images

5."You can eat whatever you want at any time of day. Have a three-course pasta feast for breakfast. People say don't eat it in the morning if it's not a 'breakfast food,' but when it comes to your own diet, you can do whatever the heck you want."

20th Century Studios

u/SeemytrVASF

6."Cooking with wood or charcoal is absolutely superior to cooking with propane."

Point Grey Pictures

u/GreenChorizo

7."I like brownies and ice cream separately, but i don’t like brownies in my ice cream. That being said, ice cream on top of a brownie is A-OK."

vanilla ice cream, a brownie and chocolate syrup on top
Getty Images

8."Orange Tic Tacs are not breath mints. They are straight-up candy."

NBC

u/Significant-Trouble6

9."Frozen blueberries are better than fresh blueberries. When we used to go blueberry picking, I would freeze the berries before eating them. Even half-frozen, they taste sweeter than when fresh."

Fresh frozen blueberries in a container.
Getty Images

10."If I crack an egg on anything while re-heating it, it has magically become a breakfast food."

Fried rice with an egg on top.
Getty Images

11.Not many foods on earth — no matter the price tag — can top the taste of fresh bread still warm from the oven topped with butter."

Whole wheat bread with butter.
Getty Images

12."Muffins are just cake disguised as breakfast food."

Blueberry Muffin with Butter.
Getty Images

13."MSG is awesome. I put it in a salt shaker mixed 50/50 with table salt, and use it in everything that calls for salt. Pure umami is a game changing ingredient."

A bowl of spicy ramen noodles.
Getty Images

14."We all have to stop it with the 'secret family recipes.' Every damn time I ask for one of my mother's recipes I get a lecture from someone about not sharing it with anyone. Come on, it's a ragu sauce, not nuclear launch codes."

ABC

u/phrantastic

15."Hot sauce doesn't add flavor, it adds heat. It makes good food taste like nothing except for the spicy hot sauce. No hot sauce on my eggs, please and thank you."

Columbia Pictures

chelseaf4679417e5

16."Eating the same thing every day and never mixing up your routine is totally fine."

Meatballs and broccoli and rice in glass containers.
Getty Image

17."The difference between fine coffee and great coffee is not worth the amount of energy people spend trying to achieve that difference."

Miramax

u/ElvisGrizzly

18."Cherry Coke is better than Regular Coke. Fight me."

Paramount Pictures Studios

u/dayofthedead204

19."Parmesan cheese improves the flavor of literally any single soup."

A bowl of soup topped with shaved Parmesan.
Getty Images

20."People like to shame American cheese as heavily processed, fake stuff, but it's absolutely delicious...especially on a burger."

A burger patty with cheese and bacon.
Getty Images

21."Cereal makes for a lousy breakfast, but it's a really great dessert."

New Line Production

u/ccaccus

22."I don't like tomatoes as a topping on sandwiches, burgers, etc... For me it's all I taste and it's super overpowering."

Making a cheese, tomato, and arugula sandwich.

23."Ruffles potato chips are best when dipped in cottage cheese."

A spoonful of cottage cheese.
Getty Images

24."Oreo cream filling is disgusting. The chocolate cookie is absolutely the best part and quite frankly, the only part worth eating."

A stack of Oreo cookies.
Getty Images

25."Avocado tastes like absolutely nothing to me. It baffles me why people are so obsessed with it."

NBC

u/MidnightRecon·

"Avocado is extremely overrated. It tastes like mushy blandness. It has almost no flavor except a hint of grass."

—A_Panda

26."If you put nuts in brownies you are an evil person."

Walnut brownies.
Getty Images

27."Most food aversions you have are because your parents didn't know how to cook that food correctly."

NBC

u/Voyager5555

28."It is completely justifiable to break up with someone who is an excessively picky eater."

Comedy Central

u/DonQOnIce

29."Cold leftovers have more flavor than re-heated leftovers. IMO, after you heat up food, all you can taste is the heat."

A slice of cold pizza on foil.

30."Coconut water tastes like water that’s already been in someone else’s mouth and was spit out."

Disney

u/sortahuman123

31."Oatmeal is best when savory. I love eating it with broccoli and cheese so much better than loading it up with fruit and/or sugar.

Savory oatmeal with egg.
Getty Images

32."Processed cheese is delicious, and I don't care what people say. When I want to make a cheese sauce, I simply do not have the time nor the patience to grate a block of cheese, make a roux, and a béchamel to melt the cheese into. Give me a good old block of Velveeta any day."

Stovetop mac 'n' cheese.
Getty Images

33."Truffles smell (and taste) like dirty feet."

—Afan

Afan

Getty Images

Do you have an unpopular food opinion? Tell us in the comments below.