Hate Blisters? Treat Your Feet to Some Actually Comfortable Loafers

"Hearst Magazines and Yahoo may earn commission or revenue on some items through these links."

As a longtime Loafer Girlie, I couldn't be happier that loafers are still having ~a moment~ (shoutout to the resurgence of Y2K and early-aughts aesthetics!!). From menswear-inspired penny loafers to chunky lug-sole loafers, I love 'em all—but since I value comfort above all else, I have zero patience for shoes that require a breaking-in period. Some styles can feel pretty stiff initially, while others are way too clunky or heavy for my liking. And if you, too, require comfy shoes to feel like your best self, I've got actually comfortable loafers that your feet will <3.

So...what makes for a comfortable loafer? As Nomasei designers Paule Tenaillon and Marine Braquet previously told Cosmo, it's always a good idea to look for loafers with "a flexible sole, a vamp that isn't overly tight, and a slight lift so that it's not too flat." Likewise, loafers made with natural fibers like leather tend to be more breathable and have more stretch than those made with synthetic materials (though you may still want to wear new leather loafers with socks until they soften). Now, on to the good stuff!

Ahead, the comfiest loafers your $$$ can buy, including flats, platforms, and pumps that won't leave your poor lil feet covered in blisters. Oh, and be sure to check out our fave loafer 'fits for some styling inspo.

Corinne Lugsole Loafer

IMO, these are the Golilocks of lug-sole loafers: chunky but not too chunky. I've been in love with mine since the very first wear (the padded insoles are *chef's kiss*), and whether I pair 'em with jeans, work pants, or midi skirts, these shoes never miss. Pro tip: I went half a size up to wear mine with socks, and the fit is perfect.

• Size range: 5-11 with half sizes

• Material: Leather

• Heel height: 0.875"

• Colors: True black or dried maple

THE REVIEW: "I absolutely love these loafers," writes one tester. "They fit true to size. I love that slightly chunky look that doesn’t make my foot look huge. They also are comfy to walk or stand in for long periods of time. Would buy again!"

Whitney Weejuns Loafer

Ah, yes, the quintessential beefroll penny loafer. Handsewn in El Salvador, the Whitney is a beloved classic for a reason, featuring gorgeous moc stitching, a very low heel, and buttery-soft leather uppers. Best of all, you can rest assured these will never go out of style.

• Size range: 5-11 with half sizes

• Material: Leather

• Heel height: 0.87"

• Colors: Wine or black

THE REVIEW: "Fit comfortably right out the box," one reviewer notes. "I was surprised no breaking in required. I ordered my usual size in shoes. They are of course looser when I wear thin no-show socks but still feel great. Definitely can tell it's a good-quality shoe. Very cute classic look!"

Lando Loafer

Yep, these are the way more affordable Gucci lug sole loafer alternatives you've seen all over TikTok—and even though they're made with vegan leather, many reviewers say they look and feel pretty darn close to the real thing. You'll love the on-trend chunky lug sole and classic horsebit hardware...as well as the fact that they're almost always available on sale on Amazon.

• Size range: 5-12 with half sizes

• Material: Faux leather

• Heel height: 1.5"

• Color: Black

THE REVIEW: "Great loafer!" reads one review. "Way more comfortable than the Gucci lug sole loafer and, uhm, saved $1,150. Thank you, Steve Madden. As other reviews suggested, I sized up a half size—they are comfortable, kind of cushy, and not too narrow."

Carolynn Tassel Loafer

Cute menswear-inspired tasseled loafers that cost less than $100? Say less!! These bestsellers allow ya to embrace the tassel trend without dropping too much dough. And, no, they're not made with real leather, but reviewers are still v impressed with the quality and the comfort.

• Size range: 5-11 with half sizes

• Material: Faux leather

• Heel height: 1.5"

• Colors: Camel brown, black, inky navy, gold, burgundy, putty white, or slate grey

THE REVIEW: "These are unbelievable loafers for the price," one tester raves. "Comfortable, stylish, and well made. I anticipate wearing these all the time for work as they are so comfortable and SO stylish."

The Felize

There are a lot of great driving shoes out there, but M. Gemi's Felize (which Cosmo loves, btw) is srsly top-notch in terms of quality and style. These shoes features a true moccasin construction, dreamy suede uppers, and a classic pebbled rubber sole—and they'll cost ya way less than a pair of Tod's drivers.

• Size range: 5-12 with half sizes

• Material: Suede

• Heel height: Flat

• Colors: Sunset red, black, saddle, midnight blue, latte, gray, or mushroom

THE REVIEW: "The Felize is a wonderful shoe," one buyer writes. "It fits true to size and is very comfortable and stylish! Sometimes driving mocs can be difficult to walk in, as the nubs aren't always placed comfortably. These mocs are as comfortable for walking as they are for driving! Highly recommend!"

Leah Loafer

I saw Olivia Rodrigo wearing the Coach Leah Loafer, so I bought the Coach Leah Loafer. I <3 the chunky '90s-inspired lug sole and the tailored detailing at the vamp (and the cushiony memory foam padding inside is also v clutch). And if you're not into metallics, you'll be happy to know this one comes in neutral colors as well.

• Size range: 5-11 with half sizes

• Material: Leather

• Heel height: 1.5"

• Colors: Silver metallic, black, black patent, chalk, or maple

THE REVIEW: As one reviewer notes, "True to size [and] very comfortable right out of the box. Amazing style! Worth the price IMO for a fancy splurge. I’m a 7.5 to 8 and got an 8—fits well with thin or thick socks."

The Starling

From the roomy toe box to the quilted satin footbed, these smoking slipper loafers from Birdies look and feel like luxury...which is prob why they've earned nearly 35,000 rave reviews. I wear my Starlings at least once a week, and just a warning: Once you experience the cloud-like comfort of these bbs, you'll be tempted to buy at least three more pairs.

• Size range: 5-13 with half sizes; medium or wide width

• Material: Leather, suede, or velvet

• Heel height: 0.31"

• Colors: 25 options

THE REVIEW: "These are the most comfortable shoes I have ever owned," reads one review. "They feel better than new slippers and are beautiful, too! Even though they cost a bit more than I am used to paying, I don't regret one penny. Totally worth it."

Royal

Clomping around in a pair of chunky loafers is fun and all, but sometimes, ya don't want something so...loud. The solution: these glossy lug-sole platforms, which are made with Melissa's propriety MelFlex material (a form of PVC that's durable, recyclable, and amazingly lightweight). Oh, and did I mention these shoes smell like straight-up bubblegum??

• Size range: 5-10

• Material: PVC

• Heel height: 2.24"

• Colors: Beige, pink, black, or glitter

THE REVIEW: According to one reviewer, "These are cute and really comfy. I’m usually a 6.5 or 7 and I order a size 6 and they fit perfect! Even though they have a chunky look, they’re lightweight!"

The Modern Loafer

So elegant! So versatile! So damn comfortable! With its sleek tapered toe and small stacked heel, this shoe is ideal for wearing with legit everything, and that fun stitch detailing keeps it from looking too *yawn.* Plus, the foam-cushioned insole helps to make it comfy from the very first wear.

• Size range: 5-11 with half sizes

• Material: Leather

• Heel height: 1"

• Colors: Camel or black

THE REVIEW: According to one tester, "The second I tried these on, they made my outfit look so much cleaner and tied together, and I was blown away by how soft and comfortable they were right off the bat. This is flexible, buttery leather, and I haven’t had a single blister—they required absolutely no breaking in. 10/10."

Desi Loafer

Finding comfortable loafers when you have a wider foot can be tricky (especially when you add on a heel). Luckily, Naturalizer offers this cute platform heel loafer in two different widths, complete with funky metallic chain-link detailing and a cushy footbed that contours to your foot.

• Size range: 5-12 with half sizes; medium or wide width

• Material: Leather

• Heel height: 2.25"

• Colors: Taupe, black, vanilla crème, tan, or cappuccino brown

THE REVIEW: "Extremely comfortable if you are on your feet all day," notes one tester. "They also look great! I got them in two colors."

Alma Loafer

Okay, but how fun is that chunky acrylic chain detail?? A modern take on a classic shoe, the Alma Loafer (which is handmade in Argentina) features a square toe, kidskin leather upper, and stacked leather heel—and while it's available in black, I'm a sucker for this rich pinot color.

• Size range: 5.5-11.5 with half sizes

• Material: Leather

• Heel height: 0.85"

• Colors: Pinot or black

THE REVIEW: "I had my eye on these gorgeous loafers for a few weeks before getting them, and they are worth every penny," one buyer raves. "The quality is impeccable, they arrived much more quickly than I anticipated, and they are stunning. I know I will wear, and love, these amazing shoes for years and years."

The Penny

The problem with a lot of loafers: They feel stiff AF. But that's not an issue with these Italian calf suede beauts, as they have a flexible, unlined construction that ensures a glove-like fit. Other perks include plush foam padding on the footbed, as well as the variety of width and color options.

• Size range: 3-14 with half sizes; narrow, medium, or wide width

• Material: Suede

• Heel height: 0.5"

• Colors: 9 options

THE REVIEW: As one reviewer notes, "Feels like a house slipper disguised as a chic loafer. They molded to my feet with my very first wear. I love how they seriously upgrade an otherwise quiet outfit."

Valencia Heels

Listen, I love a good pair of chunky loafer pumps. But when it comes to versatility, these heeled loafers from Bibi Lou are the real winners. The gold bit hardware and sleek silhouette give 'em such an elevated lewk (while the roomy square toe and walkable block heel will keep your feet happy for hours).

• Size range: 4.5-12 with half sizes

• Material: Leather

• Heel height: 2.75"

• Colors: Rojo, marino, verde, ivory, blue croc, black, or camel

THE REVIEW: "These loafers are adorable, trendy, and comfortable!" one reviewer notes. "The heel is a perfect height to wear to work and out with friends, with pants, jeans, dresses, or skirts. I will be wearing these all fall!"

Loraine Bit Loafer

It's giving Gucci Jordaan Loafer on a budget, no? With its almond toe, padded leather insole, and gold hardware, the internet-famous Loaraine Bit Loafer has earned so many rave reviews...probs because it's designer quality at an actually affordable price.

• Size range: 5-14 with half sizes; medium or wide width

• Material: Leather

• Heel height: 0.5"

• Colors: 30+ options

THE REVIEW: "These are hands down the most comfortable loafers I have ever worn," one reviewer raves. "They might possibly be the most comfortable non-athletic shoes I have ever owned. A truly classic and versatile shoe that goes with most everything. I will be purchasing in other colorways."

Cosmo 2.0 Loafer

Found: the perfect lugged penny loafer. The celeb-approved Cosmo 2.0 has been worn by everyone from Kendall Jenner to Gigi Hadid, and tbh, they're pretty affordable considering the quality. Reviewers love the cute lil penny straps and moc-toe details, especially when paired with that chunky lug sole.

• Size range: 5-12 with half sizes

• Material: Leather

• Heel height: 1.77"

• Color: Black

THE REVIEW: According to one buyer, "I've been looking at these shoes for a while now. They are exactly what I wanted. They are so well made, and so far, quite comfortable. If you are on the fence, go for it. I LOVE them."

Why trust 'Cosmo'?

Cosmo’s team of digital fashion experts have decades of combined experience in the industry. They spot relevant trends on the runway before they even hit your TikTok FYP or Insta Explore Page and conduct research across retailers of all kinds—testing many brands IRL—to bring you the best clothing and accessory picks for every season. Basically, we’ve curated the internet to bring you the chicest options like it’s our job (because it is, heh).

Each of our shopping articles adheres to the 15 Percent Pledge and includes products for all sizes. These comfortable loafers were chosen based on style, functionality, testability, price point, and so many reviews to put together this shoppable list of the very best for you!

You Might Also Like

• Here’s What NOT to Wear to a Wedding

• Meet the Laziest, Easiest Acne Routine You’ll Ever Try