• Home
  • Mail
  • Tumblr
  • News
  • Sports
  • Finance
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Answers
  • Groups
  • Mobile
  • More
Yahoo
    • Skip to Navigation
    • Skip to Main Content
    • Skip to Related Content
    • Mail
    Lifestyle Home
    Follow Us
    • Style
    • Beauty
    • Wellness
    • Pop Culture
    • Shopping
    • News
    • Horoscope
    • Video
    • NowWith

    Court throws out obscenity charge against magazine's 'morally degrading' cover starring breastfeeding model

    Erin Donnelly
    Yahoo LifestyleJune 22, 2018
    Reblog
    Share
    Tweet
    Share

    A women’s magazine caused an uproar in India earlier this year for featuring a model breastfeeding a baby on its cover. Despite complaints that the image was too sexual in nature — with critics citing the fact that model Gilu Joseph is not the infant’s mother — a court has ruled that it’s not obscene.

    As NDTV reports, the Kerala High Court has thrown out a petition accusing Grihalakshmi of violating the Indecent Representation of Women Act with its pro-breastfeeding shoot.

    “We look at the picture, like we look at paintings of artists like Raja Ravi Varma,” the court’s judgment said of its ruling in favor of the magazine. “As beauty lies in the beholder’s eye, so does obscenity, perhaps.

    “What may be obscene to some may be artistic to other; one man’s vulgarity is another man’s lyric, so to say. … May we observe, Indian psyche has been so mature for ages that it could see the sensuous even in the sacred. The paintings in Ajanta and the temple architecture are cases in point,” the judges added.

    Joseph, who was partially exposed on the controversial cover, told the media that she was slut-shamed after the issue’s publication. Much was made of her appearing to nurse the infant on her lap, even though she is not a mother herself.

    “I was slut-shamed, was termed a blue-film actor,” Joseph told NDTV. “My mother was called names. But I knew I would have to hear all this. I took it in my stride. This issue is about breastfeeding, and it’s an important cause. There is no question of regretting anything. This is my work. I have cared in films as a mother, what’s so different about this?”

    Indeed, many mothers and breastfeeding advocates have praised the cover for helping to destigmatize nursing in public.

    To some it's gross, to some it's a free show. To a child, it's unquestionably simple and necessary. To anyone smart in enough, it's natural. Good work, @mathrubhumieng #breastfeeding #changeyourmind https://t.co/YG5lqPvbXJ

    — Shreya (@ShreyaTeresita) February 28, 2018


    It's very courageous. It should encourage host of mothers to do what should be normally done for the betterment and overall growth of the infant

    — Sanjay Mukherjee (@SanjayM73565536) March 1, 2018


    But others claimed that public breastfeeding is “wrong,” with one critic insisting it was “morally degrading,” despite the court ruling.

    “I have lost my 5-month-old daughter,” the man identified as Felix MA told NDTV. “I know the pain of breastfeeding. All the months that she was in the intensive care unit, my wife could not visit her due to her own infection. I used to carry pumped milk for my daughter. And now, in this picture, an unmarried model is seen holding an infant and posing as if she is breastfeeding. Is this acceptable?” 

    Read more from Yahoo Lifestyle:

    • Tia Mowry opens up about how different breastfeeding is with her 2nd child
    • Chrissy Teigen shares a slightly scary side effect of breastfeeding
    • Breastfeeding moms who smoke pot may be passing THC to their infants

    Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter for nonstop inspiration delivered fresh to your feed, every day.


    Reblog
    Share
    Tweet
    Share

    What to Read Next

    • Boy, 11, arrested after refusing to recite 'racist' Pledge of Allegiance

      Yahoo Lifestyle
    • Prince William and Prince Harry are Reportedly Set to Split Their Royal Household

      Elle
    • Why Is it "Weird" When a Woman Wants Sex More Than a Man?

      InStyle
    • Woman faces charges after videotaped incident on school bus in which she allegedly attacked 9-year-old said to have hit her son, 5

      Yahoo Lifestyle
    • Washington state bill to ban 'philosophical' vaccine exemptions moves forward

      Yahoo Lifestyle
    • Katy Perry Was Reportedly ‘Shaking With Happiness’ When Orlando Bloom Proposed

      Elle
    • This Guy Pretended He Got Stood up at Outback Steakhouse on Valentine's Day so Strangers Would Pay His Bill

      Men's Health
    • Bella Hadid and The Weeknd Celebrated His Birthday With Matching Camo Outfits

      W
    • A Super Snow Moon Is Almost Here, so Set Your Alarms

      PureWow
    • Beyoncé Wore the Ultimate Red Lace Bodycon Dress for Valentine's Day

      Elle
    • Drinking Two Or More Diet Sodas A Day Leads To A “Significantly Greater Likelihood” Of Strokes And Heart Attacks, New Study Says

      Delish
    • 3 injured at 'Hamilton' after medical emergency sparks evacuation

      USA TODAY
    • Gov. Gretchen Whitmer calls out comments about her 'curves': 'Way out of line'

      Yahoo Lifestyle
    • I Tried on 20 Pairs of Straight-Leg Jeans to Find the Best-Fitting

      Who What Wear
    • The Real Reason Kendall Jenner Has Kept Her Relationship with Ben Simmons So Private

      InStyle
    • Kim Kardashian posts absolutely adorable photo of baby Chicago

      Yahoo Celebrity

    Tax Refund Fiasco Is Political Payback For Republicans

    taikibansei: Every dollar devoted to the middle class causes the economy to grow three times faster than a dollar for the rich, according to statistics kept at the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office. Millionaires save more of their income gained by tax cuts. Middle-class families spend more. Lower taxes for the rich leave deficits that must be paid for by the middle class. Factor in this also: study after study (look it up) has found that the bigger the tax breaks the corporations get, the more likely they are to send jobs overseas. (The story about GM last year--record profits, lots of government financial support, but closed plants and NO domestic hiring--being a great example.)

    Join the Conversation
    1 / 5

    1.4k

    • 42 outstanding Presidents' Day tech deals on TVs, tablets, laptops and more

      Yahoo Lifestyle
    • 'Hand Jobs' salon is causing controversy for its suggestive name

      Yahoo Lifestyle
    • Beyoncé Won Valentine's Day in a Red Lace Minidress

      InStyle
    • Are You Cleaning Your Dishwasher Often Enough? Here's How

      House Beautiful
    • New mom Kate Upton praised for sharing 'relatable' selfie of her using a breast pump before her Valentine's Day date

      Yahoo Lifestyle
    • The 3-Day Military Diet Says You Can Lose 10 Pounds in One Week. Does It Actually Work?

      Men's Health
    • Genius new 'eggs' let you wash clothes for $10 per year — without detergent

      Yahoo Lifestyle
    • 5 Times It's OK to Take a Break From Your Partner

      Brides
    • Governor Gretchen Whitmer Won't Stand For Sexist Comments About What She Wears

      Refinery29
    • Bella Hadid and Kylie Jenner Got the Same Insane Valentine’s Day Surprise From Their Boyfriends

      Elle
    • Bella Hadid and The Weeknd Celebrate His Birthday With Matching Outfits

      Teen Vogue
    • Prince Harry's Valentine's Day Surprise Made Him ​Prett​y​ Uncomfortable

      HuffPost
    • Cardi B Got Fiery Red Hair Just In Time for Valentine's Day

      Marie Claire
    • Kate Middleton Reveals She Was a ‘Naïve’ Parent in Candid New Speech

      PureWow
    • Pregnancy After Miscarriage: Why I Can't Shake the Fear of Another Pregnancy Loss

      Self
    • Kate Middleton and Prince Louis Went on a Valentine's Day Walk in the Park

      Elle