The Chilling True Story Behind ‘A Friend of the Family’

Photo credit: Peacock
Photo credit: Peacock
  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.


"Hearst Magazines and Yahoo may earn commission or revenue on some items through the links below."

Peacock’s new true crime drama, A Friend of the Family, hit the streamer this week with its first four episodes. The miniseries has 9 episodes total and stars Jake Lacy, Anna Paquin, Colin Hanks, and Lio Tipton, and in an extremely chilling turn, the show is based on a true story.

First, a flashback: One of Netflix’s most talked about documentaries, Abducted in Plain Sight, was released in 2017 and focuses on the same case as A Friend of the Family. The Netflix documentary is based on the book, Stolen Innocence: The Jan Broberg Story, making this new Peacock series the third iteration of one of the most-discussed kidnapping cases in recent history. In case you missed the documentary in your most recent scroll fugue state, here’s the true story behind A Friend of the Family.

The key subjects here are Jan Broberg and pedophile Robert “B” Berchtold. In the 1970s, Robert abducted Jan two separate times–once when she was 12 and again when she was 14, all in front of her parents’ eyes. The Brobergs and Berchtolds were a pair of close families in Idaho, spending so much time together that the Broberg daughters often referred to Berchtold as “B” or even “dad” occasionally. Robert became a figure in the Broberg family, developing intimate and occasionally sexual relationships with *both* Jan's parents, Bob and Mary Ann. He leveraged this parental trust to abuse and abduct Jan.

In October 1974, Robert kidnapped Jan for the first time. He told the Brobergs he was taking Jan horseback riding but instead drove her to Mexico. While in Mexico, Robert Berchtold and a 12-year-old Jan Broberg were married. Reflecting back on this time of her life, Jan remembers being brainwashed by Robert, who told her that the two were on a mission to save the Broberg family from aliens. He told Jan that the only way to save her family was for a Broberg daughter to have a child with him by the age of 16, and if it were not her, it would be one of her sisters. He then raped her, and shortly after, her parents flew to Mexico to find her. Upon returning to the U.S., Robert was arrested and charged with kidnapping.

In the aftermath of the kidnapping, Jan said she had been brainwashed by Robert. He continued to send her letters, and Jan still believed she was still on a mission to save her family. Whenever the two were together, Robert would rape her. In time, he began an affair with Jan’s mother, Mary Ann Broberg. Evidence of their affair was used to lessen the kidnapping charges against him, ultimately shortening his sentence to just 10 days served in jail. During these 10 days, Robert convinced a few fellow criminals to burn down the Broberg’s store for money–and they did.

Photo credit: Peacock
Photo credit: Peacock

In August 1976, Robert kidnapped Jan Broberg for the second time. He took her to California, where he enrolled her in an all-girls Catholic school and told the administrators that he was in the CIA and needed to keep his and Jan’s information completely private. Ultimately, the FBI tracked him down, pulled Jan out of school, and returned her to her family. Following the second kidnapping, Robert stood trial for the charge of first degree kidnapping but was only sentenced to six months in a mental facility.

Following the second kidnapping, the Brobergs kept their distance from Robert, and as Jan got older, she came to realize that the “mission” was a ruse and she had been raped. Together, Jan and Mary Ann Broberg wrote the memoir Stolen Innocence and hit the road on a speaking tour. Throughout this tour, Robert would occasionally show up and spin his story to the media, denying that he sexually abused Jan. She ultimately filed a restraining order against Robert, ordering him to stay away from her for the remainder of his life. In the end, Robert—facing charges related to a fight with a biker gangdied by suicide in 2005.

Jan herself is directly involved with the Peacock adaptation, on which she serves as executive producer. “We know if people start talking about things that actually matter like this, it will make a difference," she told Variety. "So whether they are talking smack about my parents, they’re talking. Whether they’re talking about, ‘That dumb Jan Broberg, how stupid could she be to think she was kidnapped by aliens?’ I don’t care anymore. I want them to talk because, to me, that moves the needle closer to prevention, closer to awareness and closer to what I hope to stand for, which is hope that you can heal from trauma.”

Clearly this story is rife with twists enough for a book, a documentary, and a drama miniseries, and it's brave of Jan to continue sharing her story with the public.

You Might Also Like