The Best Merchants on Etsy as Recommended by Our Writers
If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, Rolling Stone may receive an affiliate commission.
Scouring the internet to find the perfect new piece of decor for your home, bespoke gift for a friend or a new item for yourself that feels new and unique can be overwhelming. For those unfamiliar, Etsy is a unique marketplace that aggregates products made and sold by small business owners in one easy to shop format. Many of the products sold on Etsy are 1 of 1 or limited edition, meaning you’re always likely to be delighted and feel like you’re receiving a special gem of your own.
More from Rolling Stone
In addition to supporting similar small businesses and brands, our team frequently purchases items of their own from the Etsy platform. Below, we’ve aggregated a list of brands we’ve made successful purchases from with products that lived up to their promised product quality, descriptions and/or customer service.
Below are a list of our favorite shops, as well as a few available products on our wishlists from each. As always, we’ll continue updating and adding to this list as our own positive experiences with new merchants on Etsy grows. We hope you enjoy our recommendations.
Best Fashion Shops on Etsy
Leather and Suede Jackets by LeatherNasirArts
$101.69
With over 500+ sales and several high customer reviews, this shop is delivering on current western trends with ease. Our writers have found their jackets to be received in impeccable quality and at a huge value for the materials used.
The above jacket is listed starting at $101.69 and is available in several suede colors.
Linen Clothing by LinenFox
$107.50
Nearly every silhouette of linen is available for purchase from this shop at an affordable price. I’ve personally purchased several dresses and jumpsuits and plan to return for more flowly items this summer.
The above pants are on sale for $107.50.
Made to Order Linen Clothing by SondeflorShop
$198
Shipping from Lithuania, this shop creates beautifully nostalgic linen patterns and designs. I’ve recently loved their high neck vest designs.
The above vest is on sale for $198.
Vintage Clothing by VintageOnHollywood
$250
Some of the best vintage finds can be found in the most heavily populated cities. This Etsy shop that is based in Hollywood sells unforgettable timepiece relecs that will live on as forever standouts in your collection or wardrobe.
The above bowling shirt is on sale for $250.
Designer Resale by ModDept
$149
A broad assortment of vintage and resale designer items. This shop always had a really great expected luxury find.
The above Versace jacket is on sale for $149.
Vintage Clothing by RetroRise1
$116.99
Carrying a broad assortment of men’s vintage between $30-$200, this shop which was opened just 3 years ago, has since cleared more than 10,000 items sold with thousands of others still available. Great stop for bargain finds on popular brands like Carhartt, Nike, Champion and more.
The above shirt is on sale for $116.99.
Best Home Shops on Etsy
Vintage Furniture by VintageVaultTulsa
$998
VintageVaultTulsa hosts an infinite array of mid-century modern furniture. The shop is extremely responsive, willing to providing additional photos and transparent with shipping costs and delivery estimates.
Above chairs are listed for $998 with only two remaining.
Kilim Pillows by KilimPillowKingdom
$2.40+
If you’re looking to spruce up your boring throw pillows, look no further than this shop. KilimPillowKingdom sells beautifully decorative pillow covers for less than $5.
The above pillow coverage is available without an insert for $2.40 or with an insert for $8.40
70s Kitchenware by YvonnesCache
$27
I’ve been nostaligic for my grandmother’s home for as long as I can remember. Any way that I can incorporate touches of her space in my own, I’m happy to shell out whatever the cost. Yvonne has does a great job of curating memorable dishes from just that era.
The above cocktail classes are listed for only $27.
Made to Order Moroccan Rugs from Beniouraincarpets
$299.75
If you’ve ever needed a custom sized rug for your space, look no further than this Etsy shop. Beniouraincarpets is a best in class Moroccan rug dealer that provides detailed customer service and will walk you through the rug making process thoughtfully while you await your order.
The above rug is on sale for $299.75.
Vintage and Antique Silverware by DDBEANZandBOOTZ
$50
Nothing will upgrade your hosting game like a good set of silver server ware. Like much of the shops and items on theme of this post, it just all comes back to our grandparents, doesn’t it? This shop based in my home state of North Carolina does a great job of curating high quality vintage and antique silver.
By the above casserole dish for $50.
Vintage Homewares with VintageWithLaurie
$150
If you’ve ever needed to add a bit of art or color to your home, this shop is for you. Including a combination of prints, harlequin serverware and jewelry at the moment, this shop is always sure to surprise.
The above cups and saucer sets are currently on sale for $150.
Best Accessories Shops on Etsy
Handpicked Vintage by Cucarachaz
$37.80
Carefully crafted accessories at an affordable price. This shop is one I return to often for inspiration on how to spice up my wardrobe.
The above belt is on sale for $37.80.
Mexican Silver Jewelry by OldMexicoSilverShop
$239
As someone of Mexican heritage, I find it hard to stay away from this shop for long. I could find a use for just about every single item that they’re selling. Extremely high quality products that are identical to their photos.
The above necklace is on sale for $289.
Vintage and Antique Jewelry by SpiritButtons
$38
One of a kind items that have been carefully collected and curated over time. With more that 16,000 sales and several 5 star reviews, you’re likely to be a very happy customer after purchasing from this shop.
The above bracelet is on sale for $38.
Vintage Coach Bags by CristinaModa
$195
Vintage coach bags have been making a big come back, as seen on the likes of musicians and celebrities like Olivia Rodrigo among others. These timeless leather staples that many of our grand and great-grand parents may have once carried are regaining popularity.
The above bag is currently listed for $195.
Vintage Decor and Jewelry by O2Vintage
$69.50
My etsy searches tend to take me where ever I can find good Taxco Mexican silver jewelry and this shop delivers. This shop carries much more than just jewelry, however — from Eduardian silks to handmade folk art, this shop owner has an eye for well treasured items that are worth keeping.
The above bracelet is on sale for $69.50.
Vintage Coach Bags by VintageWithATouchofKlass
$299.99
Another great option for sourcing vintage Coach handbags is to shop with VintageWithATouchofKlass. Their broad assortment of inventory will make you a repeat purchaser.
The above bag is listed for $299.99.
Vintage Jewelry from BargainBitz
$178.95
Another beloved jewelry shop that ships from Pennsylvania. This shop has a expansive and evolving inventory. Theve made more than 8K sales have an abundance of 5 star reviews.
The above bracelet is on sale for $178.95.
Pet Accessories by WigglywoosPet
$23
The commoditization of pet products has not yet occured on Etsy. From shops like WigglywoosPet, you can still find affordable collar and leash accessories that don’t compromise on style. My dog has used one of their rope leashes for the last several years.
The above rope leash is on sale for $23+.
Best of Rolling Stone
