These Rubber Boots Are What You Need to Stomp Through Rain and Mud

"Hearst Magazines and Yahoo may earn commission or revenue on some items through these links."

No matter the season, a pair of rubber boots are a necessity. In winter, they keep your feet dry in wet snow and slush. When winter thaws into spring, and terra firma feels a little less than firm, it's mud boots to the rescue as puddles submerge trails and fields. In summer, there’s wet grass to mow and muddy gardens to tend, and in fall you need dry feet as you rake wet leaves, clean slop-filled gutters, and slosh through the first icy puddles.

Some people call them mud, utility, or rain boots, but whatever your preferred name, all share two main elements: high-traction soles to keep you on your feet and a waterproof or water-resistant exterior to protect you from the elements. We tested several pairs to find out which are up to the task, so read on for the best rubber boots worth considering.

The Best Rubber Boots

• Best Overall: Bogs Classic Ultra High

• Best Value: Dunlop Chesapeake

• Most Comfortable: Muck Arctic Sport II Mid

• Best For Women: Kamik Jessie
  

• Best Duck Boot: L.L. Bean Bean Boot 8-Inch

What to Consider

Material

In the face of squishy muck, a sturdy pair of rubber boots is the armor you need for dry feet. Both latex-based natural rubber and its petroleum-based synthetic counterpart are naturally impervious to water. The disadvantage: They don’t let water vapor out the way that breathable membrane booties used in waterproof hiking boots do. So as your foot sweats, that moisture is more or less trapped.

Basic models have a molded one-piece rubber upper that’s bonded to the boot’s midsole and outsole. Heavy-duty options incorporate a flexible neoprene bootie within and extending beyond a rubber shell surrounding the foot. The added warmth is worth the extra investment if you live in a cold-weather climate.

Tread

You won’t really know how grippy an outsole is or how well it sheds debris until you’re out in the field, but some basic knowledge can steer you in the right direction. Quality tread is based on the amount of grip and traction the sole provides whether that is through grippier material or lug shape and depth.

Deeper lugs are better at biting into the ground but could hang on to mud and muck if the lugs aren’t spaced far enough apart. Dirt has less room to get stuck in the shallower nooks and crannies created by shorter lugs, but those won’t provide the same traction. Still, it’s enough to keep you from slipping on slick pavement or uneven terrain.

Cut and Style

A low- or mid-cut boot is more comfortable in than higher cuts because there’s less rubber, and more open space for your legs and ankles to breathe, and release heat. That being said, a high-cut option saves you from getting a boot full of mud when you’re wading through deep bogs.

There’s also the classic duck boot, which is typically lighter and has a unique upper made of both rubber and full-grain-leather. These boots are more suitable if you plan on wearing them primarily for tracking across slushy sidewalks or muddy paths as opposed to deep waters.

Finding the Right Fit

Ordering the proper size mud boots can be a particular challenge. Tall slip-on designs tend to have roomy ankles so your foot can get in and out easily, but this can invite blisters as your foot slides within the boot. Choosing a duck boot with traditional laces offers the most customizable fit but requires more time to put on and take off.

No matter the height or lacing style, models generally come in only whole sizes. What’s more, some brands default to “unisex” sizes based on men’s feet. For the best fit, find gender-specific shoes and consult a brand’s sizing chart. A good rule of thumb for people in between sizes is to choose the smaller of the two, unless you’ll frequently wear them with thick socks.

How We Selected

After vetting 27 models based on construction, features, style, and cost, we tested several pairs near our eastern Pennsylvania headquarters in early winter. Recent rain showers made for fertile testing grounds during our use testing, but first we started with head-to-head comparisons about weight, waterproofing, and cleanability.

In order to test each pair of boots equally, we weighed each individual boot on a scale, submerged them in 3.5 inches of water and potting soil for an hour, hosed down the boots to test how easy it was to clean, and of course, wore them on trails, in backyards, on farms, walking through creeks, through fields, and on sidewalks.

For the boots we did not test in-person, we considered key criteria such as the external material, shape and design, and paid close attention to verified customer reviews.

There’s no shortage of work boots out there, and many are even waterproof. But when your work is happening on a farm or anywhere with a lot of water, you’ll want easy-to-clean, waterproof rubber, not water-resistant leather. We like the Classic Ultra from Bogs.

The handles on both sides helped us get the boot on and off easily. We found a comfortable platform in the spongy yet stable midsole and excellent arch support, a rarity within the category.

Where other boots slipped on loose grain and hay, the Classic Ultra didn’t falter. The rubber shell didn’t hang on to much dirt, and what was left behind rinsed off cleanly. Despite topping out as the heaviest boot in the test, the weight felt less bothersome on our foot. Just be aware: The Classic Ultra runs small. Buy one size up.

Shop Women’s | Shop Men’s

You might know Dunlop as a tire maker, but the company name has produced boots for more than 90 years now with this uninsulated Chesapeake being its best for waterproof protection.

The PVC upper has many of the same benefits as rubber, just in a lighter trim. It likely won’t have the same long-term durability, but our new test pair was as impenetrable as the competition. Aggressive lugs create an outsole that handled well along a sandy creek bank and on inclines, despite a few twigs and pebbles occasionally getting stuck.

It’s an incredible deal, though one that missing the mark on some level of comfort. There’s no shock-absorbing midsole or rigid heel cup to prevent twisting an ankle. The “unisex” fit wasn’t perfect either; our female tester’s foot slid around inside the boot, though she never experienced any blisters.

We recommend men go one size down and women go three sizes down. Ultimately, we don’t think these weaknesses should be deal breakers for everyone. Where it counts most, Dunlop doesn’t disappoint, and that makes the waterproof Chesapeake a reliable pick for warm days or anyone on a tight budget.

When gearing up for a cold, wet day outdoors, we reach for this pair of these rubber boots from Muck. The 5mm-thick neoprene bootie offers much-needed insulation, but we found a standout feature in the fleece lining. This cozy interior could pass for our favorite pair of winter socks were it not for all the rubber. But once we head into a muddy mess, we’re glad for that rubber.

Water and mud fall away from the boot easily, even on the lugged outsole, which gripped on a variety of surfaces without issue. (For slick winter conditions, we recommend the similar Arctic Ice instead. Its Vibram Arctic Grip sole has performed exceptionally well on snow and ice.) Another critical feature: the slightly springy EVA midsole. It’s supportive like your favorite sneaker, so full days of use passed by without any fatigue.

We also appreciate how easy it was to slide our foot into the wide opening. Getting the Sport off was slightly more challenging and often caused our sock to slip slightly.

Shop Women’s | Shop Men’s

A rubber boot’s wide opening makes it easy to get on and off, but if you like the security that comes with a close-fitting style, choose this unisex Pioneer from Dunlop. The flexible neoprene-esque Purotex on the upper felt like a thin foam sleeve gently hugging our calf.

The heel counter anchored our foot in place, something no other boot managed to do as well. We appreciated this feature all the more given that this boot runs big. We suggest ordering one size down for men and three sizes down for women. Dunlop skips rubber in the upper and outsole in favor of its durable polyurethane-based Purofort material.

We plowed through mud, slush, and wet grass without slipping or a single drop of water getting in. Given the design, we weren’t surprised that we felt warmer in the Pioneer than other boots. Still, this pricey and slightly heavy pair was one of the most comfortable we’ve tried. The tight fit ensures this mud boot won’t get trapped no matter how deep the mud puddle, so you can move ahead freely.

As the temperature rises, the heat-trapping power of neoprene quickly becomes suffocating. Stay dry without overheating in the women’s-only mud boot from Kamik. This boot skips insulation and opts for synthetic rubber that’s just as waterproof as the natural stuff yet weighs less and keeps the price tag in check.

The relatively thin upper also saves weight. Our test sample measured just south of 1.25 pounds, a considerably low figure for a taller boot like this. We appreciated this lightweight build and the cushy foam insole when our biggest obstacles were large puddles on the sidewalk. The small lugs on the outsole fit this light-duty use, too, but lent more grip than a casual boot would. As for fit, the toe box is tight and narrow, and there’s hardly any room between the insole and the top of the shoe.

Our foot felt cramped in the low-volume design, though from a length perspective, we would have been better off sizing up anyway. (We recommend following the European size chart, if you’re familiar with that, as it seems to be more accurate than the U.S. version.) This mud boot has a plain silhouette (a good thing) and comes in more than half a dozen muted or bright colors. Pair your favorite with any spring or summer clothes when rain showers are in the forecast.

Perhaps no shoe has more staying power than L.L. Bean’s original duck boot, which the brand first made in 1912. For some, it’s an all-weather wardrobe staple. Others wear it as a fashion statement. Regardless, the iconic half rubber, half full-grain-leather design has the chops to see you through rain puddles or gnarlier turf.

The company offers several heights and models, such as a Thinsulate-lined option for cold-weather use. We like the flexibility of the uninsulated eight-inch boot. Our tester wore a size smaller than her usual and found the boot was still roomy enough to pair with a chunky sock in cold weather. A large majority of mud boots are slip-on, and that makes the regular lacing employed here distinct in a good way.

Yes, it takes a bit more time to put them on and take them off, but it’s worth it for a dialed-in fit. The leather on the upper is more breathable than rubber or neoprene, though not as easy to clean and less waterproof. Nearly 1.75 ounces of water seeped into our test pair during the waterproof test. (If you want a truly waterproof option, choose the Gore-Tex model.) But when you won’t be tromping calf-deep in mud or standing in water for hours at a time, the L.L. Bean Boot is a great blend of protection and style.

Shop Women’s | Shop Men’s

Other Rubber Boots to Consider

Forget about pulling your rubber boots on and yanking them off at the end of the day. These mud boots from Xtratuf are designed with a wide opening so they're easy to get in and out of, without being so loose that they don't feel secure on your feet.

Each pair also comes with two finger loops on the front and back of the opening. Beyond the fit, the exterior can handle day-to-day wear in addition to life on the water. These boots are best served as deck boots, though with more than a dozen colors and patterns available, they're stylish enough for other activities, too.

The shorter ankle length makes them a more comfortable option, but the shoes lack the deep lugs that serve well in mud and on hikes and are best suited for flat surfaces.

Shop Women's | Shop Men's

If the L.L. Bean duck boots aren't quite what you're looking for, consider this pair from Sperry. With the same mix of rubber and leather upper, you have protection against low levels of water and mud while gaining significant breathability over fully rubber options.

While not fully waterproof, the leather on these rubber boots are treated so they're stain- and water-resistant. As for the fit and feel, they feature a memory foam footbed for added comfort.

The rubber outsole also comes with wave-style lugs built for traction, but they aren'd deep enough to get rocks or sticks stuck in between your footing. While the boots are exclusive to men, you can buy a similar pair of Sperry duck boots for women.

You Might Also Like

• The Do’s and Don’ts of Using Painter’s Tape

• The Best Portable BBQ Grills for Cooking Anywhere

• Can a Smart Watch Prolong Your Life?