Here Are the 6 Secrets to Evaluating a Tax Preparation Service

Ben Luthi
·6 min read

Advertiser Disclosure: At Slickdeals, we work hard to find the best deals. Some products in our articles are from partners who may provide us with compensation, but this doesn’t change our opinions.

Filing your tax return every year might feel like it’s a necessary evil. But if you’re one of the roughly three-quarters of Americans who receives a refund, according to the IRS, the payoff is worth it. Even if you don’t, failing to file your taxes could cause you to face harsh penalties, including jail time.

>>MORE: 9 Best and Cheapest Online Tax Services in 2021

Based on IRS filing statistics for 2020, most people hire a tax professional to prepare and file their tax return. But if you’re thinking about filing on your own, you may be considering a tax preparation service to help you do it.

The Difference Between Hiring a Professional and Using Software

You may be wondering if you should file your tax return on your own or hire a tax professional to do it for you. The biggest differences between the two options are cost and effort. According to data gathered by the National Society of Accountants, you can expect to pay $188 on average if you hire a professional to file a simple federal and state return.

In contrast, most tax preparation services offer free options, and even the paid options are cheaper than having someone else do it for you.

That said, once you hand off all of your paperwork to a professional, you’re done. They’ll take care of the entire process from start to finish, filing your return on your behalf. All you need to do is pay their fee and wait for your refund to roll in.

If you were to go with a tax preparation software — which, again, is generally cheaper — you’d need to do it yourself. Fortunately, these services will guide you through the process by asking relevant questions, and you can generally get help if you have questions. But regardless, you can expect more legwork if you do it on your own.

6 Ways to Compare Tax Preparation Services

If you’re considering a tax preparation service because of the promise of free or cheap filing, it’s important to avoid using the first one you see. While they all have the same basic function of helping you prepare and file your return, they’re not all created equal. Here are six factors to consider as you shop around.

1. Cost

As previously mentioned, most tax preparation services offer a free option. What’s covered under that free tier, however, can vary. For example, TurboTax has come under fire for enticing customers with promises of free filing, but it’s very limited, and many get directed to a paid service instead, even if their situation didn’t merit the up-charge.

In contrast, Credit Karma offers a fully free tax preparation service, but it doesn’t offer some of the more complicated features that other services do. Other services with free tiers include TaxAct, H&R Block and Liberty Tax.

As you compare costs, make sure you know what’s included in each tier and compare that to what you need to file your return. If paying some money makes sense for your situation, shop around to make sure you’re getting the biggest bang for your buck.

2. Ease of Use

Even with guidance, the tax preparation process can be confusing, so it may be worth going through at least some of your return with more than one service to get an idea of how easy they are to use.

You’ll also want to look into how they handle customer service if you have questions — is there someone available to talk to via chat, or do you have to wait a few days to get a response via email?

3. Tax Forms Supported

One of Credit Karma’s biggest flaws is that it doesn’t support all tax forms. This won’t be a problem for most taxpayers, but it can be frustrating to go through the process only to find out you have to start all over somewhere else.

As you narrow down your list of candidates, search the website to find out which forms are and aren’t supported, so you know beforehand which ones can do what you need.

4. Features

Filing your taxes can be a stressful experience, so look for features that could potentially make your life during tax season a little easier. For example, is there an option to speak live with a CPA to ask questions about a complicated situation? Do they guarantee accuracy? How many educational resources do they provide to help you learn more about the process so you can feel more confident about doing your own taxes?

Do a thorough rundown for each service to get an idea of which features are included.

5. Audit Assistance

To be clear, the chances of the IRS auditing your tax return are slim — the agency audited just 0.45% of individual returns and 1.6% of business returns in 2019. If it does happen to you, though, you’re not going to want to go through it alone.

Audit assistance is actually one of the benefits of hiring a professional to file your return, but it’s not required. Many tax preparation services offer it. Just be sure to read the fine print so you know what’s included.

6. Payment and Refund Process

If you owe money to the IRS, figure out what the payment process is for each service. For example, can you pay your tax bill with a credit card, or do you have to pay from a bank account? If you’re expecting a refund, how easy is it to add your bank account information to receive direct deposit?

Also, some services will offer refund advances, giving you access to your cash before the IRS completes a review of your return. However, some may charge a fee for this service or put the money on a prepaid debit card instead of giving you cold hard cash.

The best online tax services offer a mix of value, a good experience, and features that give you some peace of mind. Take your time to compare options, so you can file your return with confidence.

>>PROMO: Get 35% Off Federal Tax E-filing with TaxSlayer

>>EARN: Biggest Bank Bonuses Right Now: Cash Promos for Opening New Deposit Accounts

>>SAVE: Best Free Checking Accounts: Most People Can Save Around $144

>>INVEST: Biggest Brokerage Bonuses: Earn Promo Cash and Free Stock

>>RECOVER: How to Improve Your Credit Score Quickly for Free

While we work hard on our research, we do not always provide a complete listing of all available offers from credit-card companies and banks. And because offers can change, we cannot guarantee that our information will always be up to date, so we encourage you to verify all the terms and conditions of any financial product before you apply.