21 of our favorite—but problematic AF—fictional queer women

We love these problematic queer women.

Focus Pictures/A24/MGMStudios

Wholesome queer content is great... but what about the joys of deliciously depraved, decadently problematic queer content?

Of course, we want to see queer characters who don’t fit into tropes, who aren’t damaging stereotypes, and who are heroes. But also, sometimes we want to get down and dirty. Sometimes it's fun to revel in characters who take control and just do whatever the hell they want.

Real-life people are problematic. Real love is problematic. And these shows and movies celebrate that. At the end of the day, we are messy queers and sometimes we just want to watch other messy queers.

In the last year, we’ve had a ton of great new problematic lesbians to love! With the release of movies like Bottoms, Drive-Away Dolls, and Love Lies Bleeding, messy queer women are all the rage!

Here are 21 of our favorite problematic lesbians, bisexuals, and queer women. Who's your's?

Beverly and Elliot Mantle from 'Dead Ringers'

Amazon Prime Video

Dead Ringers is a beautiful, hilarious, twisted, sexy, and disorienting fever dream, and it’s exactly the kind of queer TV show we need right now.

Based on the classic Cronenberg movie from the ’80s, Dead Ringers follows Beverly and Elliot Mantle, two of the most brilliant doctors in the world who are also twin sisters (Beverly is a lesbian and Elliot is pansexual). With the help of a billionaire lesbian and her wife, they open a new birthing center, hoping to revolutionize a type of healthcare that millions of women (and some others) need access to every year. From there, the twins spiral into success, madness, love, and obsession.

While Dead Ringers is firmly in the thriller genre, it’s also a Vantablack comedy and even isn't afraid to swerve into camp, with Elliot gorging on food like Saturn devouring his son in nearly every scene she’s in, the twins calling each other “delicious,” and a penultimate episode that travels to a Southern Gothic house full of a family of twins headed by a disturbing male gynecologist. Rachel Weisz needs to win an Emmy (it's a shame she can’t win two) for playing Beverly and Elliott, twin brilliant gynecologists bent on changing the way the birthing industry works in America.

While the twins are unmistakably sisters, they couldn’t be more different, and Weisz brings brilliant subtleties to each role. The series also has an incredible writer in Alice Birch and incredible directors like Karyn Kusama, who should all also be winning Emmys this year.

Why They're Problematic: Dead Ringers isn’t afraid at all to lean into the codependency that turns into a twisted queer romance between the sisters. Elliot makes out with her sister’s neck, Beverly says “I want to crawl inside you,” they stop just short of passionately kissing on the mouth; these sisters are in love, your honor. And that’s just the beginning of what makes these wonderful characters so problematic, there’s also the drugs, deception, murder, and illegal cloning.

Why We Love Them: That fearlessness is one of the things that makes it so great. While Republican lawmakers and angry teens online will tell you that there’s nothing worse than a “problematic queer person,” most of us are smart enough to know that without being problematic, most characters are boring.

To be human is to be filled with flaws, weird ticks, trauma, and problematic thoughts and behaviors. And the best art that we can produce shows that and examines it. If we ignore what makes us problematic, we ignore what makes us human.
Dead Ringers asks what is love, what is womanhood, what is sisterhood, what is genius, and what is happiness, and it finds that none of the answers are clear. The only clear thing about this show is that it is a true masterpiece. Dead Ringers is currently streaming on Prime Video.

Lou and Jackie from 'Love Lies Bleeding'

A24

Why They’re Problematic: Where do we start? Lou and Jackie are trouble from the moment we meet them, with Jackie’s hair-trigger temper causing her to throw punches and headbutts whenever she gets angry. Both women are literal murderers, and their relationship is volatile, filled with screaming matches, insults, and physical violence.

Why We Love Them: Still, we can’t help but root for these two lovebirds! We don’t know if its the way they both look so dykey, or the fact that they are a loudly queer couple living in a small town in the ’80s, or the fact that they have the best chemistry we’ve ever seen in a movie, but we want them to overcome all obstacles and end up together.

Josie and PJ from 'Bottoms'

MGM Studios

Why They’re Problematic: These girls are the ultimate loser dykes. Aside from judging all of the girls around them based on looks, PJ and Josie (played by Rachel Sennott and Ayo Edebiri) actually start a fight club at their school hoping that they can “trick” cheerleaders into joining and eventually sleeping with them.

Why We Love Them: Like we said, these are the ultimate loser dykes, and we love that about them!!! We can all relate to the feeling of being a loser in high school, and even though these girls maybe went about things the wrong way, we can’t stay mad at them.

Carol Aird from 'Carol'

The Weinstein Company

Why She’s Problematic: In the original book that Carol is based on, The Price of Salt, Carol Aird is 32 years old and her love interest Therese is only 19. Both characters have been aged-up in the movie, but there’s still about a 15-year age gap between the sophisticated Carol and naive Therese.

Why We Love Her: Carol is also one of the best lesbian movies ever made, based on one of the best lesbian books ever made. Cate Blanchett was nominated for a much-deserved Oscar for her role. Plus, we all have mommy issues, so of course we love Carol.

Jamie from 'Drive-Away Dolls'

Focus Features

Why She’s Problematic: From the moment we first meet Jamie (Margaret Qualley), she’s flirting with other women in front of her girlfriend. When she and her bestie Marian find out the car they are driving to Tallahassee has a mysterious suitcase in the trunk, Jamie decides they should hold the suitcase hostage from the criminals chasing them.

Why We Love Her: While she may get you into trouble, Jamie will also get you out of it. She’s a fierce friend to Marian, and is always pushing her to live her best life. Plus, by the end of the movie, we see that she actually does make a pretty good partner

Janice Imi'ike from 'Mean Girls (2024)'

Paramount

Why She’s Problematic: Well, Janis is, like the name of the movie says, a mean girl. Along with her gay BFF Damien, she convinces Cady to trick Regina George into gaining weight, using lard for face cream, and embarrassing herself in front of the whole school. Even though she’s justified in wanting revenge for Regina outing her, she did some terrible things.

Why We Love Her: In this new version of Mean Girls, Tina Fey did what she always should’ve done and made Janis canonically a lesbian. Brought to life by the amazing Auli’i Cravalho, this version of Janis is the lesbian icon she was always meant to be, and one of the most relatable queer high school characters we’ve ever seen.

Catra from 'She-Ra and the Princesses of Power'

Netflix

Why She’s Problematic: Early on in She-Ra, Catra openly admits that she knows the Horde are the bad guys, but she refuses to leave. She commits a lot of war crimes and then tries to destroy the whole universe. She also spends a lot of time trying to kill her ex-BFF (and crush) Adora.

Why We Love Her: Catra is also one of the best and most well-rounded lesbian characters in all of kids and family media. Her journey from traumatized and abused teen to an adult who’s trying to work on her own issues and grow, and her journey into love with Adora, forever changed the way kids TV portrays gay characters.

Leighton Murray from 'Sex Lives of College Girls'

Max

Why She’s Problematic: Leighton is a bully and a mean rich girl. She thinks she’s better than everyone else and thinks she can buy her way out of trouble. She’s exactly the type of girl we wouldn’t want to be friends with in college.

Why We Love Her: That is, until she starts to show some growth. While Leighton never loses her edge, after she has to start volunteering at the women’s center, she softens up a bit and opens up to her friends, even coming out as a lesbian.

Emily Dickinson from 'Dickinson'

Apple TV+

Why She’s Problematic: Just like in real life, Emily in Dickinson is in love with her sister-in-law Sue. At first that might not sound too bad, especially compared to others on this list. But she makes it more problematic when, in the pilot episode, Sue is mourning the death of her blood sister when Emily says “I’ll be your sister now” right before the two make out.

Why We Love Her: Emily Dickinson is one of the greatest poets of all time. Also, Hailee Steinfeld’s hilarious, snarky, and down-to-earth portrayal of her brought her to life in an all-new way for an all-new generation.

Ginger Fitzgerald from 'Ginger Snaps'

Lionsgate

Why She’s Problematic: Okay, yes, Ginger does kill a bunch of people when she turns into a werewolf, but that’s not what really earns her a spot on this list. She also has a definitely queer, codependent relationship with her sister Brigitte. At one point, she even climbs on top of her and tries to seduce her into becoming a werewolf with her by saying, “We’re almost not even related anymore.”

Why We Love Her: Ginger Snaps is a cult classic, and we love the way it openly talks about girls going through puberty, periods, and transformations. It’s a great, feminist movie that we’ll watch again and again.

Greta Gill from 'A League of Their Own'

Prime Video

Why She’s Problematic: Greta is a player (and not just the baseball kind), there’s no way around it. Because of the time and world she’s living in, she’s made rules to not fall in love, and if that means she has to hurt Carson, so be it.

Why We Love Her: Aside from the fact that Greta (played by D'Arcy Carden) is a drop-dead gorgeous bombshell, we can understand where her set of rules comes from. Yes, she might break girls' hearts all across the country, but she’s still got a special place in ours.

Harley Quinn and Poison Ivy from the DC Comics universe

HBO Max

Why They’re Problematic: Harley Quinn and Poison Ivy are supervillains. They kill hundreds (if not thousands!) of people all the time in their schemes to rob banks, take over Gotham City, and turn the world into a plant-based paradise.

Why We Love Them: They’re also our favorite comic book couple! Harlivy has become one of the biggest ships in all of comics recently and has jumped to the silver screen in HBO’s terrific animated Harley Quinn show. These two are just so darn cute together!

Lydia Tár from 'Tár'

Focus Features

Why She’s Problematic: While Lydia Tár is an unquestioned genius, the power that she’s gained has allowed her to become a predator who seeks out young musicians and students to sleep with them and then spit them out when she’s done with them.

Why We Love Her: Again, Cate Blanchett is delivering the goods in portraying complex queer women. She was nominated for another Oscar for the role, giving us a prestige lesbian antihero.

Manuela from 'Madchen in Uniform'

Bild und Ton GmbH

Why She’s Problematic: Manuela is a fourteen-year-old girl who lost her mother when she was young. At school, she meets Fraulein von Bernburg, a kind teacher. She quickly falls in love with her teacher/mother figure.

Why We Love Her: Madchen in Uniform (1931) is one of the first sympathetic portrayals of lesbian characters in film history. Neither Manuela nor Fraulein von Bernburg dies and both characters are shown to be real people with real feelings. Simply put, it’s one of the greatest and best lesbian movies ever made.

Marla Grayson from 'I Care a Lot'

Netflix

Why She’s Problematic: The entire premise of I Care a Lot is that Marla is a professional con artist who scams old people by drugging them up and putting them in nursing homes so she can steal their money. That's pretty evil.

Why We Love Her: Still, Marla was a firecracker and a true delight to watch. Played by Rosamund Pike, who won a Golden Globe for her role, Marla is deliciously sharp and has a wicked tongue and sense of style.

Santana Lopez from 'Glee'

Fox

Why She’s Problematic: Santana was a "straight-up bitch," as she so eloquently put it herself. Whether she was destroying Kurt, Finn, or Rachel in the hallways of McKinley High, Santana always had something negative to say. She was the ultimate high school (and later, college) bully.

Why We Love Her: Santana was also the first queer Latina many viewers saw on TV and changed the way lesbians are portrayed in media. While she started off as a pretty one-note character, she grew into someone with depth who was a part of some of Glee's best storylines. Played by the legendary Naya Rivera, Santana Lopez gave birth to an entire generation of gay mean girls.

Abby McEnany from 'Work in Progress'

Showtime

Why She’s Problematic: Abby is a misanthrope and nihilist, but her selfish attitude alone doesn’t get her on this list. She also deadnamed her trans masc partner in a fight, including screaming it in the street.

Why We Love Her: Work in Progress is one of the most complex portrayals of queer characters on TV ever. While she is definitely problematic, she's also trying to grow and learn — something we should all take a lesson from.

Shane McCutcheon from 'The L Word: Generation Q'

Showtime

Why She’s Problematic: Shane is the ultimate cheater and f*boi. She’s so associated with cheating and sleeping around that we compare every lesbian f*boi character after her, to her.

Why We Love Her: Again, we compare everyone to her. For many queer women, The L Word was our introduction to queer relationships and lesbian sex, and Shane is a huge part of that. How many people did she help with their sexual awakening? We can never hate her for that!

Taissa Turner from 'Yellowjackets'

Showtime

Why She’s Problematic: Like the rest of her high school soccer team that survived in the Canadian Rockies, Taissa is a cannibal and a murderer. Even as an adult she can’t help but get drawn back into the drama of violence and secrets.

Why We Love Her: Played by Jasmin Savoy Brown (one of our faves!) and Tawny Cypress, Taissa is a badass and high-achiever. The scenes between teen Taissa and her friend/girlfriend Van are intimate and heartfelt, giving us a sweet reprieve from all the blood and horror of the wilderness.

Tiffany Valentine from 'Chucky'

USA Network/SyFy

Why She’s Problematic: Another serial killer! Tiffany will happily kidnap and murder anyone who gets in her way — or anyone who she thinks it would be fun to kill.

Why We Love Her: Tiffany got really queer in the Chucky TV show when Charles Lee Ray possessed the body of a woman named Nica and Tiffany had a great time getting to know her partner in love and murder in a whole new body. She’s a camp queen.

Villanelle in 'Killing Eve'

BBC America

Why She’s Problematic: Okay, yes, Villanelle is a psychopathic assassin and serial killer. That’s pretty problematic.

Why We Love Her: But damn, if we don’t ship her so hard with Eve Polastri, the British Intelligence investigator chasing her and trying to arrest her. How can we not love Jodie Comer and Sandra Oh?