24 Customer Favorite Items from Wayfair with More Than 1,000 5-Star Reviews

editor@purewow.com (PureWow)
·11 min read

We love shopping for our home as the weather gets warm again—even more so if when we know a major sale is just around the corner. We're of course talking about Wayfair's (link to wayfair homepage) famous Way Day. While we don't know details on the sale yet, we're getting ready to stock up on some bestsellers, like this outdoor umbrella, this set of pillow covers and this down alternative comforter.

If you’re looking to give your home a summer refresh from Wayfair, it must be fate that you’re here because we’ve gathered 24 favorites from the site that have more than 1,000 five-star reviews for you to consider adding to your space.

24 Customer Favorite Wayfair Items At A Glance:

RELATED: The Best Outdoor Furniture Under $200 So You Can Afford to Give Your Backyard a Facelift

1. Arlmont & Co. Ausonia Market Umbrella

Best Outdoor Umbrella

Why Customers Love It:

  • 7,231 five-star ratings

  • "Have had my brick red umbrella up all summer and it has not faded in the Florida sun and has survived a number of windstorms."

Keep cool in the sun under an umbrella that offers UV protection and can tilt at the neck for when the sun changes positions. This one is available in eight colors.

Buy It ($130; $57)

2. Winston Porter Brentten Apothecary Jar Set

Best Glass Jars

Why Customers Love It:

  • 1,050 five-star ratings

  • "These apothecary jars are a timeless decoration. You can put lights in them and they are gorgeous. They are a good size and a great price. They will go nicely in any room"

We'll definitely be adding these jars to our bathroom to hold our Q-tips, scrunchies and cotton swaps in a cute way.

Buy It ($60; $44)

3. Ebern Designs Shoe Storage Bench

Best Shoe Storage Bench

Why Customers Love It:

  • 1,293 five-star ratings

  • "I bought two because I loved the first one !! Very functional!"

Whether you use this beauty for shoes, blankets or anything else, this useful bench has adjustable shelves and is available in three wood shades.

Buy It ($104; $97)

4. Wayfair Basics Solid Black Out Grommet Curtains

Best Black-Out Curtains

Why Customers Love It:

  • 10,910 five-star ratings

  • "I love how they look in my porch. Curtains are made very well. Beautiful colors."

Available in 24 colors, these black-out curtains will keep the sunshine out on bright on sunny mornings when you want to sleep in.

Buy It ($20; $13)

5. Arlmont & Co. Cora Double Camping Hammock

Best Hammock

Why Customers Buy It:

  • 1,453 five-star ratings

  • "I've had this for almost two years now. Still looks great, still comfortable, still love it."

Attach this hammock between two trees or grab a stand to hold it comfortably too.

Buy It ($98; $81)

6. Willa Arlo Interiors Edgar Square Pillow Cover

Best Pillow Covers

Why Customers Love It:

  • 3,293 five-star ratings

  • "I love the pillow covers. Perfect color, perfect texture, Wayfair is the way to go!"

Switch up your pillow covers for spring and summer. These are available in 18 colors and three sizes.

Buy It ($60; $26)

7. Wayfair Sleep Down Alternative Comforter

Best Comforter

Why Customers Love It:

  • 2,980 five-star ratings

  • "This down alternative comforter is wonderful. The best part are the corners with loops to tie a duvet to it!"

Add a cute duvet cover to this comfy down alternative comforter. The quilted squares will keep the filling evenly distributed so you don't have to adjust.

Buy It ($150; $47)

8. Lodge Enamel Cast Iron Dutch Oven

Best Dutch Oven

Why Customers love it:

  • 1,666 five-star ratings

  • "Gorgeous piece. Cleans really easily. Retains heat and evenly distributes it. Love the purchase and look forward to using it for years to come."

Cook your cobblers, stews, bread and more in this handy pot. Choose between the eight gorgeous colors and four sizes.

Buy It ($93; $65)

9. Orren Ellis Aneysa Cotton Towel Set

Best Towels

Why Customers Love It:

  • 3,920 five-star ratings

  • "These towels are great! Super absorbent and so soft. A great deal for this bundle."

Upgrade your bathroom linens to this super soft, 100 percent cotton 24-piece set.

Buy It ($280; $55)

10. Zevro Double Cereal Dispenser

Best Cereal Dispenser

Why Customers Love It:

  • 5,550 five-star ratings

  • "I love them. They hold a lot of cereal and they're perfect for my coffee bar and my grandchildren."

Make your kitchen more fun for your kids by adding this double cereal dispenser to hold their favorite breakfast.

Buy It ($68; $31)

11. Joss & Main Skye Oriental Terracotta Area Rug

Best Rug

Why Customers Love It:

  • 2,716 five-star ratings

  • “Love the rug! The colors and pattern make it look like an antique Persian rug. It’s really soft and lays down perfectly flat. I’ll be buying more.”

Spice up your hallway with this decorative rug. The antique design will add a flare to your space that wall hangings can’t give. You can even get a matching one for your family room.

Buy It ($169; $109)

12. Sol 72 Outdoor Merton Rattan Sectional Seating

Best Outdoor Sectional

Why Customers Love It:

  • 1,308 five-star reviews

  • “I love everything about it. So versatile! I love moving things around and this set allows me just that. [It's also] very easy to assemble. I’m very happy with my purchase.”

Cozy up on this seven-piece outdoor sectional with friends and family this summer. This weather- and UV-resistant set comes with the cushions, so no extra purchase necessary!

Buy It ($590; $540)

13. Greyleigh Needville Modern & Contemporary Accent Mirror

Best Accent Mirror

Why Customers Love It:

  • 5,206 five-star reviews

  • “This mirror is exactly what I was looking for. Very high quality for the price. I highly recommend it!”

This simple mirror will add a trendy touch to any living space. The modern metal framing is super-versatile, making it easy to keep even when you’re switching up your color scheme.

Buy It ($232; $192)

14. Willa Arlo Interiors Tibo Bar Cart

Best Bar Cart

Why Customers Love It:

  • 1,663 five-star ratings

  • “Beautiful cart! Very sturdy, easy to put together and it is STUNNING! We have received countless compliments on it and it shipped so quickly!”

This bar cart can house your favorite bottles, glasses and decanters. Who says storage can’t be glamorous? It also has wheels that lock, so you can easily move it closer to your guests.

Buy It ($360)

15. Cuisinart Coffee Center

Best Coffee Pot

Why Customers Love It:

  • 8,143 five-star ratings

  • “Absolutely love it, it’s gorgeous! I love that I can make a full pot or just make one cup with a K-cup or just make hot water for tea. I highly recommend it."

Calling all coffee lovers: This machine can make you a single cup of coffee or a whole pot if you need it. If you’re getting sick of your Keurig but love the ease of K-cups, no worries, because they’re compatible with the single-serve feature. Program to brew by itself for you in the mornings so even if you’re running late, your coffee is ready to pour.

Buy It ($365; $200)

16. Andover Mills Petrone Combo Laundry Center

Best Laundry Basket

Why Customers Love It:

  • 6,103 five-star ratings

  • “I really like it, it’s not too big and not too small. It’s a perfect size for our room and I love that you have the top portion that folds up or down so you can iron on it.”

Make laundry easier with this three-in-one hamper. Sort by clothing type or family member for maximum organization. The bags are removable to effortlessly grab and dump the clothes right into the washing machine.

Buy It ($103; $75)

17. The Twillery Co. Acosta Reversible Quilt Set

Best Quilt Set

Why Customers Love It:

  • 17,269 five-star ratings

  • “I absolutely love this quilt! It’s so well-made and feels so soft to touch. Exactly as pictured, definitely exceeded my expectations.”

Update your bedding to accommodate the warmer weather with a light and breathable quilt. This set is machine washable and reversible.

Buy It ($100; $48)

18. Birch Lane Lockridge Double Dresser

Best Dresser

Why Customers Love It:

  • 3,433 five-star ratings

  • “We’ve had this dresser for two plus years and still comment on how much we LOVE IT! It’s built so well and looks awesome.”

If you love the farmhouse style home décor, this dresser is for you. It houses nine spacious drawers for all of your clothing, and it comes assembled (so no confusing directions).

Buy It ($1,020; $957)

19. NineStars Stainless Steel Motion Sensor Trash Can

Best Trash Can

Why Customers Love It:

  • 3,485 five-star ratings

  • “I love it! Just right for my kitchen and matches my kitchen appliances perfectly!”

Never touch a dirty trash can lid again with one that opens automatically. This one is 13.2 gallons and is most likely compatible with your go-to trash bags. Plus, it has finger-print resistant coating.

Buy It ($73; $59)

20. ClosetMaid Cabinet Door Organizer

Best Cabinet Organizers

Why Customers Love It:

  • 3,828 five-star ratings

  • “I love it! I had no trouble putting it together, all the parts were present and it looks great! It fits perfectly in our half bath as storage for some cleaning supplies and sundries.”

Say no to cluttered cabinets and pantries with this steel organizer. It holds over 50 pounds and you can adjust the wire shelves to whatever height you prefer.

Buy It ($58; $47)

21. Devoe Wagon Wheel Chandelier

Best Chandelier

Why Customers Love It:

  • 5,300 five-star ratings

  • "We got the bronze light fixture, and it is absolutely gorgeous! I am in love, and it adds great character, and it's simple and classic. Perfect for our nine-foot ceiling living room. We ended up taking all the links out and installing it. Super easy. We get compliments on it all the time!"

Want to elevate your living space? Try a chandelier. This wagon wheel-shaped one is great for illuminating, brightening, and adding shine to any room (or even an entryway or staircase).

Buy It ($254; $152)

22. Alfredo Tufted Velvet Side Chair

Best Velvet Chair

Why Customers Love It:

  • 3,278 five-star ratings

  • "Think no more buy them! These chairs bring such warmth and style to my living room. They do sit low, which is what I needed because my sofa is a little low, and I need everything to be on the same level. Nice velvet material and nice to the touch."

If you add this velvet accent chair to any room, it will instantly give it a more chic and sophisticated feel. (BTW: It comes in 17 beautiful bright and muted colors.

Buy It ($245)

23. Marlon Low Profile Bed

Best Bed Frame

Why Customers Love It:

  • 2,268 five-star ratings

  • "I can’t stress enough how much I love this bed! I downsized my bedroom when we built our house, and I wanted a simple bed that didn’t dwarf my room like my old bed with huge posts would have done. This bed makes my small room feel bigger."

Your bed sets the tone for your entire bedroom. If you're not satisfied with the one you have now, this one is a great option. It gives the bedroom a modern, rich flair. In other words, this is a bed you won't get tired of (no pun intended).

Buy It ($1,689; $945)

24. Bartolomeus Stone Outdoor Fire Pit

Best Fire Pit

Why Customers Love It:

  • 2,559 five-star ratings

  • "It definitely looks like real stone, heavy enough to stay put but easy enough to pull one-handed to move around. Height is good for keeping your legs warm."

Fire pits have been huge over the past year. The good thing about this one is you can get a serious bang for your buck. It features a wire mesh screen, which protects against flying sparks (because safety is important!), and it's easy to clean.

Buy It ($619)

RELATED: 25 of the Most Random-But-Useful Wayfair Products to Watch Out for on Way Day

PureWow may receive a portion of sales from products purchased from this article, which was created independently from PureWow's editorial and sales departments.