The 10 Best Drugstore Lipsticks Under $20

There’s a method for choosing the perfect lipstick. First, find the color. It should be rich in pigment with the correct undertones that pair perfectly with your skin tone. Second: The formula. You want a creamy lipstick that stays put for hours, better yet, all day long. And finally, the cost. While there are some lippies worth the investment, there’s something oddly satisfying about getting a quality lip color that doesn’t break the bank. Enter: Drugstore lipsticks.

Often overlooked and under-appreciated, there are some drugstore lipsticks that truly deliver. Celebrity makeup artist, Andrew Sotomayor says finding a good lipstick, no matter the price, depends on what’s good for you. “It should feel comfortable on your lips and look beautiful,” he says. “Good lipsticks should also stay put for a reasonable amount of time and be made of non-toxic ingredients.” And even though you can’t swatch on colors before buying in the drugstore, most mass retailers do allow for returns if you’re not satisfied. That way, you’re not stuck with a formula you don’t like.

To help ease your search (and save you money, too), here are the 10 creamiest, most hydrating, smudge-free lipsticks drugstore can offer.