How to Pick the Best Eyeliner for Your Eye Color

By Meirav Devash

The notion of a single “best” liner shade for your eye color is as outdated as eating for your blood type. But certain shades can intensify your natural eye color and, in some cases, even change its appearance. Charlotte Tilbury, the makeup artist behind Colour Chameleon Eyeshadow Pencils, offers her color theories.

FOR BLUE EYES

"Contrasting shades bring out the eye color, so copper and gold make blue eyes appear even bluer," says Tilbury. And when warm metallics pick up gold flashes in the iris, they really light up cool blue eyes. Dot just the inner corners, keep the liner tight to the lash line, or fill in the whole lid.

Other colors: Terra-cotta, champagne, navy

Try:

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner in Denim Ink

By Terry Precision Waterproof eyeliner in Gold Ornament

E.L.F. Studio Cream Eyeliner in Copper

See more: 50 Beauty Products to Try Before You Die

FOR GREEN EYES

Red complements green on the color wheel, so pick shades with reddish undertones. “Garnet, amethyst, and bronze are particularly dazzling on green eyes,” she says. However, they can make you look tired, especially if diffused into pinkness. Lining the lid in black first helps.

Other colors: Rust, mahogany, aubergine

Try:

Prestige Waterproof Automatic Eyeliner in Bronze

M.A.C. Technakohl Eye-Liner Kajal in Image Conscious

Essence Eyepencil & Shadow in Chocolate Brownie

FOR BROWN EYES

You can’t go wrong with earthy browns, but “amber and midnight-blue tones emphasize the light flecks in brown eyes,” says Tilbury. If you’re not ready to commit to too much color, line just the waterlines. Rimming the eyes in dark blue gives the same effect as black in a less severe way.

Other colors: Mink gray, purple, cobalt

Try:

Charlotte Tilbury Rock ‘N’ Kohl Eye Pencil in Veruschka Mink

Chanel Long-Lasting Eyeliner in Ambre Doré

Iman Perfect Eye Shadow Pencil in Forbidden

See more: Top Anti-aging Products $25 and Under

FOR HAZEL EYES

"Emerald and gold bring out the green tones in hazel eyes," she says, and warm, neutral browns enhance their richness. Diffuse a green line—or a chocolate-brown one, depending on how colorful you want to go—over the lid. Kick up the radiance with a touch of gold at the inner corner and the center of the lid.

Other colors: Bronze, olive, plum

Try:

Rimmel London Exaggerate Eye Definer in Ripe Plum

L’Oréal Paris Infallible Eye Crayon in Everlasting Gold

Givenchy Color Kajal Eye Pencil Intense Look in 1

More from Allure:

35 Hairstyles to Try in 2015

Find the Best Haircut for Your Face Shape

32 Affordable New Beauty products You Have to Try!

10 Celebrity Hairstyles That Will Make You Look 10 Years Younger

photos: Delphine Achard/WWD, Courtesy of Bobbi Brown, By Terry, E.L.F., Giovanni Giannoni/WWD, Courtesy of Prestige, M.A.C., Essence, Kyle Ericksen/WWD, Courtesy of Charlotte Tilbury, Chanel, Iman, Kyle Ericksen/WWD, Courtesy of Rimmel London, L’Oreal, Givenchy