'Private Equity Companies Have Bought Up Hundreds Of Thousands Of Single Family Homes' - House Subcommittee Addresses Investments In Single-Family Rentals

Kevin Vandenboss

June 29, 2022 at 1:12 PM·3 min read

The House Committee on Financial Services, led by Chairwoman Maxine Waters, Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations held a hearing on June 28, 2022, entitled, “Where Have All the Houses Gone? Private Equity, Single Family Rentals, and America’s Neighborhoods.”

According to the subcommittee chair, Al Green, the committee found that “private equity companies have bought up hundreds of thousands of single-family homes and placed them on the rental market. This removes from the housing market, homes that might otherwise have been purchased by individual homeowners.”

Two high-profile targets of the committee’s recent investigations include real estate investment trusts (REITs) Invitation Homes Inc. (NYSE: INVH) and American Homes 4 Rent (NYSE: AMH).

According to the Committee Memorandum, the subcommittee's investigation found that corporate ownership of single-family rental homes rose significantly following the 2008 financial crisis, growing 3% annually since 2010, with the fastest year-over-year increase being in the third quarter of 2021.

In October 2021, the subcommittee sent a survey to the five largest owners of single-family rentals in the U.S.: Invitation Homes, American Homes 4 Rent, Cerberus Capital Management’s FirstKey Homes, Pretium Partners’ Progress Residential and Amherst Residential.

The survey requested national-level quarterly data, from March 31, 2018, through September 30, 2021, on issues such as the total number of properties each company owns, their methods of acquiring and selling homes, and the value of bonds offered to investors. The survey also requested data from each company on the timeframe for late fees, tenant income, tenant demographics, and eviction rates in the zip codes where the company owned the most rental properties.

The committee analyzed the national-level and ZIP code-level data from each company to understand the industry and company-specific trends over time and analyzed estimate data from the U.S. Census for the same five-year period.

Based on the survey data, the committee found these companies had an aggregate 27% net growth in their housing stock over the survey period, representing a total net property gain of 76,235 single-family rental homes.

These companies acquired homes through multiple channels, including the Multiple Listing Service (MLS), foreclosure auctions and constructing build-to-rent homes. The companies primarily sold homes through bulk sales to other institutional investors, with only 0.5% of their properties being sold to tenants.

The survey data showed these companies purchased homes in neighborhoods with lower home prices and higher rents. The average median home value in the top 20 ZIP codes where these companies owned homes was $198,766, approximately 14% below the national median home value of $229,800. Meanwhile, the average median gross rent in the five companies’ 20 top ZIP codes was $1,259, approximately 13% above the national median of $1,096.

The committee’s investigation also found that the companies increased fees per lease by approximately 40% over the survey period, from $147.20 in 2018 to $205.29 in 2021.

While the committee hasn’t yet recommended any specific action regarding private equity ownership of single-family homes, some possible solutions that were recommended during the hearing include rent controls for corporate owners of apartments and single-family rentals, required disclosures of beneficial ownership and providing some type of incentive for owners to sell to individuals rather than institutional investors.

Photo: courtesy of Gage Skidmore on Flickr.

See more from Benzinga

Don't miss real-time alerts on your stocks - join Benzinga Pro for free! Try the tool that will help you invest smarter, faster, and better.

Yahoo Finance
Companies are having their best earnings season in nearly 2 years
Earnings for the S&P 500 are growing at their fastest rate since 2022 and analysts see that trend continuing into next quarter, setting up a positive backdrop for stocks.
Associated Press
The UN says there's 'full-blown famine' in northern Gaza. What does that mean?
The head of the United Nations World Food Program says northern Gaza has entered “full-blown famine” after nearly seven months of war between Israel and Hamas. Cindy McCain in an NBC interview broadcast Sunday said severe Israeli restrictions on humanitarian deliveries to the territory that has long relied on outside food assistance have pushed civilians in the most isolated, devastated part of Gaza over the brink. Famine was now moving south in Gaza, she said.
Yahoo Finance
Stock market today: Stocks gain as Fed rate hopes fuel continued rally
Stocks rallied at the end of last week, getting a boost from a "Goldilocks" jobs report.
Reuters
Brazil officials eye curbs on pension spending, but Lula may resist
Senior officials in Brazil's economic team are signaling a need to curb pension spending in order to shore up public accounts, although their biggest challenge may be convincing President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva to take such a measure. Despite a sweeping 2019 pension reform, spending on retirements and pension benefits continues to surge, affected by an aging population and Lula's policy of boosting benefits by more than inflation. Treasury Secretary Rogerio Ceron said last week that pension expenses "still deserve attention" and may require "measures that allow the dynamics of this expenditure to have growth compatible with medium- and long-term fiscal sustainability."
Reuters
US financial markets watchdog to collect data on bilateral repo
The Office of Financial Research (OFR), a U.S. Treasury Department-based research powerhouse, said on Monday it has adopted a final rule that will allow it to collect data on certain transactions in the repurchase agreement (repo) market. Most hedge fund activity in repo markets - where banks and other players such as hedge funds borrow short-term loans backed by Treasuries and other securities - is done bilaterally between brokers and customers. By establishing data collection for non-centrally cleared bilateral transactions, regulators want to improve visibility into this opaque but vital funding market for Wall Street.
CBS News
An unexpected gesture of kindness lifts grieving barista
A Starbucks barista in Little Rock, Arkansas was deeply moved thanks to the kindness and generosity of a customer.
AFP
Columbia axes graduation ceremony as US colleges counter Gaza protests
Columbia University, the epicenter of US student protests against the war in Gaza, on Monday cancelled its main graduation ceremony, as colleges seek to contain the demonstrations that have rocked campuses for weeks.- 'Order must prevail' - For many students who graduated from high school during the Covid pandemic, it will be the second such ceremony that is canceled due to external disruption.
NBC News
Judge finds Trump further violated gag order and again threatens him with jail 'if necessary'
Judge Juan Merchan on Monday again cited former President Donald Trump for violating the gag order he imposed on the trial and warned he could face jail "if necessary" for continuing to ignore it.
AFP
Israel's Rafah evacuation order heightens global alarm
Israel called on Palestinians to leave eastern Rafah Monday ahead of a ground invasion of the southern Gaza city, amid increasing global alarm about the consequences of such a move.The Palestinian Red Crescent said "thousands" of Gazans were on the move, leaving eastern Rafah.
Associated Press
Trump Media fires auditing firm that US regulators have charged with 'massive fraud'
Trump Media and Technology Group, the owner of social networking site Truth Social, has fired an auditor that federal regulators recently charged with “massive fraud.” The former president's media company dismissed BF Borgers as its independent public accounting firm on Friday, according to a securities filing — which also notes that Trump Media engaged with Arizona-based accountant Semple, Marchal & Cooper as BF Borgers’ replacement over the weekend. BF Borgers' dismissal arrived on the same day that the Securities and Exchange Commission charged the firm and its owner Benjamin F. Borgers with “deliberate and systematic failures” in more than 1,500 audits.
AFP
Former White House hopeful Sanders seeks reelection at 82
Former presidential candidate Bernie Sanders, the longest-serving independent senator in American history, said Monday he will seek a fourth term in an announcement touting his record over 16 years and taking aim at US military funding for Israel.Sanders, who suffered a heart attack during his 2020 presidential campaign, is the second-oldest senator, behind 90-year-old Republican Chuck Grassley.
AFP
Russia announces nuclear drills, threatens UK targets beyond Ukraine
Russia announced on Monday that its troops stationed near Ukraine would run nuclear weapons drills and threatened to strike UK military targets outside the embattled country, citing what it said was an escalation in Western sabre-rattling.The Russian foreign ministry meanwhile said it had summoned the UK's ambassador in Moscow and warned him that if Ukraine used British weapons to attack Russia, that Moscow could hit UK military targets in Ukraine "and beyond."
NBC News
Former Trump Organization exec takes the stand as judge warns Trump he could jail him for contempt
A former top executive at the Trump Organization took the witness stand in Donald Trump's criminal trial Monday after the judge presiding over the case fined the former president for violating his gag order and threatened to impose jail time if he continues to do so.
AFP
Biden again warns Netanyahu as Rafah invasion looms
US President Joe Biden on Monday "reiterated his clear position" to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu against an invasion of Rafah, the White House said, after Israel defied US warnings and told Palestinians to evacuate part of the southern Gaza city."The president reiterated his clear position on Rafah," the White House said in a brief readout of the call, adding that Biden also briefed the Israeli leader on talks to free Israeli hostages held by the Palestinian militants.
Reuters
UN rights chief calls Israeli orders to relocate Palestinians from Rafah inhumane
Israeli orders to relocate Palestinians from Rafah are inhumane and risked exposing them to further danger and misery, the U.N. human rights chief said on Monday, warning that such actions can sometimes amount to a war crime. Israel carried out airstrikes in Rafah on Monday and told Palestinians to evacuate parts of the southern Gaza city where more than a million people uprooted by the seven-month war have been sheltering in tents and crowded schools. Israeli strikes have flattened other parts of Gaza to such an extent that there is no location beyond Rafah with the infrastructure and resources to host those currently sheltering there, the U.N. human rights office statement added.
AFP
Stocks rise on renewed hopes of rate cuts
Stock markets advanced on Monday on renewed optimism that the US Federal Reserve will cut interest rates this year and on a positive corporate earnings season."The market... might be feeling better about the earnings outlook and the interest rate outlook, but the geopolitical backdrop remains a challenge to say the least," said Briefing.com analyst Patrick O'Hare.
CNN
Israel-Hamas ceasefire talks have stalled. Here’s why neither side may want a deal
Experts say both sides are pushing for maximalist demands because their political survival depends on it.
AFP
Sony backtracks faced with anger of 'Helldivers 2' players
Sony backtracked Monday after players of its popular cooperative third-person shooter game "Helldivers 2" pushed back against a requirement to link with its PlayStation Network platform.Steam is a popular platform for playing video games on PCs, tablets and phones, while PlayStation Network is a similar platform for PlayStation users.
Reuters
Malawi court drops corruption charges against vice president
A court in Malawi has dropped corruption charges against the country's Vice President Saulos Klaus Chilima, clearing a legal hurdle over his potential candidacy in next year's presidential election. Chilima was arrested in 2022 over graft allegations after the country's corruption watchdog alleged he was rewarded for assisting Xaviar Ltd and Malachitte FZE, two companies connected to British businessman Zuneth Sattar, to be awarded contracts by the Malawi Government. Both Chilima and Sattar denied any wrongdoing.
Associated Press
Georgia's attorney general says Savannah overstepped in outlawing guns in unlocked cars
Georgia's attorney general says city officials in Savannah overstepped their authority by making it illegal to leave firearms in unlocked cars. Savannah's mayor and city council in April enacted the new city ordinance aimed at making it harder for criminals to steal guns, citing local police statistics showing more than 200 guns reported stolen last year from vehicles that weren't locked. State Attorney General Chris Carr, a Republican, said in a letter to Savannah officials Friday that the gun ordinance runs afoul of a state law that prohibits local governments from regulating “the possession, ownership, transport, (or) carrying” of firearms.

Latest Stories