Elon Musk flaunts Tesla’s perfect score on LGBTQ equality index, saying his company respects ‘personal choices’

Eamon Barrett

June 2, 2022 at 4:06 AM·3 min read

It’s Pride Month, and Tesla CEO Elon Musk marked the first day of the LGBTQ awareness month by touting the electric-car maker’s equal opportunity credentials.

“Tesla scores 100/100 for the 7th year in a row for LGBTQ equality,” Musk tweeted, linking to the latest Corporate Equality Index (CEI) from the Human Rights Campaign (HRC), an LGBTQ advocacy group based in Washington, D.C.

The CEI ranks over 1,200 businesses, including all Fortune 500 companies, by their implementation of and commitment to policies for LGBTQ equality, awarding each company a score out of 100 based on HRC’s own metrics, such as whether the company has introduced a nondiscrimination policy for LGBTQ issues or offers health policies that cover “domestic and civil partnerships.”

Yet Musk’s follow-up tweet appears to misalign with Tesla’s apparent commitment to LGBTQ equality.

“We are trying to accelerate sustainable energy, so what matters is how much someone can contribute to that goal,” Musk said. “Personal choices are your own and are respected.”

https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1532030554778087424

Need it be said, sexual orientation is not a “personal choice.” But, based on Musk’s previous tussles with the HRC, the Tesla executive’s comment might have more to do with gender identity (which the HRC defines as “how individuals perceive themselves and what they call themselves”) than sexuality.

Tesla and the HRC didn’t immediately respond to requests for comment.

In 2020, Musk tweeted a cartoon mocking people for putting gender pronouns in their bios, which some people viewed as transphobic. In response, Musk said that he “support[s] trans [rights], but all these pronouns are an esthetic nightmare.” At that time, too, he pointed to Tesla’s perfect score on the CEI.

In response, then-president of HRC Alphonso David joined the chorus of campaigners rebuking Musk’s pronoun tweet, saying the CEO's comment “is exactly the opposite of what inclusive leadership looks like today” and is “decidedly out of step with the best practices we advise companies.”

“Musk should apologize,” David said. Musk did not.

Perfect score

Tesla is far from the only company to achieve a perfect score on the CEI rating. According to HRC, there are 842 companies with a 100-point ranking on this year’s CEI, including 258 Fortune 500 companies. (Fortune was not involved with compiling the index.)

HRC also notes that there are seven companies on its list that have achieved a perfect score for 20 years running, starting from the inaugural CEI in 2002: Apple, JPMorgan Chase, American Airlines, Nike, Xerox, Eastman Kodak, and Replacements Ltd. However, other rights groups suggest that HRC’s rankings are not a perfect measure for how corporations embrace LGBTQ rights.

Last week, progressive think tank and advocacy group Data for Progress published its annual Corporate Accountability Project list, which provides research on Fortune 500 companies’ political donations to anti-LGBTQ+ politicians.

According to the Corporate Accountability Project, some companies that achieved a 100% on the CEI—including AT&T, Comcast, Amazon, the Walt Disney Co., and Walmart—are still donating to politicians that Data for Progress considers to be anti-LGBTQ.

Tesla does not appear on Data for Progress’s accountability list; the organization did not immediately respond to a request to clarify whether that’s because the think tank did not assess Tesla’s campaign spending or because Tesla does not finance such groups.

This story was originally featured on Fortune.com

Associated Press
The FAA investigates after Boeing says workers in South Carolina falsified 787 inspection records
The Federal Aviation Administration said Monday it has opened an investigation into Boeing after the beleaguered company reported that workers at a South Carolina plant falsified inspection records on certain 787 planes. Boeing said its engineers have determined that misconduct did not create “an immediate safety of flight issue.” In an email to Boeing's South Carolina employees on April 29, Scott Stocker, who leads the 787 program, said a worker observed an “irregularity” in a required test of the wing-to-body join and reported it to his manager.
TODAY
Woman, 38, has 100 moles removed after melanoma diagnosis: ‘I wear my scars proudly’
Theresa Kurtz was diagnosed with melanoma after her mother died of skin cancer. Doctors have removed and biopsied 100 suspicious moles on her body.
Associated Press
Russia defends veto of UN resolution to prohibit nukes in outer space, urges vote to ban all weapons
Russia on Monday defended its veto of a U.N. resolution urging all nations to prevent a nuclear arms race in outer space, challenging the U.S., Japan and their Western allies to support Moscow’s rival resolution calling for a ban on all weapons in space “for all time.” Russia’s U.N. ambassador, Vassily Nebenzia, said the United States and Japan, which sponsored the vetoed resolution, are guilty of of “hypocrisy and double standards.”
Associated Press
Donald Trump calls Joe Biden weak on antisemitism, ignoring his own rhetoric
Donald Trump is accusing Joe Biden of offering a weak response to antisemitism, wielding the clashes on colleges campuses over the war in Gaza as a campaign issue. The latest example came over the weekend, when Trump — accusing the White House of having a role in his multiple state and federal criminal prosecutions — told Republican donors gathered for a private retreat at his Florida resort that Biden is running a “Gestapo administration,” referring to the secret police force of Nazi Germany.
CBS News
White-coated candy recalled nationwide over salmonella risk
Recall includes yogurt pretzels and other confections sold by retailers such as Dollar General, HyVee, Target and Walmart.
NBC News
Texas couple welcomes identical quadruplet girls: ‘Holy moly!’
Doctors put the odds of having identical quadruplets at about one in 15 million — which makes Mercedes and Jonathan Sandhu very special.
CNN
Trump seeks delay in classified documents case, saying prosecutors mishandled evidence
Donald Trump’s attorneys have found a new reason to seek to delay the classified documents case: Some of the documents found in boxes at Mar-a-Lago have shifted out of order since FBI agents seized them two years ago.
Yahoo Finance
Lucid stock down on Q1 loss, confirms Gravity SUV on track for 'late 2024' launch
EV maker Lucid reported mixed first quarter results as a wider-than-expected loss trumped the company's confirmation that its Gravity SUV is still on track for a 2024 debut.
AFP
Boeing probed in US over possible falsified records on 787
US air safety authorities are investigating whether embattled aviation giant Boeing completed required inspections on its 787 aircraft and whether employees falsified records, officials said Monday."The FAA is investigating whether Boeing completed the inspections and whether company employees may have falsified aircraft records," the agency said.
Associated Press
Russia critic Kara-Murza wins Pulitzer for passionate columns written from prison cell
Vladimir Kara-Murza, who has written columns as a contributor for The Washington Post from his prison cell in Russia, has won the Pulitzer Prize for commentary. Kara-Murza, 42, is a Russian politician, author and historian who has been imprisoned in Russia since April 2022.
NBC News
Rich people are spending more than ever to run for Congress. A big test is coming in Maryland.
Wealthy office-seekers plowed more of their own money than ever into runs for Congress last year. Now, the biggest one of all is facing an important hurdle.
TODAY
EXCLUSIVE: A wife noticed a change in her husband's eye. He dismissed it. It was a rare cancer
Dad had swollen eye that his wife noticed. He felt a lump. It was rare MALT lymphoma. He had surgery, radiation. Is now cancer free.
CNN
Social Security will not be able to pay full benefits in 2035 if Congress doesn’t act. Medicare has a little more time
Social Security and Medicare will not be able to fully pay benefits in just over a decade if lawmakers don’t act to address the pending shortfalls, according to reports released Monday by the entitlement programs’ trustees. While the trust funds’ finances improved slightly, they remain in dire shape.
Associated Press
For a Louisiana lawmaker, exempting incest and rape from the state's abortion ban is personal
For Louisiana Rep. Delisha Boyd, the uphill battle she faces to exempt pregnancies that are the result of rape and incest from Louisiana’s strict abortion ban is not just morally right — it’s also personal. With a GOP-dominated legislative committee set to debate and vote on Boyd's exemption bill Tuesday, the Democratic New Orleans lawmaker has decided to publicly share her own story to underscore the importance of letting rape and incest survivors decide their own fates. If the bill advances, it will still have to make it through both Republican-led chambers of the Legislature.
Reuters
Qatar says Hamas response to truce proposal is positive
Hamas sent on Monday to mediators its response to a truce proposal which could be described as positive, a spokesperson for Qatar's foreign ministry said early on Tuesday. A Qatari delegation will head to Cairo on Tuesday to resume indirect negotiations between Israel and Hamas through the mediators, Majed Al-Ansari added in a statement. Qatar, which alongside Egypt and the United States has played a mediation role in the talks, said it hoped the negotiations would culminate in an agreement for an immediate and permanent ceasefire in Gaza.
AFP
No letup yet for flood-battered southern Brazil
The rains may have abated, but floodwaters continued their assault on southern Brazil Monday, with hundreds of municipalities in ruins amid fears that food and drinking water may soon run out.In total, 385 cities, towns and villages have been hit, many of which remain cut off from the world -- without access to drinking water or electricity or any means of calling for help.
Yahoo Finance
Tyson shares close lower as pinched consumers get choosy about meat
Tyson Foods expect sales to remain flat in 2024 as consumers seek value and trade between channels.
TODAY
Sheinelle Jones' 11-year-old daughter had a major laundry fail ... and TikTok helped her fix it
TODAY co-host Sheinelle Jones is teaching her three kids, Kayin, Clara and Uche, to tackle household responsibility, including laundry.
CNN
Phi Delta Theta member removed from Ole Miss fraternity after confrontation during campus protest
Phi Delta Theta has removed an individual from its fraternity following a heated exchange between a group of pro-Palestinian protesters and a much larger group of counter protesters at the University of Mississippi last Thursday.
CNN
Israel says Hamas deal is ‘far’ from meeting its demands as Rafah offensive looms
Israel said the terms of a ceasefire deal Hamas accepted on Monday remained “far from” meeting its demands and warned its military operations in Rafah would continue, even as it sent negotiators to talk to mediators.

Perfect score

Latest Stories