Focus shifts to star judges, as contestants falter
FILE - In this June 29, 2011 file photo, Javier Colon, winner of the first season of the singing competition series "The Voice," poses for photographers after the finale in Burbank, Calif. More than a year after his win, Colon is among the rapidly increasing number of reality singing contest winners who didn't go on to fame and fortune. Even as these shows proliferate the number of breakout stars from their ranks has dwindled. (AP Photo/Matt Sayles, File)
NASHVILLE, Tenn. (AP) — Javier Colon's family and friends were so excited when he won the first season of "The Voice," they assured him that he was set for life — and famous.
The 35-year-old musician knew better.
"I never expected that I would be like the next Kelly Clarkson," Colon said, referring to the superstar who got her start on "American Idol." ''Expectations and hopes are different things. Fortunately for me, I've had a lot of experience in the music business — some good ones and some not so good ones — that led me to auditioning for 'The Voice.' I've learned to just not expect much."
More than a year after his win, Colon is without a record contract and still trying to land a breakout hit on the charts. He is just one of the increasing number of singing contest winners who are struggling to find their way after TV success. Among the more recent "Idol" winners who have faltered after capturing the crown are David Cook and Kris Allen; and while runner-up status or even being a top finalist could lead to fame in the early seasons, like with Clay Aiken, Jennifer Hudson and Chris Daughtry, prospects for non-winners have dropped so much that this year, "Idol" stopped offering second-place finishers a guaranteed recording contract.
Last season's "X Factor" winner Melanie Amaro's debut single, released last month, hasn't made much of a dent on radio (though her official album debut is in December), and there are concerns that the most recent "Voice" winner, Jermaine Paul, may end up following the same path as Colon.
It all points to a troubling trend for those who still believe in their original mission from the early days of reality TV.
"That's what the show, at the end of the day, was designed for," said Simon Cowell, a judge and creative force on "American Idol" who has since moved to "The X Factor," which debuts Wednesday on Fox. "Ratings are important, but if you're not producing the goods year on year, then it's sort of pointless making these shows."
FILE - This May 24, 2012 file photo released by Fox shows judges, from left, L.A. Reid, Demi Lovato, Britney Spears and Simon Cowell from the singing competition series, "The X Factor," in Austin, Texas. The contest between "The Voice" and "The X Factor" is escalating after NBC scheduled its "Voice" against Wednesday's second-season debut of Fox's "X Factor." (AP Photo/Fox, Ray Mickshaw)
At the same time, there's been a noticeable shift in the competition shows' focus. Once content with finding the next Mariah Carey, these days it's more about ... well, Mariah Carey.