What to Read Next

Reality Check Dissects the Voice and X Factor Finales! Plus: How to Make 'Em Better Shows

Michael Slezak
December 23, 2012

The X Factor and The Voice have concluded their respective Season 2 and Season 3 installments, and with the celebratory confetti swept up and carried off to a Los Angeles-area landfill, it seems like the right time to do a post-mortem on how the reality singing competitions’ final results played out.

In this week’s Reality Check, my cohost Melinda Doolittle and I examine how The X Factor‘s Tate Stevens lost the battle of the Top 3 performance finale, but still managed to win the war. (Hint: An unfortunate duet between his arch rival and an embattled country diva probably helped his chances.) We also talk about what the show’s producers should try to change for Season 3 — and yes, we get more specific than “Burn it to the ground and start from scratch!”

PHOTOS | X Factor: The 25 Best Performances of Season 2

Melinda and I also take a deep dive into The Voice‘s Season 3 outcome: How Cassadee Pope turned the performance finale into a victory lap; why the two-hour results show was infinitely more enjoyable than The X Factor‘s; and how Adam Levine’s particular style of coaching should serve as a template for incoming panelists Usher and Shakira.

RELATED | The Voice: 25 Best Performances of Season 3

So press play below for your weekly dose of Reality Check, and for all my reality TV recaps, commentary and interviews, follow me on Twitter @MichaelSlezakTV!


Related stories

The Voice Exclusive Video: Season 3 Top 4 Cut Loose on Last Call with Carson Daly

The Voice Recap: They've Been Really Tryin', Baby [Updated]

MasterChef Exclusive Preview: No Pressure! It's Only Boulud, Ducasse, Savoy and Ramsay!

Get more from TVLine.com: Follow us on Twitter, Facebook, Newsletter