'Pretty Little Liars' poll: Is [spoiler!] really dead?

Yahoo! TV
1 / 2

"Pretty Little Liars" -- "Out of Sight, Out of Mind" SHAY MITCHELL, LUCY HALE

"Out of Sight, Out of Mind" - The PLLs are looking for answers in all of the wrong places in "Out of Sight, Out of Mind," an all new episode of ABC Family's hit original series "Pretty Little Liars."

After watching "Pretty Little Liars" for so long, we probably shouldn't be surprised when there's a major twist, but that definitely didn't stop us from being floored by Tuesday night's big reveal.

Toby's dead?! Is this for real?

We were glad to see Emily showing some skepticism when she received the supposed program for Toby's funeral in her car following a particularly creepy scene.

But Spencer sure believes it. And why shouldn't she? Other than not seeing his face, she spotted his tattoo, so clearly it was him.

[Related Poll: Who is the man for Spencer?]

Hold on. She didn't see his face. It could be anyone -- even Mona -- just playing a trick on her to help her lose her mind (which she did, so Team A can check that off its to-do list).

Furthermore, Toby is too central a character for the showrunners to just kill off with no fanfare and in any sort of struggle we didn't get to see. In other words, something tells us we'll be seeing plenty more of actor Keegan Allen.

But that's just our two cents. We want yours! Hit the poll above and give us your theories in the comments!

"Pretty Little Liars" airs Tuesdays at 8 PM on ABC Family.