"American Idol": "The 'talent' last season was abysmal, and Ellen's participation was just a joke — and not a funny one. I only hope they finally learned their lesson about trying to get 'diverse' talent that will appeal to everyone, and that this year they will get the 12 best singers possible. However, I think this season's judging choices will stink just as badly as Ellen did." — kittybiddy Source: TV Guide
Jumped the Shark: Viewers' Picks
See your picks of shows you think have jumped the shark and why.