In the eternal Tom Brady vs. Peyton Manning debate, here's an area where the Colts quarterback has a slight advantage. Manning had already demonstrated nice comic timing in his umpteen commercials, but on "SNL," he was a star. During his 2007 hosting gig, he delighted in sticking a pin in his perfect choirboy image, most memorably in a fake United Way ad that saw him mercilessly berate small children for our amusement. So in the battle of "SNL" hosts, Manning comes out on top. Don't worry about Tom Brady, though: He still has Gisele's shoulder to cry on at night.
Best and Worst Athlete Actors on TV
We're playing referee and making the final call on the best and worst athletes turned actors in TV history.