YouTube Illegally Uses Return-to-Office Push to Derail Union, Complaint Claims

YouTube Illegally Uses Return-to-Office Push to Derail Union, Complaint Claims

(Bloomberg) -- Alphabet Inc. is illegally using return-to-office policies as a tool to try to derail YouTube contract workers from organizing in Texas, a union alleged in a National Labor Relations Board complaint.

Most Read from Bloomberg

In the filing Tuesday, the Alphabet Workers Union accused the tech giant and a staffing firm of responding to a YouTube unionization campaign by announcing new stricter rules. Under the restrictions, set for February, refusing to return to the local office in Austin will be considered “job abandonment” and “voluntary termination,” the union said.

The policy change will punish workers who have grown accustomed to doing their jobs remotely and falls especially hard on employees who live outside the area, many of whom are pro-union, the group said. The complaint also alleges that a supervisor made implied anti-union threats and that management has been transferring work to offices in other places — including India — in an attempt “to chill the union organizing effort” by the Texas staff.

Treatment of contract workers has become a flashpoint for Alphabet — the owner of Google and its YouTube unit — which relies heavily on staffing firms to meet its labor needs. Contract employees became the majority of the company’s global workforce in 2018, and Alphabet Workers Union has been trying to organize both direct and subcontracted staff.

Tuesday’s complaint was filed against both the staffing vendor managing the workers, Cognizant Technology Solutions Corp., and Alphabet itself, which the union contends is a “joint employer” — a company that exercises enough control over workers to be legally responsible for their treatment and is obligated to negotiate if they do vote to unionize.

Cognizant said Tuesday that its return-to-office policy has been “communicated repeatedly and consistently to all of its associates since December 2021,” long before workers petitioned to unionize.

“The small number of associates who voluntarily left the Austin area and are unable or unwilling to return have the opportunity to be considered for assignments on other client projects at Cognizant,” spokesperson Jeff DeMarrais said in a statement. “There is simply no merit to these claims.”

Alphabet didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment.

Alphabet has denied being a joint employer of the YouTube contract workers. “These have not been and are not our employees,” company attorney Aaron Agenbroad said at a November NLRB hearing about the unionization petition, according to a transcript obtained via a Freedom of Information Act request.

The AWU, an affiliate of the Communications Workers of America, petitioned in October to represent the group of about 60 YouTube staff, saying the vast majority of them had signed up to join.

The workers’ jobs include ensuring videos are correctly labeled and looking into requests from users of YouTube Music. The team has been working remotely since early 2020, longer than most employees have worked there, and the announcement of the return-to-office push was abrupt, according to the union.

“Suddenly when we say, ‘Hey, we’re going to unionize,’ it’s like, ‘Hey, let’s get back to office,’” said YouTube worker Neil Gossell, an activist with the union campaign. “So the timing on that seems really suspect.”

In its statement, Cognizant said the employees “were fully aware of the intention to return to the office prior to the filing of a petition.”

“All associates working on this project were hired with the understanding that the jobs were based in an Austin office location,” Cognizant’s DeMarrais said.

If AWU successfully persuades the NLRB that Alphabet is a joint employer of the YouTube workers — and then prevails in a unionization vote — the internet company itself would be required to formally negotiate with the union for the first time.

Telework policies have been a contentious pandemic-era issue at all sorts of businesses, and the CWA has filed NLRB complaints against other employers for allegedly failing to fairly negotiate over it. Last spring, a group of Cognizant employees working on Google Maps in Washington state, who haven’t formally unionized but are organizing with AWU, threatened to go on strike over a return-to-office deadline they said was unsafe. According to the union, Cognizant then extended the deadline by 90 days.

(Updates with additional Cognizant comment in 13th paragraph.)

Most Read from Bloomberg Businessweek

©2023 Bloomberg L.P.