Thinking about renting out your lovely second home? Leave out emotion | At Home with Marni

Turning a vacation home such as this Big Bear Lake, California, cabin into a short-term rental is not for those who can’t bear the wear and tear, owner Avril Wood said. For Wood, the cost and inconvenience is worth having a place that earns its keep. “I wouldn’t change anything.”
Turning a vacation home such as this Big Bear Lake, California, cabin into a short-term rental is not for those who can’t bear the wear and tear, owner Avril Wood said. For Wood, the cost and inconvenience is worth having a place that earns its keep. “I wouldn’t change anything.”

I do not have a second home for the same reason I do not have a second husband. I can barely keep up with the one I have. But I have a lot of friends who are more competent than I am, including my friend Avril, who with her only husband as far as I know, Bill, owns a second home in a ski area that they rent out about 120 days a year.

Avril emailed me after reading my column about replacing my flatware. After nearly three decades of regular use, I had run low on forks.

“Forks are the first to go in rental homes,” she said in her email. “I have to replace mine once a year.”

“People steal your forks?” I asked.

“Oh, that’s not all!” she said.

Curious, I called her to find out what else folks who rent out their vacation homes had to contend with.

“I used to have this dream of decorating our getaway for me and my family,” Avril said of the 1,800-square foot, three-bedroom-plus loft cabin in Big Bear Lake, California, which she and her husband have owned for nearly 25 years. “But Bill taught me a long time ago to take my heart out of it. Once I separated my emotions, I was fine.”

Now, Avril and Bill Wood aren’t real estate novices. They own dozens of rental properties in several states, homes that others live in and furnish. But that is quite different from renting out a vacation home that you’ve furnished for yourself and also occasionally live in. The latter situation hits close to home.

“How can you not be emotional about your house?” I asked.

“I don’t put my heart and soul into it anymore,” she said. “That way, when something goes missing, I don’t get upset.” Her aim is to decorate the vacation home nicely enough to attract good tenants, and to occasionally enjoy herself, but also to decorate it affordably with replacement in mind.

“I don’t spend money on the place like I used to. Because restocking goes with the territory, I’ve learned some inexpensive shortcuts.”

Here are some of those lessons learned:

Plan for attrition. Blankets, TV remotes, pots and pans, they go, she said. Budget for it. “Every time I visit the cabin, I survey what’s missing in the way of plates and wine glasses, then go straight to the Dollar Store,” she said. “I used to be nice and stock the kitchen with baggies and aluminum foil, but no one ever replaced them.” Now she keeps kitchen and other personal supplies in rubber bins in a locked closet.

Get ready for mysterious disappearances. For her, it’s bedspreads. “It’s the weirdest thing,” she said. “Either renters take them, or the cleaning crew takes them to wash and doesn’t return them. I’ll never know.” She stopped buying lovely down-filled duvets, and now buys her bedspreads online at Eddie Bauer on discount. “Eventually, you get numb to it,” she said.

Use a management company. Because the Woods live nearly two hours away, they have a property manager oversee rental arrangements. The management company deals with the lease agreement, the keys, the cleaning crew, and minor repairs. For that, they get 35% of the rental fee. The Woods get the rest. The company also offers some protection. Recently, when a tenant took a new vacuum cleaner, the management company went after the culprit and handled the situation.

Head off wear and tear. While Avril used to buy decorative area rugs to put over her wood floors in the entry and living areas, now she uses large black rubber mats. “We have a lot of snowy, muddy boots tromping through here in the winter, and in the summer wet sandy kids who’ve been in the lake. The rugs just got ruined,” she said. Though not as pretty, the rubber mats are durable, protect her wood floors, and are safer since they won’t slip. In addition, she’s opted for well-made furniture upholstered in durable fabrics.

Embrace bed in a box. Beds add up in a place with three or more bedrooms, she said. A decent mattress can cost between $1,000 and $3,000 and are bulky to transport. Her solution: “I go to Costco to buy a bed in a box for $500 to $700. The compressed mattress makes delivery easier. She puts the new mattress on existing box springs, and saves.

Brace yourself for rearrangements. “I will never understand why renters think they can come into my home and redecorate,” she said. “They don’t just decide the plates and bowls belong on the other side of the kitchen; they move furniture.” One group moved her kitchen table, which seats eight, from the kitchen into the living room to be by the window. Another carried a heavy double dresser from the upstairs bedroom to the downstairs bedroom, a feat that would have required two strong men. Both parties left the furniture where they’d moved it. Perhaps the strangest change, one tenant took the small appetizer plates from the cupboard and hung them on the wall. People have nerve.

Marni Jameson is the author of six home and lifestyle books, including “What to Do With Everything You Own to Leave the Legacy You Want,” “Downsizing the Family Home – What to Save, What to Let Go,” and “Downsizing the Blended Home – When Two Households Become One.” You may reach her at


This article originally appeared on Sarasota Herald-Tribune: MARNI JAMESON: Avoid common mistakes when renting out your second home