American Home Shield vs. Amazon Home Warranty (2020)

Home Service Research Team
·8 min read

Adobe Stock - Iriana Shiyan

Deciding between a home warranty plan from American Home Shield and Amazon Home Warranty? In this article, our review compares these two companies on their coverage plans, pricing, and customer reviews, and helps you determine which company offers the best home warranty for you and your home. Continue reading for a detailed analysis of each of these providers.

To get a free quote from American Home Shield, call .

In this article:

  • American Home Shield vs. Amazon Home Warranty Comparison

  • Pros & Cons

  • American Home Shield Coverage Plans

  • Amazon Home Warranty Coverage Plans

  • American Home Shield vs. Amazon Home Warranty Cost

  • Customer Reviews

  • Conclusion

  • Frequently Asked Questions

American Home Shield vs. Amazon Home Warranty Comparison

American Home Shield

  • Get a free quote: Visit site

  • Our rating: Best Overall

  • Number of plans: 3

  • Premium cost: $50–$60 per month

  • Service fee: $75–$125

  • State availability: All but AK

  • BBB rating: B

  • Years in business: 49 years

Best Overall

bhg BUY IT

Amazon Home Warranty

  • Get a free quote: Visit site

  • Our rating: Best Customer Service

  • Number of plans: 3

  • Premium cost: $40–$49 per month

  • Service fee: $75

  • State availability: All but CA, IA, MO, OK, and WA

  • BBB rating: B

  • Years in business: 10 years

Best Customer Service

bhg BUY IT

Pros & Cons

To help you determine which company is best for you and your home protection needs, here’s a quick overview of each company’s pros and cons.

American Home Shield: Pros

  • Longest-running home warranty company

  • Offers coverage for items with unknown pre-existing conditions

  • Holds a Better Business Bureau (BBB) accreditation and a B rating

American Home Shield: Cons

  • Offers only five optional add-ons

Amazon Home Warranty: Pros

  • Offers 19 optional add-ons

  • Offers one month of free coverage when customers sign up for a plan

  • Provides 24/7 customer service

Amazon Home Warranty: Cons

  • Doesn’t have an online chat function for easy use

  • Has only 10 years of industry experience

American Home Shield Coverage Plans

American Home Shield offers three coverage plans, including a Systems Plan, an Appliances Plan, and a Combo Plan. The Systems Plan covers important home systems like your air conditioning and plumbing, the Appliances Plan protects appliances like your dishwasher and refrigerator, and the Combo Plan combines the coverage of the Systems and Appliances Plans into one comprehensive coverage option.

Best Overall

bhg BUY IT

American Home Shield also offers five optional add-ons to consumers:

  • Septic pump

  • Pool and spa

  • Well pump

  • Guest unit up to 750 square feet

  • Electronics extended warranty

View the specific items covered under each American Home Shield plan below:

The Appliances Plan covers:

  • Refrigerators

  • Ranges/Cooktops

  • Ovens

  • Dishwashers

  • Built-in Microwaves

  • Free-standing Ice Makers

  • Built-in Food Centers

  • Clothes Washers and Dryers

  • Garage Door Openers

  • Trash Compactors

The Systems Plan covers:

  • Air Conditioning

  • Heating

  • Ductwork

  • Built-in Exhaust/Vent/Attic Fans

  • Main Breaker/Fuse Panel Box

  • Doorbells/Chimes

  • Interior Electrical Lines and DC Wiring

  • Smoke Detectors

  • Ceiling Fans

  • Central Vacuum

  • Interior Plumbing Line Leaks and Breaks

  • Plumbing Stoppages

  • Toilets

  • Faucets

  • Plumbing Fixtures and Valves

  • Whirlpool Tub Motors and Components

  • Water Heaters

  • Instant Hot/Cold Water Dispensers

  • Garbage Disposals

The AHS Combo Plan combines all the coverage of the previous two plans.

To get a free quote from American Home Shield, call .

Amazon Home Warranty Coverage Plans

Amazon Home Warranty's coverage plans are very similar to those offered by American Home Shield—Amazon Home Warranty offers a Systems plan, an Appliances plan, and a Combo plan.

Best Customer Service

bhg BUY IT

The Systems and Appliances plans cover systems and appliances, respectively, and the company's Combo plan combines the coverage of the Systems plan and Appliances plan and adds coverage for these items:

  • Exhaust hood

  • Ceiling fan

  • Instant hot water dispenser

  • Garbage disposal

  • Attic fan

  • Bathroom exhaust fan

  • Doorbell

  • Kitchen fan

Amazon Home Warranty also offers 19 optional add-ons:

  • Whole-house humidifier

  • Additional microwave

  • Central vacuum

  • Well pump

  • Wine refrigerator

  • Secondary refrigerator

  • Water softener

  • Sump pump

  • Septic system

  • Lawn sprinkler system

  • Additional central AC unit

  • Additional central heating unit

  • Pool and spa

  • Additional washer/dryer

  • Ice maker

  • Limited roof leaks

  • Sump pump

The lists below show what each Amazon Home Warranty plan covers.

The Appliances plan covers the following:

  • Washer and dryer

  • Dishwasher

  • Refrigerator (with ice maker)

  • Freezer

  • Microwave ovens

  • Oven/range/stove/cooktop

  • Trash compactor

The Systems plan covers:

  • Hot water heater

  • Ductwork

  • Jetted bathtub

  • Garage door openers

  • Air conditioning system

  • Heating system

  • Plumbing system

  • Electrical system

The Combo plan covers everything in the two plans listed above, plus:

  • Doorbell

  • Kitchen fan

  • Exhaust hood

  • Bathroom exhaust fan

  • Ceiling fan

  • Instant hot water dispenser

  • Attic fan

  • Garbage disposal

To get a free quote from Amazon Home Warranty, call .

American Home Shield vs. Amazon Home Warranty Cost

The sample quotes our reviews team received indicate that Amazon Home Warranty offers a cheaper monthly premium than American Home Shield. Additionally, Amazon Home Warranty offers a $75 service fee, while American Home Shield lets homeowners choose a service fee between $75–$125. The service fee a homeowner selects with American Home Shield impacts the cost of their monthly premium.

Note: The optional add-on cost for these two companies depends on the specific item selected. Typically, each optional item adds about $40 to $180 to a homeowner’s annual home warranty cost.

American Home Shield Cost

  • Monthly premium: $49.99 to $59.99

  • Service fee: $75 to $125

Amazon Home Warranty Cost

  • Monthly premium: $42.00 to $52.00

  • Service fee: $75

Customer Reviews

American Home Shield and Amazon Home Warranty both hold B ratings from the Better Business Bureau (BBB). AHS is accredited with the organization, while the BBB revoked Amazon Home Warranty’s accreditation in November 2020 for failure to adhere to certain required standards.

Regarding customer reviews, Amazon Home Warranty has received better customer reviews on average than American Home Shield. Though Amazon Home Warranty holds a higher average rating, it’s hard to compare the two companies evenly on customer reviews because American Home Shield has received a significantly higher number of reviews.

Conclusion

American Home Shield and Amazon Home Warranty are two of the most popular home warranty companies in the industry because of their variety of coverage plans, positive reputations, and affordability.

Our review team named American Home Shield as the best overall home warranty because of its breadth of coverage, coverage for undetectable pre-existing conditions, and years of experience in the home warranty industry. We named Amazon Home Warranty the provider with the best customer service because of its 24/7 availability and workmanship guarantee.

We recommend American Home Shield for homeowners who want to choose their own service fee or want a home warranty company with decades of experience. We recommend Amazon Home Warranty for homeowners who prefer a wide variety of optional add-ons and want to work with a trusted customer service department.

To get a free quote from American Home Shield, call .

Alternative Home Warranty Provider: Select Home Warranty

If you're looking for a more affordable option, consider Select Home Warranty over American Home Shield and Amazon Home Warranty. Our review team named this provider as the best for budget shoppers because it sells its coverage plans for under $40 per month. In addition, Select Home Warranty includes free roof leak coverage with all of its plans.

To get a free quote from Select Home Warranty, call .

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the waiting period for Amazon Home Warranty and American Home Shield?

The waiting period for new Amazon Home Warranty or American Home Shield customers is 30 days. This means that coverage won’t kick in and homeowners won’t be able to file a claim until this 30-day period is over.

What are the benefits of a home warranty?

Homeowners with a home warranty can protect their home's systems and appliances from expensive repairs or replacements caused by normal wear and tear. Instead of paying large amounts of money out of pocket, homeowners pay a low monthly premium and a service call fee for every service request they make.

What items are covered by a home warranty plan?

What a home warranty plan covers depends on your home warranty provider and the plan you purchase. Home warranty companies commonly sell plans that protect appliances only, systems only, and both appliances and systems.

Do American Home Shield and Amazon Home Warranty cover plumbing systems?

Yes, both of these companies cover plumbing systems in their Combo and Systems plans.

How good is Amazon Home Warranty?

Amazon Home Warranty offers three solid coverage plans and has received excellent reviews from customers, earning a 4-star average customer review rating on its BBB webpage.

What are some other reputable home warranty companies?

Here are some home warranty companies that made our review team’s top home warranty list:

Latest Stories

  • Zimmerman seals deal with Nats, says might not be last year

    Now that he’s set to play for the Washington Nationals this season, Ryan Zimmerman might stick around a little longer, too. Zimmerman and the Nationals made it official Saturday, announcing his $1 million, one-year contract. “If I can settle into this role and do well this year, by no means does this have to be my last year,” the 36-year-old Zimmerman said on a Zoom call with reporters.

  • Trump weighed firing acting AG Jeffery Rosen during final weeks to pursue unfounded voter fraud claims

    "Until the very end, the pressure never stopped; the pressure was real," a person familiar with the matter told USA TODAY.

  • Tennis pro Yastremska denied in bid to lift suspension

    The International Tennis Federation on Saturday denied a bid by 29th-ranked Dayana Yastremska to lift a suspension for failing an out-of-competition doping test. The ruling can be appealed to the Court of Arbitration for Sport by the 20-year-old Ukrainian. Players at Grand Slam tournaments and events sanctioned by the ITF, ATP and WTA are tested for substances prohibited by the World Anti-Doping Agency.

  • Villa at the double as Newcastle lose again

    Aston Villa made light of manager Dean Smith's touchline ban with a 2-0 win at home to Newcastle on Saturday that added to the pressure on the Premier League strugglers.

  • Tesla accuses engineer of stealing crucial company software

    Tesla has sued a new engineer for allegedly stealing crucial software it uses to run its business.

  • Judge: Kenosha shooter can't associate with supremacists

    An 18-year-old Illinois teen charged with fatally shooting two people during a protest in southeastern Wisconsin last year is prohibited from associating with known white supremacists under a judge's recently modified bail conditions. Kyle Rittenhouse was 17 during the Aug. 25 demonstration in Kenosha, Wisconsin, as hundreds were protesting the police shooting of Jacob Blake, a Black man. Rittenhouse has been charged with multiple counts, including reckless and intentional homicide, endangerment and being a minor in possession of a firearm.

  • Fact check: Meme of fake email perpetuates conspiracy theory

    Viral social media posts claim to show an email obtained by WikiLeaks. The email is fabricated.

  • Inside the Messy Disney Love Triangle Dominating the Pop Charts

    Photo Illustration by The Daily Beast/Photos GettyIn the span of just two weeks, three Disney stars have engulfed the old and young in their bizarre love triangle.On Jan. 7, Olivia Rodrigo, known for her acting and singing on Disney’s Bizaardvark and Disney+’s High School Musical: The Musical: The Series, released “drivers license,” a heartbreak song that not only immediately shot to No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 but also twice broke Spotify’s record for most daily streams of a non-holiday song. The song quickly became an overnight phenomenon, with TikTok users creating millions of videos recreating the music video or explaining the drama behind it.The song’s ripped-from-the-headlines backstory only added to the public’s obsession. Rodrigo has been a Taylor Swift fan since she was a kid, and Swift’s songwriting style has clearly inspired Rodrigo, who’s mined specific details of her life to tell the universal story of love lost. “I got my driver’s license last week, just like we always talked about / ‘cause you were so excited for me to finally drive up to your house,” she sings, later crooning about seeing the guy everywhere, especially in all the white cars. Fans quickly picked up on this, pointing out that Rodrigo said in an interview that her rumored former flame (and High School Musical co-star) Joshua Bassett taught her how to drive in his white car.But maybe the most telling lyrics come when Rodrigo sings, “I bet you’re with that blond girl, who always made me doubt / she’s so much older than me, she’s everything I’m insecure about,” because as it turns out, Bassett was recently seen with a blond girl who is “so much older”—four years, which is practically a decade to a 17-year-old like Rodrigo. Olivia Rodrigo and Joshua Bassett of High School Musical: The Musical: The Series perform onstage during the 5th Annual Elsie Fest: Broadway's Outdoor Music Festival on October 05, 2019, in New York City. Jenny Anderson/Getty Enter Sabrina Carpenter, recording artist and star of Girl Meets World and Netflix’s Work It. She’s the rumored “blond girl,” because she and Bassett were spotted together at Black Lives Matter protests over the summer and dining out in California—a year after Bassett allegedly wrote a love song about Rodrigo called “Anyone Else” in his Salt Lake City apartment while filming HSMTMTS, which Rodrigo nods to with: “I guess you didn’t mean what you wrote in that song about me” in “drivers license.” Rodrigo and Bassett seemed to be on good terms through late April, when Rodrigo liked Bassett’s tweet urging his followers to “remind someone you love them right now.” But in August, Rodrigo posted on TikTok about “failed relationships.”How the Hell Did Olivia Rodrigo’s ‘Drivers License’ Become the No. 1 Song in America?In an attempt to tell her side of the story, the 21-year-old Carpenter released “Skin” last week, which lacks any kind of self-awareness, especially considering she’s the elder in this situation. On “Skin,” she sings, “Maybe then we could pretend there’s no gravity in the words we write / Maybe you didn’t mean it, maybe ‘blond’ was the only rhyme,” and then later, “You can try to get under my, under my, under my skin / While he’s on mine.” Bassett subsequently praised the song on his Instagram, writing, “been stuck in my head since I heard it!!!”Oh, and Bassett has a song, too. It’s called “Lie Lie Lie,” and even though he wrote on his Instagram Story that it’s about a “friend,” fans think it’s about Rodrigo. In it, he sings, “So you’re telling them it’s all my fault / You’re the victim this time,” and in its accompanying music video Bassett hangs out a car window, which mirrors what Rodrigo does in her music video.Both Rodrigo and Carpenter have cited Lorde and Swift as songwriting inspirations—“Taylor Swift is my songwriting idol and I wouldn’t be half of the woman and a songwriter I am today without her,” Rodrigo told NME. Carpenter said in an interview: “I think Lorde is an incredible lyricist and someone I always look up to and also musically, she does such her own thing in her own lane.” As for Bassett, he says John Mayer is his inspiration.Somehow, by the grace of God or good publicists or possibly both, all three artists have released their own song about the love triangle in a matter of two weeks. Not only that, but Rodrigo and Bassett seemingly put their hate aside while promoting HSMTM: The Holiday Special in December, even praising each other’s prolific songwriting skills.Rodrigo, Bassett, and Carpenter are far from the first young lovebirds to put their real-life drama to song. In 2008, an 18-year-old Swift went on The Ellen Show to tell the host and her millions of watchers that boy-bander Joe Jonas broke up with her in a 25-second phone call, and that she had written a song about it—“Forever and Always,” which was on her Grammy-winning album Fearless. There were other songs, too, like “Better Than Revenge,” where Swift sang about another girl “stealing” her boyfriend. “She’s not a saint and she’s not what you think, she’s an actress / She’s better known for the things that she does on the mattress,” sang Swift. The Jonas Brothers returned fire with “Much Better,” which nodded to Swift and all the “tears on her guitar” and how “much better” the new girl was. The rumored “much better” girl was actress Camilla Belle, who doesn’t write songs, so perhaps we’ll never know her side of the story. (However, when Swift receives bad press, Belle usually tweets.)Britney Spears and Justin Timberlake played this game, too, with “Cry Me A River” and “Everytime.” But the alleged other man in this situation, Wade Robson, was just a dancer, so he never got his chance to sing the blues or cast a Spears lookalike in a music video. Hilary Duff, Lindsay Lohan, and Aaron Carter made comments about one another in the press and on SNL about their love triangle, but as far as songs go, there was really only ever Duff’s “Haters,” where she sang, “You say your boyfriend’s sweet and kind / But you’ve got your eyes on mine.”Rodrigo may not have gotten the guy in the end, but she did receive Swift’s approval. “I say that’s my baby and I’m really proud,” Swift commented on Rodrigo’s Instagram photo.Read more at The Daily Beast.Get our top stories in your inbox every day. Sign up now!Daily Beast Membership: Beast Inside goes deeper on the stories that matter to you. Learn more.

  • Prince Harry Speaks on Social Media's Role in Capitol Riot: 'There Was a Literal Attack on Democracy'

    The Duke of Sussex spoke to Fast Company about the spread of online misinformation, and when he and Meghan Markle may return to social media.

  • Dow Jones Futures: Stock Market Rally Extended As Apple, Tesla Lead Earnings Tsunami

    The stock market is riding a bullish wave, but here comes a tsunami of earnings, led by Apple and Tesla. With the Nasdaq extended, here's what to do.

  • Conor McGregor vs Dustin Poirier live stream: Free links to UFC 257 fight spread online amid ‘hyper-piracy’

    Illegal streaming sites pop up across Facebook, Reddit and Twitter in build-up to fight

  • AC Milan stay top despite Atalanta defeat as rivals Inter held

    AC Milan held top spot in Serie A on Saturday despite falling 3-0 at home against Atalanta after nearest rivals Inter were held to a goalless draw at Udinese.

  • Packers elevate CB Tramon Williams to gameday roster for NFC title game

    The Packers elevated the veteran cornerback to the gameday roster for Sunday's NFC title game.

  • Eddie Jones admits to being embarrassed by the brilliance of Sir Dave Brailsford

    The two coaches have swapped ideas at meetings where they discussed performance at the highest level of sport.

  • Eva Mendes Took a Step Back from Social Media After Her Daughter Said She 'Was on the Phone Too Much'

    Eva Mendes shares two daughters, Esmeralda Amada, 6, and Amada Lee, 4, with Ryan Gosling

  • ‘A Wild Year on Earth’ Review: Nature Doc Series Is Solid Attempt at a Comprehensive Global Calendar

    BBC America's new entry doesn't reinvent a well-established formula, but it makes stitching together the complexity of the natural world look easy.

  • Looking ahead to the road trip, Trotz describes how new protocols compare to the bubble

    NY Islanders Coach Barry Trotz discusses how road trips will be different for the team as they look ahead to visiting the Capitals and Flyers. Protocols will be different from what they were in the bubble, but "you forge a bit of bond and character on the road".

  • This Swiss Mountaintop Villa Is Filled With Beautiful Stone That Mirrors Its Natural Surroundings

    The modern chalet, designed by Liaigre, is no ordinary winter retreat.

  • Michigan Mega Millions ticket wins $1B jackpot

    Someone in Michigan bought the winning ticket for the $1 billion Mega Millions jackpot, which was the third-largest lottery prize in U.S. history. (Jan. 23)

  • Texas man charged after storming US Capitol, making death threats against Rep. Ocasio-Cortez and police officer

    Miller tweeted "assassinate AOC" hours after posting pictures of himself storming the Capitol. "Next time we bring the guns," he said in another post.