San Francisco-based nonprofit Asian American Journalists Association (AAJA) has sparked online backlash after listing Taiwan as a "province of China" in its “Guide to Covering Asian Pacific America.”
Highly disputed: The AAJA style guide notes that the “fact” of Taiwan’s status as a Chinese province is “disputed by the Taiwan government” and currently fuels current political tension.
Critics accused the nonprofit of seemingly siding with the Chinese government and its stance on Taiwan being a Chinese territory rather than an independent state.
On Twitter, AAJA member William Yang wrote that the guide’s description of Taiwan would be "heavily contested by experts.”
Wow, @aaja, as a member of your organization here in Asia, I have to strongly disagree with your so-called guide to cover #Taiwan. The description below would be heavily contested by experts focusing on Taiwan. https://t.co/hTVIPw6a0G
— William Yang (@WilliamYang120) November 25, 2021
According to the Taiwanese journalist, AAJA has taken its side on Taiwan's political status, which many countries still have no official stand on.
Jessica Drun, a nonresident fellow in the Atlantic Council’s Global China Hub, similarly called out the nonprofit.
I really appreciate the work @aaja does in telling the stories of communities of color, especially AAPI, and for promoting diversity in the newsroom. That said, I do want to gently push back on this framing in their Guide to Covering Asian Pacific America: https://t.co/wqVyDQQPTb pic.twitter.com/0qHsrpwO3j
— Jessica Drun 莊宛樺 (@jessicadrun) November 25, 2021
“The highlighted part is also disputed and is the Chinese government’s view — and one that it forces on other countries,” tweeted Drun, who focuses on security and political issues concerning China and Taiwan. “If we are coming at it from the angle of the United States, Washington’s official position is that Taiwan’s status is undetermined.”
Vice reporter Melissa Chen noted that this is a “reminder that American provincialism on foreign affairs covers POCs as well.”
Absolutely shocking that the Asian American Journalists Association (@aaja), of all orgs, would print the factually incorrect Taiwan is “officially a province of China.” Or perhaps not — a reminder that American provincialism on foreign affairs covers POCs as well. https://t.co/EAT8d3VKUP
— Melissa Chan (@melissakchan) November 25, 2021
Critics have also condemned the guide for ignoring Taiwan’s 16 officially recognized indigenous tribes who have existed for more than 6,500 years. According to AAJA, most "native Taiwanese Chinese" originated from "migrants from Fujian, followed by ’'mainland' Chinese’ and ‘others.’"
An outdated guide: Responding to Drun’s tweets, AAJA President Michelle Ye Hee Lee said the existing style guide is outdated and currently under revision, noting that its 2020 version is merely a republication of the 2012 guide.
“This style guide is from 2012, and we took it down because we're overhauling the style guide,” Lee wrote. “Last year, we put it back up with a note up top that it's under review, [because] reporters asked for help with basic terminology as they covered anti-AAPI violence.”
According to Lee, the nonprofit is “re-evaluating every existing entry” and “launching a public evaluation process to solicit community input and resources.”
NKTV reporter and AAJA member Jeremy Chen has since offered to help in creating a
“more updated entry since it's going to continue to be widely reported and I get questions from other journalists about #Taiwan.”
As a Taiwanese American journalist and @aaja member, what she says below is 100% accurate. @myhlee I'd like to help create a more updated entry since it's going to continue to be widely reported and I get questions from other journalists about #Taiwan. https://t.co/fr1ePlqjGU
— Jeremy Chen (@JeremyChenKTNV) November 26, 2021
Featured Image via AAJA
Enjoy this content? Read more from NextShark!