6 clues that you're a good candidate to refinance your mortgage

Kim Porter
·5 min read
6 clues that you're a good candidate to refinance your mortgage
6 clues that you're a good candidate to refinance your mortgage

As mortgage rates keep plummeting to new all-time lows, homeowners are grabbing hold of opportunities to reduce their monthly payments and total interest costs by swapping out their loans.

This year's spectacular drop in rates has doubled the number of mortgage refinance applications compared to 2019, according to the Mortgage Bankers Association. When you refinance, you get a new home loan with new terms, and you pay off your existing mortgage.

Are you a good candidate to refinance? Look for these six signals that the answer is yes.

1. You could do much better than your current interest rate

Pretty much every homeowner is hunting for a rock-bottom rate. Mortgage giant Freddie Mac says average 30-year mortgage rates just dropped below 2.75% for the first time ever, partly thanks to the Federal Reserve's extreme measures to cut interest rates and bring the economy out of its coronavirus recession.

Some mortgage experts say refinancing isn't worth the time and money involved unless you can slash your rate by at least around three-quarters of 1 percentage point. That means, for example, if you can go from 3.75% down to 3% or lower.

Some 19.4 million homeowners could potentially lower their rate by three-quarters of a point or more — and save an average $309 a month, mortgage data firm mortgage technology and data provider Black Knight reported last week.

Shop around and compare rates from several lenders to find the best rate available to you.

2. Your breakeven point is reachable

Angry woman doing her taxes at home
El Nariz / Shutterstock
Do the math to determine how long it will take you to make back your loan closing costs.

When you get a rate quote from a lender, you should receive an estimate of your new monthly payment and closing costs. Those loan fees typically reach $5,749, according to mortgage data firm ClosingCorp.

When you do the math, you'll see that if you spend $5,749 to save Black Knight's average of $309 a month, it'll take you more than 18 months (a year and a half) to break even. It might not make sense to refinance if you may be moving out of the home relatively soon.

Also consider how long you’ll be paying interest. If you’re 10 years into a mortgage when you refinance into a new 30-year loan, then you’ll be making 40 years’ worth of payments in the long run. In that case, you might want to explore refinancing into a 15-year loan or a 20-year mortgage, instead of going with another 30-year.

3. Your job feels secure

Lenders recheck your employment status right before you close on a refi loan. In recent months, many people have found themselves out of work and out of the running for a new mortgage because of COVID-related lockdowns and business closures.

If you’ve lost your job, your company has shut down or your manager is out of reach due to the virus, the loan could fall through. Having a job that seems secure will help you get your refi.

Try to head off any problems by coordinating with your manager beforehand. And if you think your job may be in danger, keep up your networking and take other steps to protect your finances and find a new job quickly.

4. Your credit score and DTI ratio are where they should be

report credit score banking application risk form document
REDPIXEL.PL / Shutterstock
You'll need a respectable credit score to refinance during the pandemic.

Today's high unemployment raises risks for mortgage lenders, who are demanding higher credit scores and tightening other lending standards to protect themselves.

The average FICO credit score for conventional loan refinance applicants was 762 in May, up from 741 a year earlier, according to mortgage software firm Ellie Mae. If you haven't looked at your score in a while, you can easily check it for free.

Lenders also look more closely at a borrower's debt-to-income ratio, or DTI, which measures what portion of monthly income goes toward debt payments. A lower ratio means less risk for the lender.

A year ago, lenders were approving borrowers with debt-to-income around 36%. Requirements have been stricter this year, and the average borrower has had a DTI of 33%.

If your credit score has dropped recently or you’ve taken on more debt, you might not qualify for a refinance. You’ll need to check with your lender about requirements.

5. A refi will work well within your overall budget

A refi could help lower your monthly payment and create breathing room in your budget. But consider all of your financial goals.

Do you have money earmarked for financial emergencies? It might be better to keep money stashed in savings rather than use it toward closing costs.

And don't go raiding your retirement account to pay for a refinance either. If you have your retirement savings in a 401(k) plan through your job or a traditional IRA and you're younger than age 59 1/2, you'll have to pay income tax on the withdrawal plus a steep penalty equal to 10% of the amount you take out.

6. Your home equity is good

Young man proudly standing in front of a house with big tree blurred in background
CURAphotography / Shutterstock
Having a decent amount of equity in your home will help you get your loan and at a low interst rate.

When calculating your refinance costs, your lender will check your home equity. That’s how much of your home you own, based on the difference between your mortgage balance and the home’s market value.

Having more equity can increase your loan-approval chances (you’ll need at least 20% for conventional loans) and help you get a lower mortgage rate on your refinance.

Refinancing a mortgage is a personal decision. It’s a great way to cut costs and make room in your monthly budget. Just be certain you've got the stuff to qualify for the loan and that you'll stay in the home long enough to actually save money.