I'm Still Thinking About These 13 TV Siblings Who Were Just Replaced As If Nothing Was Different

·7 min read

1.Ruby Stokes played Francesca, the sixth Bridgerton child, on Bridgerton for the first two seasons.

Closeup of Ruby Stokes
David M. Benett / WireImage / Getty Images

Here she is in Season 2:

Ruby Stokes in "Bridgerton"
Liam Daniel / Netflix / Courtesy Everett Collection

It was recently announced that Hannah Dodd would be taking over the role for Season 3.

Closeup of Hannah Dodd

Francesca only appeared briefly in a handful of episodes for the first two seasons. The recasting is reportedly due to Stokes' lead role in Netflix's upcoming Lockwood & Co. and the scheduling conflicts that brings.

Jeff Spicer / Getty Images

2.Jake T. Austin played Jesus on The Fosters for the first two seasons.

Closeup of Jake T. Austin
Amanda Edwards / Getty Images

Noah Centineo took over the role from Season 3 onwards. He also reprised his character in the spinoff, Good Trouble.

Closeup of Noah Centineo

Austin chose to leave The Fosters due to his character's lack of screen time and wanting to pursue other opportunities. In a since-deleted tweet, the actor explained, "I was only asked to return for 3 episodes and wasn’t going to be able to work on anything else, so I left…" However, he also emphasized that he was "honored" to be a part a "groundbreaking" series.

Gabe Ginsberg / WireImage / Getty Images

Here they are in their roles side-by-side:

Side-by-side of Jake T. Austin and Noah Centineo playing Jesus in "The Fosters"
Freeform / Everett Collection

3.Callum Wharry played Tommen, Joffrey and Myrcella's younger brother, in Seasons 1 and 2 of Game of Thrones.

Closeup of Tommen in "Game of Thrones"
HBO

Dean-Charles Chapman took over the role for Seasons 4 through 6.

Closeup of Dean-Charles Chapman

It's never been formally stated why Wharry was recast, but the most likely explanation is that the writers needed to age up Tommen for the character's more mature storylines. Fun fact: Before landing the part of Tommen, Chapman also played Martyn Lannister for just two episodes in Season 3.

Frazer Harrison / Getty Images

Here they are in their roles side-by-side:

Side-by-side of Callum Wharry and Dean-Charles Chapman playing Tommen in "Game of Thrones"
HBO

4.Parker Bagley played Jason, Alison's older brother, for the first season of Pretty Little Liars.

Closeup of Parker Bagley
Jeff Kravitz / FilmMagic / Getty Images

Drew Van Acker took over the role from Seasons 2 to 7.

Closeup of Drew Van Acker

It's unknown why Jason's actor was swapped out, but he wasn't the only Pretty Little Liars character to be recast — for example, Jason and Alison's mom, Jessica, was portrayed by Anne Marie DeLuise in the pilot, then by Andrea Parker from Season 2 onwards. Additionally, Toby was played by James Neate in the pilot and then by Keegan Allen for the remainder of the series.

Robin L Marshall / Getty Images

Here they are in their roles side-by-side:

Side-by-side of Parker Bagley and Drew Van Acker as Jason in "Pretty Little Liars"
Freeform / Getty Images

5.Valerie Jones played Judy, the youngest Winslow daughter, in the pilot of Family Matters.

Closeup of Valerie Jones
Abc Photo Archives / Disney General Entertainment Content via Getty Images

Jaimee Foxworth took over the role after the pilot and played Judy up until Season 4, when her character strangely disappeared without any explanation.

Closeup of Jaimee Foxworth
Jesse Grant / WireImage / Getty Images

Here they are in their roles side-by-side:

Side-by-side of Valerie Jones and Jaimee Foxworth as Judy in "Family Matters"
ABC / Getty Images

6.Bradley Stryker played Trey, Ryan's older brother, in Season 1 of The O.C.

Closeup of Bradley Stryker
Jeffrey Ufberg / Getty Images

Logan Marshall-Green took over the role from Season 2 onward.

Closeup of Logan Marshall-Green
Albert L. Ortega / Getty Images

Here they are in their roles side-by-side:

Side-by-side of Bradley Stryker and Logan Marshall-Green as Trey in "The O.C."
FOX

7.Also on The O.C., Shailene Woodley originally played Kaitlin, Marissa's little sister, in Season 1.

Closeup of Shailene Woodley
Stefania D'alessandro / Getty Images

The character was absent in Season 2, and Willa Holland took over the role from Season 3 on.

Closeup of Willa Holland
C Flanigan / FilmMagic / Getty Images

In an interview with ET Canada, Woodley explained why she was recast: "I was 11, and I was on as a guest, recurring character, or whatever. My character went to boarding school, and when they decided to bring her back, they actually re-auditioned me to bring her back. But I didn’t go through puberty until late: I was the 15-year-old who had no boobs. So, at 11, I was like a little mouse-child. I looked like an 8-year-old. So, there was no weirdness when Willa Holland got it because she was so obviously right for the role…and I was so obviously not."

Here they are in their roles side-by-side:

Side-by-side of Shailene Woodley and Willa Holland as Kaitlin in "The O.C."
FOX

8.Ric Carrott played Chuck, the oldest Cunningham son, in the pilot of Happy Days.

Closeup of Ric Carrott
ABC Photo Archives / Disney General Entertainment Content via Getty Images

Gavan O'Herlihy took over the role for the remainder of Season 1.

Closeup of Gavan O'Herlihy
ABC Photo Archives / Disney General Entertainment Content via Getty Images

The part was then recast a third time, with Randolph Roberts taking over for just two episodes in Season 2.

Randolph Roberts holding a basketball
ABC Photo Archives / Disney General Entertainment Content via Getty Images

Chuck's character disappeared entirely after Season 2. No explanation was ever given as to where he went, and all of the characters acted as if he'd never existed. The example is so infamous that it coined the term "Chuck Cunningham Syndrome."

Chuck Cunningham
ABC

Here are the three Chucks in their roles side-by-side:

Side-by-side of Ric Carrott, Gavan O'Herlihy, and Randolph Roberts as Chuck in "Happy Days."
ABC

9.Lily Nicksay played Morgan, Cory and Eric's little sister, for the first two seasons of Boy Meets World.

Closeup of Lily Nicksay
ABC Photo Archives / Disney General Entertainment Content via Getty Images

Lindsay Ridgeway took over the character from Season 3 onward.

Closeup of Lindsay Ridgeway

Nicksay, who was only 4 years old when she played Morgan, called the recasting a "mutual decision" between her parents and the producers. However, Nicksay did reprise her role for the finale of the Boy Meets World spin-off, Girl Meets World — she appeared alongside Ridgeway!

Ron Galella / Ron Galella Collection via Getty Images

Here they are in their roles side-by-side:

Lily Nicksay and Lindsay Ridgeway as Morgan in "Boy Meets World"
ABC / Getty Images

10.Also on Boy Meets World, Daniel Jacobs (son of the show's executive producer, Michael Jacobs) played Josh, the baby of the Matthews family.

Closeup of Daniel Jacobs
ABC

In Girl Meets World, however, Uriah Shelton took over the role.

Closeup of Uriah Shelton

To be fair, this one makes sense — Jacobs didn't pursue acting as a career, and Josh was a teenager by this point, so the difference wasn't really notable. Still, though!

Tony Rivetti / Disney Channel via Getty Images

Here they are in their roles side-by-side:

Daniel Jacobs and Uriah Shelton as Josh in "Boy Meets World" and "Girl Meets World"
ABC / Disney Channel

11.Jazz Raycole played Claire, the middle Kyle child, for the first season of My Wife and Kids.

Closeup of Jazz Raycole
Albert L. Ortega / Getty Images

Jennifer Freeman took over the role from Season 2 onward.

Closeup of Jennifer Freeman

In an interview with the Christian Post, Raycole explained why she was recast: "I was 12 years old when I got that job. The producers wanted a different thing; they wanted someone a little bit older. I wasn’t ready for that. I ended up going to New York to dance, which was my first passion. I really thank God for that because I got to grow and travel."

Emma Mcintyre / Getty Images

Here they are in their roles side-by-side:

Side-by-side of Jazz Raycole and Jennifer Freeman as Claire in "My Wife and Kids."
ABC

12.Lecy Goranson played Becky on Roseanne from Seasons 1 through 5.

Becky in "Roseanne"
ABC Photo Archives / Disney General Entertainment Content via Getty Images

When Goranson left Roseanne to attend college, Sarah Chalke took over the role from Seasons 6 through 9.

Closeup of Sarah Chalke
Paul Archuleta / Getty Images

However, Goranson then came back and occasionally played the character during Season 8 whenever Chalke wasn't available. Chalke then resumed the role full time again in Season 10. The writers eventually turned the confusing casting sitch into a running gag on the show. Goranson reprised her role as Becky on the reboot, The Conners. Chalke also appeared on the reboot as another character, Andrea, to add to the joke.

Becky and Andrea in "The Connors."
Adam Rose / Disney General Entertainment Content via Getty Images

Here they are in their roles side-by-side:

Side-by-side of Lecy Goranson and Sarah Chalke as Becky in "Roseanne"
ABC / Getty Images

13.And finally, Lisa Robin Kelly played Laurie, Eric's older sister, on That '70s Show in Seasons 1-3, and Season 5.

Closeup of Lisa Robin Kelly
Fotos International / Getty Images

Christina Moore took over the role for Season 6.

Closeup of Christina Moore

Kelly was replaced after she began having problems with alcohol use and took a leave from acting. She died in 2013.

Greg Doherty / Getty Images

Here they are in their roles side-by-side:

Lisa Robin Kelly and Christina Moore as Laurie in "That '70s Show"
FOX