By Olivia Oran (Reuters) - In the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis, the banking industry sought to address an ethics crisis with surveys, town hall meetings, appointments of overseers and mechanisms for employees to report malfeasance. Now, the high-pressure sales scandal at Wells Fargo & Co provides more evidence that large U.S. banks may have little to show for the effort. Bank consultants say tens of millions of dollars are spent each year on initiatives to build a culture of integrity, partly at the urging of regulators such as the Federal Reserve Bank of New York and the U.S. Office of the Comptroller of the Currency. Octavio Marenzi, co-founder of Opimas, a management consultant that focuses on the finance industry, said banks have spent a lot of money researching their culture and updating ethics handbooks - with little impact. "A lot of what the banks are doing are superficial attempts," said Marenzi. "It's more window-dressing than anything else." The continuing spate of scandals reinforces doubts about the effectiveness of such efforts. Wells Fargo's debacle - involving the creation of as many as 2 million accounts without customers' permission – is only the latest black eye for bankers. Other recent lapses have included widespread rigging of benchmark interest rates by traders at several banks; reports that JPMorgan Chase & Co hired children of high-ranking Chinese officials to curry favor; and allegations in a London court that Goldman Sachs Group Inc bankers hired prostitutes for officials at Libya's sovereign wealth fund to win business. Wells has also previously faced accusations of discriminatory mortgage lending practices from local and federal authorities. Wells, which has denied the accusations, reached a settlement with the U.S. Department of Justice in 2012. A FEW BAD APPLES? Earlier this month, Wells reached a $185 million settlement with the U.S. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and the Los Angeles City Attorney over abusive sales tactics involved in the creation of bogus customer accounts. In a statement, Wells Fargo spokesman Mark Folk said the bank takes responsibility for customers receiving products they did not request. "Wells Fargo's culture is committed to the best interests of our customers, providing them with only the products they want and value," Folk wrote. Workers have described a pressure-cooker atmosphere where they risked losing their jobs if they did not hit unrealistic sales targets. They say this pressure defined working for Wells Fargo and directly led to widespread fraud in the opening of bogus accounts. Wells Fargo officials have countered that problems were isolated to a relatively small number of workers. Lawmakers who questioned Wells Fargo Chief Executive John Stumpf at a heated Senate Banking Committee hearing last week were unmoved by this explanation, particularly in light of the bank's firing of 5,300 workers over what it described as improper sales. "Is it normal for 1 percent of a business unit to be fired over fraud?" Republican Sen. David Vitter asked. Democratic Sen. Jeff Merkley later asked a panel of government officials who regulate Wells Fargo or were involved in the settlement why Stumpf attributed the problem to rogue individuals rather than a pervasive culture or structural incentives installed by bank executives. "It's inconsistent with our findings," responded Thomas Curry, U.S. comptroller of the currency. On Tuesday evening, independent directors on the bank's board said they would pursue their own investigation and claw back $41 million worth of previously granted stock awards from Chairman and Chief Executive John Stumpf, who would also forego his salary as the directors' probe continued. In a statement, Lead Independent Director Stephen Sanger said directors would “take all appropriate actions to reinforce the right culture and ensure that lessons are learned, misconduct is addressed, and systems and processes are improved.” REDOUBLED EFFORTS Morgan Stanley CEO James Gorman has said that a creating a culture of integrity is among his top priorities. JPMorgan CEO Jamie Dimon said in the bank's 2014 annual report that his firm needed to "redouble" efforts to reform its culture after making "a number of mistakes - some of them quite painful and costly - over the last several years." The mistakes included a $13 billion deal with the U.S. government to settle allegations of overstating the quality of bad mortgages to investors. Since then, JPMorgan launched an examination of its culture that included interviews between senior executives and over 16,000 employees. Citigroup Inc also recently launched an internal video series in which senior executives discuss how they handled business decisions in gray areas of ethics. The bank also lets employees know when colleagues are dismissed for inappropriate conduct, such as in 2014 when it dismissed 12 employees after finding fraudulent loans in Mexico. This was communicated to the firm in a memo from CEO Michael Corbat. For the first time this year, Morgan Stanley will ask risk and compliance officers to evaluate so-called "material risk-takers," such as bankers and traders. This feedback will play a factor in promotion and compensation decisions. European bank executives are also focused on promoting a culture of honesty. Deutsche Bank AG CEO John Cryan has spoken publicly about the German lender's need to change, while former Barclays PLC CEO Antony Jenkins was so focused on improving the British bank's culture that some employees dubbed him St. Antony. The banks declined to comment for this story. MEASURING CHANGE As they have embarked on these cultural-change campaigns, banks have struggled with how to measure progress. Bankers who spoke to Reuters on condition of anonymity mostly acknowledged their institutions have more work to do. Some have started running employee opinion surveys with questions such as, "What makes you proud to come to work?" and "What impedes the way you do business?" Personality tests can also examine how employees think about risk and how their personal values affect business decisions, said Ernst and Young's Clive Martin, who works with banks on culture issues. Banks are also looking for signs that an employee might engage in bad behavior. For example, if a trader who frequently hits risk limits, misses compliance training, or doesn't take a mandatory two week holiday that is imposed to catch fraud, it could be a red flag, consultants and bank lawyers say. The New York Fed, which has held symposiums on changing the culture of Wall Street, has suggested creating a database of bank employees who were dismissed for bad behavior. Even with all these methods and tactics, some experts see little fundamental improvement. "You can tell banks to be good, and the Fed tries hard - it holds gatherings and seminars, gets us academics in and we talk about stuff," said Shivaram Rajgopal, a professor at Columbia Business School who has researched corporate culture. "The less cynical perspective is, maybe it's hard to move the needle." (Reporting by Olivia Oran in New York; Editing by Lauren Tara LaCapra and Brian Thevenot)
Here's what the US can learn from Switzerland, which has nearly eliminated mass shootings while maintaining a high rate of gun ownership.
- The Daily Beast
Texas DPS/InstagramUVALDE, Texas—The 18-year-old gunman who opened fire at a Texas elementary school, killing at least 19 kids and two adults, wrote three disturbing messages on Facebook just minutes before the massacre, warning of the carnage to come.“I’m going to shoot my grandmother,” Salvador Ramos wrote about 30 minutes before his rampage at Robb Elementary School, Texas Gov. Greg Abbott said Wednesday.Ramos made good on his vow, writing minutes later that he’d “shot my grandmother.” His la
- In The Know by Yahoo
Disney guest claims she couldn't enter Epcot with 'revealing' shirt: 'I had to either leave and change or buy merch'
A Walt Disney World guest claims she pushed the limits of the park's dress code and learned that a popular TikTok "hack" for a free shirt might no longer be an option.
Jason Momoa shared an Instagram photo of him getting an MRI, which prompted fan concern. The star recently underwent hernia surgery but is reportedly ‘OK.’
Elon Musk is the most influential CEO in the world. The mogul with 95 million followers on Twitter is determined to use his platform to weigh in on public debates, whatever they may be. In recent months, the CEO of the electric vehicle manufacturer Tesla has thus imposed his voice on subjects such as the Russian war in Ukraine, free speech with the eventful acquisition-in-progress of the social network Twitter for $44 billion, cancel culture and its corollary wokeism.
- NBC News
The man who opened fire in a Texas elementary school Tuesday, massacring 19 children and two adults, was a loner who kept to himself and avoided any kind of
- Harper's Bazaar
In BAZAAR's latest #DayInTheLife episode, the actress prepares for the stage and talks realizing her childhood theater dreams.
- USA TODAY
Texas school shooter lived in Uvalde: What we know about gunman, motive and how weapons were obtained
The massacre at Robb Elementary School in Uvalde, Texas, is one of the deadliest shootings at a U.S. grade school. Here's what we know about gunman.
- Fort Worth Star-Telegram
“It was a great hangout area for parties, and if given the choice to do it again—I would!” said a good-humored Kim Whiteside, who owns the home at 6145 Whitman Ave.
People Are Praising This Woman For Her Simple Solution To Getting Rid Of Camel Toe When Wearing Biker Shorts Or Leggings
"Saw this at 5 a.m., tried it at 8 a.m. — confirming at 11 a.m. that IT WORKS. YOU ARE AN ANGEL!"View Entire Post ›
Queen Elizabeth previously announced that she would not be attending any garden parties, which celebrate guests' public service, this year
While it's no surprise that Princess Charlotte is a fan of horse riding, it turns out Prince William and Kate Middleton's daughter also has another talent...
The extremist Arizona Republican shared misinformation about the gunman that was circulating on right-wing networks.
- Entertainment Tonight Videos
Morgan Tremaine, a former employee of TMZ, took the witness stand on day 22 of Johnny Depp's defamation trial against his ex-wife, Amber Heard. Tremaine shocked the gallery during an argumentative back-and-forth exchange with Heard's attorney, Elaine Bredehoft, in which he suggested she possibly took on the actress as a client in an attempt to gain '15 minutes of fame.'
The accessory paired perfectly with a necklace featuring the letter "A" for son Archie
- Lexington Herald-Leader
Three Kentucky GOP House committee chairs took losses in Northern Kentucky this primary cycle. What was the driving force behind their defeat and what does it mean for the rest of the state?
- Men's Health
Top Gun: Maverick has now flown into cinemas and as impressive as its flying scenes are, it's the treatment of Val Kilmer's Iceman that leaves a lasting memory.
- NBC Sports BayArea
Steph Curry, LeBron James and other NBA players supported Steve Kerr's message to politicians in the wake of the mass shooting at an elementary school in Uvalde, Texas.
- Entertainment Weekly
A source close to the actress has reacted to the supermodel's testimony, in which she said Depp "never pushed me, kicked me, or threw me down any stairs."
- Business Insider
Russian veterans group calls Putin's special military operation a 'failure' and demands mobilization for 'full-blooded war'
Pro-Russian bloggers, including military and veterans groups, have become increasingly critical of the Kremlin following major losses in Ukraine.