Skip to Navigation
Skip to Main Content
Skip to Related Content
Undocumented Workers Are The Backbone Of Dairies. Will Trump Change That?
Dee J. Hall and Riley Vetterkind | A partnership between Wisconsin Center for Investigative Journalism and HuffPost
October 6, 2017
Read full article
Sign in to post a message.
These factory farms are making the exact same argument that Industrialists did to justify the sweat shops of a century ago. Only back then it was Eastern European immigrants who they preferred to employ since they could force them to work long days for low wages because they were afraid to rock the boat. It is nothing but exploitation for the sake of profits. And normalizing it just increases the flow of illegals into the country while depressing wage growth for everyone.
It's fascinating to me that people will argue for increased wages for hipster Starbucks baristas in one breath—and then turn around and say illegals are needed to keep labor costs down on physically demanding dairy farms. I guess only rich dilettantes need a decent wage—not midwestern farm hands. What a joke.
Why do they not arrest the people who hire illegals?
Undocumented workers wouldn't be a problem if people weren't hiring them so they don't have to pay living wages to Americans.
This is an easy fix. Force dairies to hire DOCUMENTED workers. Fine them if UNDOCUMENTED workers are found on site. Stop using work as an excuse for allowing illegal immigration. You would not let an American citizen work for less than minimum wage, it should be illegal to hire an illegal to do the work for less; and if we are willing to hire legal workers for a decent wage, then do so and stop encouraging people to come here illegally. Hiring an illegal worker is ILLEGAL.
So BIG MILK is knowingly hiring illegal aliens?
Well... that IS a problem.
“We cannot find the American person to come in and work full-time on a dairy,” Ripp said. “It’s too many long hours. It’s too hard of work. And it’s seven days a week, 365 on a dairy farm... A cow does not take a day off.” Do you know what labor laws are, Mr. Farmer? We don't work people 7 days a week, 365 days a year here in America. You hire multiple shifts and pay overtime. That's why any one who is aware of his rights won't work for you. And that is why you want illegal immigration to continue, so that you can continue to pay and treat your workers poorly.
If someone does something illegal, and then benefits from it, and we wring our hands and say "whatever will they do when we enforce the law?" we are participating in dysfunction and illegality.
Really??? Who milked the cows before the illegals were here? Americans did. The only reason an employer would want an illegal is to drive wages down and increase net profits
OK ICE, now you know where to go. And how about getting some legislation through that heavily fines companies that employ illegals and give their CEO's some prison time too?
Sorry being from the milk belt I call BS . . .Americans won't do that work ? are you delusional. You really mean, Americans will not work for $4.00 and hour and a cot . . . in that case, yes, you are correct. The issue with these poor wittle mega-agra-businesses is that want to wring out every penny of profit and the last way to that is through slave wages . . . so please, sell your cow crap to someone who does not know the real truth . . . liars !!
Translation: We pay slave wages so no American would do the job for that price.