• Home
  • Mail
  • News
  • Finance
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Search
  • Mobile
  • More
Yahoo
    • Skip to Navigation
    • Skip to Main Content
    • Skip to Related Content
    • Mail
    Advertisement

    UC Berkeley must face lawsuit alleging bias against conservative speakers

    By Jonathan Stempel
    ,
    Reuters•April 26, 2018

    By Jonathan Stempel

    (Reuters) - A federal judge rejected the University of California at Berkeley's bid to dismiss a lawsuit claiming it discriminated against conservative speakers like Ann Coulter by imposing unreasonable restrictions and fees on their appearances.

    In a decision late Wednesday, U.S. District Judge Maxine Chesney in San Francisco said two conservative groups could pursue claims that the school applied its policy for handling "major events" and an earlier policy for "high-profile speakers" in a manner that unfairly suppressed conservative speech.

    But the judge also said she was "unpersuaded" by claims by the plaintiffs that the school engaged in intentional viewpoint discrimination, and that the major events policy was too vague. She said the plaintiffs could not seek punitive damages.

    The Berkeley College Republicans and the Young America's Foundation, a Tennessee group, had sued after the university canceled Coulter's scheduled speech last April 27, citing security concerns.

    Janet Napolitano, president of the University of California, was also named as a defendant.

    UC Berkeley is known as the birthplace of the student-led Free Speech Movement of the 1960s. Like other schools, it has tried to welcome different views without jeopardizing safety or its educational mission.

    The major events policy was adopted in July, and gave school officials discretion to take various steps to ensure security.

    Chesney said the plaintiffs may pursue an equal protection claim over a security fee charged for an appearance by conservative commentator Ben Shapiro that was well above a fee at the same venue for Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor, part of the court's liberal bloc.

    In a statement on Thursday, UC Berkeley said it was pleased with Chesney's "core" ruling upholding the major events policy, and denied having previously had a "secret" policy for high-profile speakers. It also called the roughly $9,000 fee charged for the Shapiro appearance "lawful and appropriate."

    Harmeet Dhillon, a lawyer for the plaintiffs, also welcomed the decision.

    "It is good news that the case is going forward," Dhillon said in a telephone interview on Thursday. "The First Amendment is a core constitutional principle, and every government policy that restricts, censors or bars otherwise legal speech is unconstitutional."

    The case is Young America's Foundation et al v Napolitano et al, U.S. District Court, Northern District of California, No. 17-02255.


    (Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New York; Editing by David Gregorio and Dan Grebler)

    What to Read Next

    • Buffalo cops resign from unit in protest after two of their own are suspended for injuring 75-year-old

      USA TODAY
    • D.C.’s 16th & H: Network Reporters Talk About Covering A “Surreal” Week Of Protests Near The White House

      Deadline
    • The stranger-than-fiction tale of Circus of Books: How a straight, married, suburban couple became accidental gay porn pioneers

      Yahoo Music
    • Trump Erupts After Attack Target Lisa Page Joins MSNBC As National Security Analyst

      HuffPost
    • New arms race taking shape amid a pandemic and economic crisis

      Yahoo News Video
    • George Floyd live updates: North Carolina memorial; DC could see 'one of the largest' protests

      USA TODAY
    • Trump Tweet Gets Personal Fact-Check From Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey

      HuffPost
    • Officers Charged in George Floyd's Death Not Likely to Present United Front

      The New York Times
    • Reddit's Alexis Ohanian cites daughter with Serena Williams in resigning to make room for black candidate

      Yahoo Sports
    • Floyd protests and Trump's response gave Washington a week it won't soon forget

      Yahoo News
    • Bootstrapping gear for coronavirus tests: How companies innovated to solve a critical shortage

      Yahoo News Video
    • George Floyd: US capital braces for biggest demonstration yet

      BBC
    • Ivanka Trump Gets A Blunt Reminder Of Her Own Complicity After ‘Free Speech’ Call

      HuffPost
    • Do You Use Google Chrome’s Incognito Mode? You May Be Eligible for $5K

      The National Interest
    • Drew Brees to Donald Trump: ‘This is not an issue about the American flag’

      Yahoo Sports
    • 'Stay mad as hell,' says last surviving author of famous report on 1967 riots

      Yahoo News
    • Trump administration orders Marriott to close Cuba hotel

      Yahoo News Video
    • Mourners to remember George Floyd as further protests expected across US

      The Guardian
    • Why 'tough guy' policing fails

      Good Morning America
    • No 'silver lining': Trump faces voter backlash amid crises

      Associated Press
    • 'Riverdale' star Vanessa Morgan says she's tired of black people 'being used as side kick non dimensional characters to our white leads'

      Yahoo TV
    • Two Buffalo police officers charged with assault over alleged shoving of 75-year-old man

      NBC News
    • CDC finds some Americans are still drinking and gargling bleach — here’s what you need to know

      Yahoo Life
    • Young white men with long guns at George Floyd protests likely affiliated with far-right group Boogaloo

      USA TODAY
    • Yahoo News Network
    • Help
    • Privacy (Updated)
    • Privacy dashboard
    • Suggestions
    • About our Ads
    • Terms (Updated)
    • Sitemap