Columbus Councilmember Shayla Favor wins Democratic nomination for Franklin County Prosecutor
County by County Results Athens County Coshocton County Crawford County Delaware County Fairfield County Fayette County Franklin County Guernsey County Hardin County Hocking County Knox County Licking County Madison County Marion County Morgan County Morrow County Noble County Perry County Pickaway County Pike County Ross County Union County
COLUMBUS, Ohio (WCMH) – Columbus City Councilmember Shayla Favor has likely won the Democratic nomination for Franklin County Prosecutor.
With 100% of precincts reporting, Favor leads Anthony Pierson 41% to 35%, according to unofficial election results. Natalia Harris trailed in third place with 24% of the votes.
“We put forth a progressive vision for public safety that voters endorsed,” Favor said. “This race was about more than being a trial attorney — it was about being a leader.”
Three Democrats faced off Tuesday to be the party’s nominee for Franklin County prosecutor, the top legal position in the county. But after a tight race between Pierson and Favor, Favor emerged with more than 27,000 votes.
Favor will face Republican John Rutan in November. If elected, she would be both the first female and first Black prosecutor of Ohio’s most populous county.
Full coverage of major central Ohio races
Favor, recently elected to Columbus City Council after being appointed to it in 2019, ran on a campaign of rebuilding public trust in the prosecutor’s office and addressing systemic issues in the criminal justice system.
Favor was previously an assistant prosecutor in Columbus’ law office, prosecuting zoning, building, health and nuisance code violations. While she’s never prosecuted a felony criminal case, Favor has said the county’s top legal position should be filled by someone who can efficiently and effectively oversee a team of trial attorneys.
Favor said she will focus on addressing inequalities in the criminal justice system that make it unfair for both defendants and victims, like the lengths of cases, sentencing recommendations and decisions on who, and when, to prosecute.
Pierson returned to the prosecutor’s office as its deputy chief legal counsel in 2023 after prosecuting homicides and deadly police shootings for the Ohio Attorney General’s office. He’s been a prosecutor in Dublin, chief legal counsel for Ohio’s juvenile corrections system and held various prosecuting roles in Franklin County.
Pierson campaigned on five main priorities: improving staff training, recruiting and retaining a diverse attorney staff, increasing transparency surrounding officer-involved shootings, and standardizing plea bargain offers and sentencing recommendations. Specifically, Pierson promised that whenever a grand jury declines to indict an officer for use of deadly force, the prosecutor’s office will release the entire case file within 48 hours.
Harris, the chief city attorney of Delaware, has held prosecutorial positions at both the city and county level in her more than two decades of experience.
At the top of Harris’ priorities was increasing the office’s transparency with the public. She argued that significant decisions – like whether to assign outside counsel to prosecute police officers charged with murder – should be explained to the community. Harris also believes data on who is prosecuted, for what charges and to what result should also be publicly available.
With years of appellate experience, having taken cases to the Ohio Supreme Court and federal appeals courts, Harris said strengthening the office’s civil division is another priority for her.
For the latest news, weather, sports, and streaming video, head to NBC4 WCMH-TV.
