Thanksgiving story: One holiday gathering was going to be a little out of the ordinary

The day had started out just right, but Thanksgiving was about to get a littler stranger than usual.
The day had started out just right, but Thanksgiving was about to get a littler stranger than usual.

Whenever someone wants to know what was my most memorable Thanksgiving, I don't usually have to think for very long to come up with my answer. For several years we would go to Thanksgiving at my brother-in-law's home over by Lake Hefner in Oklahoma City.

This particular year, I got up early and went to a 5K Turkey Run. After the race, I drove back home to Choctaw and picked up my wife who had been cooking all morning. We took a couple of pots of food over to my in-laws listening to "Alice's Restaurant" by Arlo Guthrie on the way over. It was a tradition that KRXO would play Arlo's classic every year at noon, and we always timed it so we could hear it on the way over to the in-laws' house. We were supposed to be there at 1 p.m. for the family luncheon. It always took at least a half hour to get to their house. "Alice's Restaurant" ran almost 20 minutes.

When we got to their neighborhood, there was road construction so we had to go in a back way, but it was still just after 12:30 when we found a parking spot on the crowded street. We grabbed a pot of food apiece and rushed up to the porch. I knocked on the door and heard, "Come in." I entered the home followed by my wife. I saw more people than usual, but sometimes my in-laws invited people from their church. I gave my nephew, who was seated at a corner table, a wave and carried the food into the kitchen.

I did think it was kind of odd that everyone had already started eating as I thought we were on time. I sat my pot of food down on a table in the kitchen where even more people were seated. It was then I had time to look around and I noticed I did not know anyone in the room. I got this sinking feeling in my stomach as I realized we were at the wrong house! Everyone was very friendly and they even invited us to join them for their lunch. The "nephew," well, at a closer glance, he sort of resembled our nephew, but it wasn't him.

The people promised they wouldn't tell my in-laws, who lived next door, as we hurriedly exited. Over the years I have come to accept that perhaps it was just a perfect storm that allowed those events to happen: I was perhaps tired from the race, we were in a hurry, had to take a slightly different route, it was a crowded street, and an overcast day. Probably the real truth is that I was still singing the refrain of "Alice's Restaurant" in my head and not really paying attention to anything. Nothing wrong with that!

John Carpenter
John Carpenter

John Carpenter, of Choctaw, is a retired U.S. probation officer, a life-long Oklahoman and proud graduate of Oklahoma State University.  

This article originally appeared on Oklahoman: Thanksgiving gathering seemed a little strange that year