Your Tax Dollars Are Being Used To Attack Patagonia
WASHINGTON — The House Committee on Natural Resources has joined Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke’s fight against Patagonia, accusing the American outdoor retailer of lying in order to sell merchandise.
On Friday, the committee — which is chaired by Rep. Rob Bishop (R-Utah) — posted an image to Twitter that reads, “Patagonia Is Lying To You ... A corporate giant hijacking our public lands debate to sell more products to wealthy elitist urban dwellers from New York to San Francisco.”
That the post comes from an official government account has raised both ethical and legal questions.
.@Patagonia doesn't want #MonumentsForAll, they just want your money #BearsEars pic.twitter.com/2nuvfS0imZ
— Natural Resources (@NatResources) December 8, 2017
Walter Shaub, the former director of the U.S. Office of Government Ethics, said the federal government “officially and publicly calling a company a liar for political reasons is a bizarre and dangerous departure from civic norms.”
Shaub also wrote that the “attack” on Patagonia “sure looks a lot like a violation” of House committee rules dealing with social media communication.
When a federal government official publicly calls you a liar on an official social media account, without any due process whatsoever, the first thing you should do is call a lawyer. The second thing you should do is find out the name of the official who posted this tweet. https://t.co/0D7Doj6dkk
— Walter Shaub (@waltshaub) December 9, 2017
Here we go. The House committees handbook limits Committee social media communications much likeMember social media accounts. This attack on @patagonia sure looks a lot like a violation, Ben. https://t.co/1Ujw87irzA pic.twitter.com/cM1QdqJF3d
— Walter Shaub (@waltshaub) December 9, 2017
Patagonia has been a fierce critic of the Trump administration’s monthslong review of protected national monuments. The company has joined a coalition that’s suing to block the sweeping cuts that President Donald Trump made last week to Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante national monuments.
After Trump signed a pair of proclamations to dismantle the protected Utah sites, Patagonia updated its home page with the words “The President Stole Your Land.”
The post from Bishop’s committee closely resembles one earlier this week from Patagonia.
This is the largest elimination of protected land in American history.
Take Action: https://t.co/biZPxo7PHh#BearsEars pic.twitter.com/OqW9FHPk3Q— Patagonia (@patagonia) December 4, 2017
In the days since Patagonia responded to Trump’s move to gut the Utah monuments by a collective 2 million acres, Zinke has railed against the private company.
He’s dismissed it as a “special interest” that makes its products in China, and told Fox Business on Friday that the company “should focus on how to bring manufacturing back into the country instead of lying to the public about losing federal land.”
While it’s true that the land remains public and under federal control, withdrawing monument status opens the door for drilling, mining and other development.
Along with its post to Twitter, the House committee sent out a newsletter Friday that some saw as a call for individuals to boycott the company. The email, posted to Twitter by David Feinman, the director of government relations for the Conservation Lands Foundation, contained the subject line: “The Source (Patagonia: don’t buy it)”.
Love HuffPost? Become a founding member of HuffPost Plus today.
— David Feinman (@davefeinman) December 8, 2017
fairly sure it’s a violation of House rules to use official resources to call for a boycott of a company. perhaps House Ethics should review. thoughts @NRDems, @RepRaulGrijalva?
— David Feinman (@davefeinman) December 8, 2017
In a response to Feinman, Ben Goldey, the committee’s digital director, said “nobody is calling for a boycott.”
Nobody is calling for a boycott🤔
— Ben Goldey (@BenGoldey) December 8, 2017
Committee spokeswoman Katie Schoettler echoed that message Saturday.
“We’re not urging a boycott of Patagonia,” she said in an email statement. “We’re calling on them to stop selling a false narrative and to refrain from distributing misleading statements.”
Both former government ethics director Shaub and Democrats on the Senate Committee on U.S. and National Resources urged the House committee to delete the post. As of Saturday afternoon it remained up.
Goldey did not address Shaub’s conclusion that the post violated committee rules, but wrote on Twitter, “it’s clear we disagree with [Patagonia’s] statement that ‘The President Stole Your Land.’”
It's clear we disagree with their statement that "The President Stole Your Land." Feel free to email me for further comment.
— Ben Goldey (@BenGoldey) December 9, 2017
This story has been updated with a statement from the House Committee on Natural Resources.
Also on HuffPost
Basin and Range National Monument, Nevada
Bears Ears National Monument, Utah
Berryessa Snow Mountain National Monument, California
Canyons of the Ancients National Monument, Colorado
Carrizo Plain National Monument, California
Cascade Siskiyou National Monument, Oregon
Craters of the Moon National Monument, Idaho
Giant Sequoia National Monument, California
Gold Butte National Monument, Nevada
Grand Canyon-Parashant National Monument, Arizona
Grand Staircase Escalante National Monument, Utah
Hanford Reach National Monument, Washington
Ironwood Forest National Monument, Arizona
Mojave Trails National Monument, California
Organ Mountains-Desert Peaks National Monument, New Mexico
Rio Grande del Norte National Monument, New Mexico
Sand to Snow National Monument, California
San Gabriel Mountains National Monument, California
Sonoran Desert National Monument, Arizona
Upper Missouri River Breaks National Monument, Montana
Vermilion Cliffs National Monument, Arizona
Katahdin Woods and Waters National Monument, Maine
Marianas Trench Marine National Monument, Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands/Pacific Ocean
Northeast Canyons and Seamounts Marine National Monument, Atlantic Ocean
Pacific Remote Islands Marine National Monument, Pacific Ocean
Papahanaumokuakea Marine National Monument, Hawaii/Pacific Ocean
Rose Atoll Marine National Monument, American Samoa/Pacific Ocean
This article originally appeared on HuffPost.