By Andrew Chung WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The U.S. Supreme Court gave presidents more control over key jobs in federal agencies on Thursday, ruling that the way the Securities and Exchange Commission selected in-house judges who enforce investor protection laws violated the U.S. Constitution. The justices agreed with President Donald Trump's administration that the SEC, in having low-level staff install administrative law judges, infringed upon powers given to the president in the U.S. Constitution's "appointments clause" regarding the filling of certain federal posts. The ruling could reverberate through the federal government, which has nearly 2,000 administrative law judges who decide matters as varied as unfair trade practices, veterans benefits and patent infringement. The court's 7-2 decision backed Raymond Lucia, a California-based former radio host and investment adviser who was banned by an SEC administrative law judge from investment-related work and fined $300,000 for making misleading claims in his "Buckets of Money" retirement wealth strategy. The ruling marked a victory for the Republican president, who has sought to limit the power of certain federal agencies. Trump's administration sided with Lucia, reversing the government's previous stance supporting the SEC taken by the administration of his Democratic predecessor, Barack Obama. The Justice Department said it was pleased with the decision. The ruling, authored by liberal Justice Elena Kagan, could also make it easier for these in-house judges to be fired by a president's political appointees in agencies rather than being protected from such action, as is currently the case. The justices overturned a lower court ruling that had endorsed the SEC's hiring practice for the judges. The agency's commissioners, who are presidentially appointed, should have named them, not SEC staff, the justices said. Six justices found the hiring process unconstitutional while Justice Stephen Breyer said it violated only federal administrative law. Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Sonia Sotomayor dissented. Lucia must now be given a new hearing in front of a properly appointed administrative judge, or the commission itself, the justices said. 'CONSTITUTIONAL ACCOUNTABILITY' "We are thrilled with the result, which is a victory for the rule of law, constitutional accountability and liberty," Lucia's attorney Mark Perry said. An SEC spokesman said the agency is reviewing the decision. The SEC had argued that its judges were merely employees in part because their decisions are not final and still subject to review by the commission. It marked the latest case in which the Supreme Court limited the SEC's powers. The justices last year scaled back the agency's ability to recover ill-gotten profits from defendants' misconduct, and on Monday accepted a case that could narrow the scope of defendants' liability for securities fraud. With Thursday's decision, "the Supreme Court continues its growing streak of rebukes to the SEC," said Nick Morgan, a lawyer at the firm Paul Hastings who previously worked in the agency's enforcement division. Kagan said administrative judges wield powers extensive enough to qualify under the Constitution as "inferior officers" subject to appointment by the president, a federal department head or a court. Just "as armies can often enforce their will through conventional weapons, so too can administrative judges," Kagan said. The SEC charged Lucia with securities fraud in 2012. SEC Administrative Law Judge Cameron Elliot found him liable, barring him from the industry and ordering him to pay $300,000 in fines. Corporate rights groups had complained that as the SEC's enforcement powers expanded, it sent more cases to its own judges rather than federal district courts, giving the agency an unfair "home court" advantage. The ruling could affect dozens of cases pending before the SEC and other cases in federal appeals courts. Perry, Lucia's lawyer, said there are about 150 administrative judges across 25 agencies who might fall under the officer designation. (Reporting by Andrew Chung; Editing by Will Dunham)
Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting
- Miami Herald
A Royal Caribbean International cruise ship left from PortMiami with 600 passengers on board Sunday evening — part of a test sail trip as the cruise industry gears up for a grand restart later this summer.
- The Telegraph
The Duchess of Sussex has revealed that she hid references to Diana, Princess of Wales in her new children's book. The Bench, which was inspired by Prince Harry’s relationship with the couple’s two-year-old son Archie, includes illustrations of Princess Diana's favourite flower, forget-me-nots. The subtle nod to the Princess is one of numerous personal "nuggets tucked within the book", the Duchess said on Sunday in her first media interview regarding the book. The Duchess’ debut publication topp
Prince Charles shares throwback Father's Day photo with Prince Harry amid reports that he won't let Archie become a prince
Prince Charles told the Sussexes that he will change key legal documents to make sure that Archie doesn't inherit the "prince" title, said reports.
- Business Insider
Sen. Ron Johnson, who stalled the passing of Juneteenth as a federal holiday, was booed at an event commemorating the day
Johnson said it would be too costly to give federal employees another day off, but conceded his efforts on Tuesday.
- Business Insider
MyPillow CEO Mike Lindell suggests 'divine appointments' were responsible for him connecting with former president Trump
At a Florida event, the MyPillow founder said that "one prophet guy" told him years ago that he and Donald Trump would become great friends.
- USA TODAY
During more than five years of harassment, about 30 pieces of mail with homophobic names on them were sent to the couple’s home in Massachusetts.
A Florida man pulled out a gun on a Starbucks employee who turned out to be the local police chief's daughter
"It was upsetting to me to know that someone would go to that extreme not having cream cheese on his bagel," Police Chief Noel-Pratt said, the AP reported.
- LA Times
A survey after the insurrection in January found that 56% of Republicans agreed that force might be needed to save "the traditional American way of life."
The Portuguese soccer star bought the 2,500-square-foot pad for $18.5 million in 2015. He first put it on the market in 2019.
- LA Times
Colt Brennan was a star football player at Hawaii who finished third in Heisman Trophy voting before years of substance abuse problems cost him his life.
- The Telegraph
Marine Le Pen's far-Right National Rally party took the lead in the key battleground region of Provence in the first round of voting, the first exit poll said on Sunday night, amid a historically low turnout. The regional election on Sunday was regarded as a major test of whether Ms Le Pen can win votes, less than a year ahead of a presidential election which is largely expected to pit the far-right leader against incumbent president Emmanuel Macron. Overall, the National Rally party, or RN, is
- Business Insider
GOP congressman lashes out at Juneteenth becoming a federal holiday: 'Are we going to do one for the Native American Indians?'
Rep. Ralph Norman was one of 14 Republicans who voted against the new federal holiday commemorating the day enslaved Black people were told they were free.
Disruption in the shipping industry is creating a shortage of goods - and consumers face higher prices.
- Lexington Herald-Leader
Crews rescued a trapped woman who was then taken to a hospital.
- Business Insider
Fauci pushes back against the 'craziness' of attacks on his evolving pandemic response, saying 'that's the way science works'
Dr. Anthony Fauci told Kara Swisher that people who criticized his shifting stance on masks are "actually criticizing science," Axios reported.
An American student and former Marine was found dead in Russia days after texting her mom: 'I hope I'm not being abducted'
Days before her body was found, Catherine Serou texted her mom saying, "In a car with a stranger. I hope I'm not being abducted," NPR reported.
- Idaho Statesman
A new understanding of the life of the Pacific Northwest missionary shows how little we really know about our past, writes Bob Kustra.
Gene Hackman, who played family patriarch Royal, was unhappy with his low salary, the cast and creators revealed during a 2021 Tribeca Festival panel.
- The State
Lap-by-lap highlights from the NASCAR race at Nashville Superspeedway.
- Yahoo News
Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Fla., is preparing to introduce a bill that would place new sanctions on China unless it allows “a transparent international investigation of suspect laboratories in Wuhan."