St. George opponents ask Louisiana Supreme Court to rehear case, say new city can’t incorporate

BATON ROUGE, La. (BRPROUD) – East Baton Rouge Metropolitan Councilman LaMont Cole, who sued to keep St. George from incorporating, has requested that the Louisiana State Supreme Court rehear the case and reverse their ruling or reinstate the lower courts’ decisions.

In April, the court found that legal error led to lower courts denying the incorporation, and the lower court’s judgment was reversed. The city’s incorporators and electors won the judgment requested.

The lower court said a challenge to the incorporation was the new city’s timely ability to provide services, which will be split between parish-provided and non-parish-provided. But justices said parish-provided services wouldn’t be affected by incorporating.

In the Thursday, May 9, request for a rehearing, attorneys said the Supreme Court “is ill-equipped and unauthorized to conduct the evidentiary hearing required to set the date of incorporation or fix its boundaries” if St. George is incorporated.

“The decision, in this case, should be reversed and the decision of the lower courts reinstated or, at a minimum, rehearing and remand to remedy these deficiencies is crucial to avoid the chaos of litigation that is certain to follow,” attorneys said.

What you need to know about St. George: New Louisiana city will be in East Baton Rouge Parish

East Baton Rouge Mayor-President Sharon Weston-Broome, who was on the initial lawsuit arguing against incorporation, released a statement Thursday.

Today’s request for a rehearing in the St. George lawsuit is a testament to the robustness of our legal system, providing avenues for citizens to seek resolution. While I’m not a plaintiff in this case, I fully support every individual’s right to engage with the courts, particularly in significant matters like this.

As Mayor-President, I recognize the pivotal moment our parish faces and the need for unwavering leadership. I’ve listened to the diverse range of sentiments expressed by our citizens, from jubilation to apprehension. It’s my solemn duty to address every query regarding the financial implications for our City-Parish and its residents.

Over the past year, my administration has diligently crafted budget models, collaborated with department heads to assess debt responsibilities, retirement effects, and, above all, the provision of essential services.

We stand poised and equipped to advocate for the welfare of all 445,000 parish residents, ensuring that East Baton Rouge remains an affordable, harmonious, and flourishing community for families.

In furtherance of this commitment, I’m pleased to announce the appointment of William Potter to the St. George transition taxing district, as stipulated by the 2020 legislation. Mr. Potter brings a wealth of expertise as a respected CPA and financial analyst, honed through his tenure at the esteemed firm, Postlethwaite & Netterville.

It’s imperative to clarify that my appointment is neither belated nor negligent. The enabling legislation triggers the establishment of the transition tax district upon incorporation validation.

Should the rehearing be denied, Mr. Potter stands ready to serve and represent my administration with diligence and proficiency.

Baton Rouge Mayor-President Sharon Weston-Broome

Andrew Murrell, the attorney who represented the incorporators, said in a Friday statement that the request is “an assault on the St. George citizen’s right to vote and self-governance.”

Read his full statement below.

The rehearing request is an assault on the St. George citizen’s right to vote and self-governance. Reading the majority opinion, you can only reach the conclusion that St. George is incorporated. The rehearing request continues to push false narratives that are neither supported by facts or by the law. It should be denied because there is nothing in the court’s record that supports the falsehoods contained in the opposition’s argument for rehearing.

This rehearing request is an illustration of an old legal saying, “When you don’t have the facts, you pound the law. When you don’t have the law, you pound the facts. When you don’t have either, you pound the desk.”

The citizens of St. George are moving forward with the creation of our citizen. This city will be an example of efficiency and accountability. Our community welcomes anyone with a desire to create a better for our children and grandchildren.

Andrew Murrell

Latest News

For the latest news, weather, sports, and streaming video, head to BRProud.com.