Saying 'Be Careful' to Kids Actually Makes a Difference


You may think it’s falling on deaf ears when you tell your kid to “Be more careful next time” after a bad fall, but a new study that looked at parent-child conversations about safety suggests otherwise: Researchers found that conversations parents have with their children after a serious injury, explaining why the activity was dangerous, helps kids internalize safety values and may help them be more careful in the long run.

“Early on, parents use supervision to keep their kids safe,” Elizabeth E. O’Neal — study author and a Ph.D. candidate in the department of psychological and brain sciences at the University of Iowa — tells Yahoo Parenting. “As infants, they always have an eye on them. But as they get older, supervision lessens by necessity because parents can’t follow them around all the time. So parents needs to find a new way to keep kids safe.”

STORY: Mom Shares Photo of 3-Year-Old Son After Dry Drowning Scare

The researchers found that parents use several strategies to help their kids avoid injuries, including explaining an alternative plan for doing the same activity without getting hurt (like advising them to walk, not jump, down the stairs) or simply telling them to be more careful. The study also found that parents were more likely to explain why a behavior was dangerous if the child was older, starting around age 7.

STORY: 8 Things Our Parents Never Had to Worry About

That’s likely because parents feel an older child can better understand why the activity is risky. However, O’Neal says children are never too young to understand a simple explanation of why a behavior is dangerous. “When children are really young, parents might say, ‘Don’t touch that,’ but adding, ‘Don’t touch that — it’s hot and it could burn you’ can help,” she says.

The study also revealed some not-so-surprising gender differences: Parents are four times more likely to tell their daughters to be careful than their sons. “Boys are at greater risk of being injured than girls are,” notes O’Neal. “Parents often encourage boys to take risks, whereas they don’t as often with girls. But telling girls to be more careful might contribute to these lower injury risks of girls.”

No parent wants their child to get hurt, but on the flipside, being overly protective isn’t helpful either. “It’s a fine line,” she says. “Kids have to push their limits of their physical abilities to learn new skills, but girls aren’t getting encouraged to do this as often.”

If your kid does get hurt, having a conversation with him or her about why that behavior is risky and ways to avoid injuries in the future can help. Those safety messages do sink in over time.

“Parents are really the first line of defense when it comes to preventing injuries,” says O’Neal. “The same way that parents install moral values in their children, parents can work to install safety values, and one day you realize, ‘Oh, they get it!’ Parents are teaching their children about what in their surroundings could lead to injury, so that when kids are navigating a new dangerous situation, they can think, ‘Maybe jumping from this tree is not a good idea.’”

(Photo: iStock)

Please follow @YahooParenting on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and Pinterest. Have an interesting story to share about your family? Email us at YParenting (at)