This past week, more than a century and a half after the end of the Civil War, the United States military got around to effectively banning the flag of the Confederacy, a short-lived nation built explicitly on the idea of white supremacy. At roughly the same time, the U.S. Supreme Court was voting to uphold a law in Florida that would require those who had been convicted of felonies and served their time to still pay a fine before they can vote—a fee that would disproportionately burden Black people. And Americans were finding out that Breonna Taylor, a Black EMT in Kentucky, received no medical help for at least 20 minutes after three plainclothes officers killed her during a no-knock raid on the wrong apartment. The officers haven’t been charged with a crime.
Then John Lewis died. With his death, the country lost a civil rights icon, a man whose skull was cracked during a beating on the Edmund Pettus Bridge at the hands of a state trooper and went on to become the second Black person to represent Georgia in Congress since Reconstruction.
Amid the news of these past few weeks, it’s easy to feel like Lewis’ legacy might also be dying. That’s why the United States should make a symbolic commitment to the values Lewis nearly died for. First, Alabama should rename the Edmund Pettus Bridge, named after a lead member of the Ku Klux Klan, for Lewis instead. But more important, Americans should also look to the heart of the U.S. government, the Capitol, where a statue to Alexander Hamilton Stephens, the vice president of the Confederate States of America, still stands. The United States cannot be a country that honors both Stephens and Lewis; after this summer, after the death of Lewis, Americans have to make a choice. And it should begin with replacing the Stephens statue with one honoring Lewis.
Like Lewis, Stephens was also a Georgia legislator. Elected in 1843 as a Whig, he gradually began voting with Democrats in the following decades. He was elected as a delegate to the Georgia Secession Convention, established as a response to the election of Abraham Lincoln, in 1861. That same year, he was chosen by the Congress of the Confederacy to be the vice president of the provisional government.
Stephens delivered a speech that remains maybe the clearest distillation of white supremacy ever uttered not long before the first shots of the Civil War were fired at Fort Sumter in Charleston, South Carolina, in 1861. He argued in the now-infamous “Cornerstone” speech that the founders had it wrong; that there was no real tension between liberty and race-based chattel slavery if science and God’s purpose were properly understood. “Many governments have been founded upon the principle of the subordination and serfdom of certain classes of the same race; such were and are in violation of the laws of nature. Our system commits no such violation of nature's laws. With us, all of the white race, however high or low, rich or poor, are equal in the eye of the law. Not so with the negro. Subordination is his place. He, by nature, or by the curse against Canaan, is fitted for that condition which he occupies in our system,” Stephens thundered during the speech.
He said the “cornerstone” of the Confederate States of America, whose Constitution established permanent Black enslavement, rested “upon the great truth that the negro is not equal to the white man; that slavery subordination to the superior race is his natural and normal condition. This, our new government, is the first, in the history of the world, based upon this great physical, philosophical, and moral truth. … It is upon this, as I have stated, our social fabric is firmly planted.”
He was making explicit what Thomas Jefferson, George Washington and others had made implicit about eight decades earlier in the U.S. Constitution, which had a number of clauses that protected the interests of slave owners.
No matter. The Architect of the Capitol, the agency in charge of landmark buildings in Washington describes Stephens as “a dedicated statesman, an effective leader, and a powerful orator, always seeking moderation and peace,” a white-washed story of an overt racist that is all too typical in American history. This denial is what made it possible for a man like Donald Trump to become president despite his numerous faults and lack of political experience and unlikely for a man like Lewis to make it to the White House despite his outsize role in helping perfect this nation.
It took Americans like Lewis—and Rev. C.T. Vivian, another civil rights icon who died this past week—to undo the damage caused by men like Stephens. It was Americans like Lewis who made the words Thomas Jefferson wrote real. It was Americans like Lewis who lived a life of self-sacrifice in a way many previous leaders failed to. Lewis loved the white people who repeatedly jailed him and beat him and nearly killed him. George Washington couldn’t be bothered to free the Black men and women toiling in bondage on his estate. The bankruptcy of the ideas of men like Stephens and Pettus was made clearer because of the presence of Americans like Lewis.
That’s why he’s the kind of American we long should have been building monuments and memorials to. And we wouldn’t even have had to downplay or ignore his participation in great evils by saying he was just “a man of his time”—because he was too busy building a new era. He fought for racial equality for Black people and Native Americans and those in the LBGTQ community and everyone else he found on the wrong side of disparities and discrimination.
Though I met him only once, I suspect Lewis would be telling us that instead of replacing the Stephens statue with one to him, he’d rather see the Voting Rights Act restored; that he’d want us to not forget about the injustice inflicted upon Breonna Taylor, her family and community and the importance of making a reality significant, long-lasting policing reforms; that while symbols are powerful and must be grappled with, he wouldn’t want us to settle for such gestures. (He supported removal of the Stephens bust but not in favor of renaming the Pettus bridge, saying that such a change would “compromise the historical integrity of the voting rights movement.”) He’d warn us to never forget what his friend Martin Luther King Jr. said, that injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.
This country has seldom deserved the kindness, courage and compassion of men like Lewis, who never allowed their righteous anger to become a burning bitterness. Replacing a statue, compared to the sacrifices Lewis made, is easy work, but it shows a commitment to finishing his work and leaving our old idols behind. It’s the least we owe him.