One Wisconsin restaurant named one of the top 100 ‘Seafood Spots’ in America, according to Yelp

(WFRV) – Wisconsinites craving some seafood can travel to Milwaukee to have some of the best seafood in the country, according to Yelp.

St. Paul Fish Company in Milwaukee cracked Yelp’s list of the top 100 seafood spots in 2024. On St. Paul Fish Company’s website, there appears to be another location in Mequon.

Their menu has a variety of items ranging from fish tacos to a traditional fish fry. St Paul Fish Company came in at 79 in the top 100 list. It was also the only Wisconsin restaurant to make the list.

Thanks for signing up!

Watch for us in your inbox.

Subscribe Now

Local 5 Community News

Take a look at Yelp’s top 25 below, then head over to the site for the full list of 100 well-reviewed restaurants that will de-scale and de-gut your sea creatures before bringing them to the table.

  1. Blue Seafood & Spirits – Virginia Beach, Virginia

  2. Bajamar Seafood & Tacos – Las Vegas, Nevada

  3. Holbox – Los Angeles, California

  4. 167 Raw Oyster Bar – Charleston, South Carolina

  5. Hook & Anchor – Newport Beach, California

  6. Happy Snapper Seafood Restaurant – Orlando, Florida

  7. J Crab House — Kissimmee, Florida

  8. Mr. Shuck’s Seafood – Brunswick, Georgia

  9. South Bay Wild Fish House – Astoria, Oregon

  10. Los Tortugo’s Seafood Market – Port Isabel, Texas

  11. Dockside Seafood Restaurant – Jacksonville Beach, Florida

  12. Oceana Restaurant – Palm Desert, California

  13. FreshCo Fish Market & Grill – Miami, Florida

  14. Joe’s Oyster Bar – Port Isabel, Texas

  15. Xi Yue Hui Seafood Hot Pot AYCE (All You Can Eat) – Brooklyn, New York

  16. Seafood Broiler – Norco, California

  17. Indialantic Seafood Company – Indialantic, Florida

  18. Scooter’s Fish House – Navarre, Florida

  19. Portofino – San Francisco, California

  20. The Crawfish Hut – Burien, Washington

  21. Stewby’s Seafood Shanty – Fort Walton Beach, Florida

  22. Albany Fish Company – Albany, Georgia

  23. Nine Seafood Restaurant – Cerritos, California

  24. Mariscos Costa Alegre – San Jose, California

  25. Matunuck Oyster Bar — South Kingstown, Rhode Island

In compiling its 2024 list of the “Top 100 Seafood Spots,” Yelp’s team limited its rankings to restaurants within the platform’s seafood category, concentrating on those with reviews that frequently mentioned the word “seafood” specifically. These eateries were then ranked based on criteria including each restaurant’s Yelp ratings and volume of reviews as of Dec. 31, 2023. Yelp’s analysts also limited the number of list entries per state, for purposes of “geographic diversity.”

Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources asking public not to burn due to elevated fire danger

No additional information was provided.

For the latest news, weather, sports, and streaming video, head to WFRV Local 5 - Green Bay, Appleton.