Librarian Rejects Melania Trump's Gift Of Dr. Seuss Books

Cavan Sieczkowski
Updated

A Cambridge, Massachusetts, librarian is making headlines after declining a gift of Dr. Seuss books from first lady Melania Trump.

In celebration of National Read a Book Day on Sept. 6, Trump and the Department of Education chose a school in each state to receive 10 Dr. Seuss books based on school programs that have “achieved high standards of excellence, recognized by State and National awards and Blue Ribbon Awards.”

Cambridgeport School was one of those selected, but librarian Liz Phipps Soeiro decided to decline the offer.

In an open letter published on Horn Book’s website on Tuesday, Phipps Soeiro explained that her school is located city where “yearly per-pupil spending ... is well over $20,000.” The librarian suggested the books would be better off in “underfunded and underprivileged communities that continue to be marginalized and maligned by policies put in place by Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos.”

Melania Trump gives Dr. Seuss books to patients as she visits the Queen Fabiola Children's Hospital in Brussels in May. (Photo: AURORE BELOT via Getty Images)
Melania Trump gives Dr. Seuss books to patients as she visits the Queen Fabiola Children's Hospital in Brussels in May. (Photo: AURORE BELOT via Getty Images)

″[My] school doesn’t have a NEED for these books,” Phipps Soeiro wrote. She argued that Trump’s access to Dr. Carla Hayden, the current Librarian of Congress, should have resulted in a less “tired and worn” selection of titles. Seuss books, she said, are also “steeped in racist propaganda, caricatures, and harmful stereotypes.” (Potentially racist themes in Seuss’ work are a widely discussed topic in children’s literature.)

Phipps Soeiro closed the note by thanking Trump for the recognition, and reminding her of the responsibility the first lady and President Donald Trump have to children across the country:

I am honored that you recognized my students and our school. I can think of no better gift for children than books; it was a wonderful gesture, if one that could have been better thought out. Books can be a powerful way to learn about and experience the world around us; they help build empathy and understanding ... You and your husband have a direct impact on these children’s lives. Please make time to learn about and value them. I hope you share these books with your family and with kids around the country. And I encourage you to reach out to your local librarian for more recommendations.

Following the publication of the open letter, Phipps Soeiro faced backlash on social media for rejecting the gift, and her accounts are now private or deleted. A follow-up blog post from Horn Book argued that the librarian’s main point, the more-than-adequate funding of her school, had been largely overlooked.

Still, the White House pushed back, saying it was “unfortunate” the situation became “divisive.”

“Mrs. Trump intends to use her platform as First Lady to help as many children as she can,” the first lady’s spokeswoman, Stephanie Grisham, said in a statement sent to HuffPost on Friday. “She has demonstrated this in both actions and words since her husband took office, and sending books to children across the country is but one example. To turn the gesture of sending young students some books into something divisive is unfortunate, but the First Lady remains committed to her efforts on behalf of children everywhere.”

The Cambridge school system told CBS Boston that Phipps Soeiro was not authorized to accept or reject the book donation.

But Roger Sutton, editor in chief of Horn Book, a Massachusetts-based children’s publisher, stands behind Phipps Soeiro. He told HuffPost in an email, “The fact that I okayed this piece for publication is statement enough.”

Also on HuffPost:

Latanya N. Jenkins, Reference Librarian for Government Information and African American Studies - Samuel L Paley Library

“The greatest challenge we face today is the lack of a comprehensive way to make resources available. Libraries provide access to information, connecting people and the things they’re looking for. If my library shut down tomorrow there would be chaos.”
“The greatest challenge we face today is the lack of a comprehensive way to make resources available. Libraries provide access to information, connecting people and the things they’re looking for. If my library shut down tomorrow there would be chaos.”

Kyle K. Courtney, Copyright Advisor at Harvard University Library

“Libraries are more important to our world than people realize. We are the 'holders of forever' ensuring access to our cultural heritage while providing the free access and flow of information to anyone in the world. All you have to do is ask.”
“Libraries are more important to our world than people realize. We are the 'holders of forever' ensuring access to our cultural heritage while providing the free access and flow of information to anyone in the world. All you have to do is ask.”

Naomi Gonzales, Public Health Coordinator at National Network of Libraries of Medicine

“To me, libraries will always be a place of discovery and empowerment. We help equip people with the knowledge they need to face their challenges, no matter how personal or epic."
“To me, libraries will always be a place of discovery and empowerment. We help equip people with the knowledge they need to face their challenges, no matter how personal or epic."

Jessie Nachem, Librarian at the Wright Institute Oakland Public Library

“Libraries are centers of discovery and a safe place to go where one is encouraged and supported in finding information that is empowering and transformative. That process is what inspires me to be a part of librarianship.” 
“Libraries are centers of discovery and a safe place to go where one is encouraged and supported in finding information that is empowering and transformative. That process is what inspires me to be a part of librarianship.” 

Leontine Synor, Trustee at East Cleveland Public Library

“Libraries are resources for those who otherwise would not have access to information due to finances, educational achievement, and other barriers. Libraries also serve as a safe space for those who are met with circumstances beyond their control, and provides them a place to learn, interact, ask questions and locate resources.”
“Libraries are resources for those who otherwise would not have access to information due to finances, educational achievement, and other barriers. Libraries also serve as a safe space for those who are met with circumstances beyond their control, and provides them a place to learn, interact, ask questions and locate resources.”

Susan K .McClelland, Adult and Teen Services Librarian at Oak Park Public Library

“Librarians are warrior princes and princesses wielding book love like words! We are ever vigilant, curious, intelligent, and kind. Libraries are the banners that we carry proudly into the fray! Forward, ever Forward!”
“Librarians are warrior princes and princesses wielding book love like words! We are ever vigilant, curious, intelligent, and kind. Libraries are the banners that we carry proudly into the fray! Forward, ever Forward!”

Dolly Goyal, Library Director at Los Gatos Library

“There’s a huge and growing barrier to technology facing a large portion of our population. Millions of people don’t have direct access to technology or understand how to use it. Libraries provide free tools and e-literacy services with patience and compassion.”
“There’s a huge and growing barrier to technology facing a large portion of our population. Millions of people don’t have direct access to technology or understand how to use it. Libraries provide free tools and e-literacy services with patience and compassion.”

Taina Evans, Library Information Supervisor at Brooklyn Public Library

“Librarians empower users in their pursuit of knowledge, learning, and in discovery and research across all disciplinary fields, transcending race, color, and creed. By far the most valuable institution available to the public for free. I love working here, empowering others.”
“Librarians empower users in their pursuit of knowledge, learning, and in discovery and research across all disciplinary fields, transcending race, color, and creed. By far the most valuable institution available to the public for free. I love working here, empowering others.”

Erik Toussaint, Library Program Coordinator at FOKAL (Foundation for Knowledge and Liberty)

“Libraries are important for getting people to gather and share community values. Their openness to the world facilitates communication and knowledge. Many people cannot afford technology or access to the internet. We need the library to help with that. Without libraries there would be a radical decrease of academic performance, less connection among people of the community, no more space for expression or learning of new skills.”

Love HuffPost? Become a founding member of HuffPost Plus today.

This article originally appeared on HuffPost.