GOP Doesn't Want to Govern and Democrats Can't

Ron Fournier
National Journal

In the broadest possible sense, this is what happened in "This Town" this month:

Republicans undercut the economy and damaged their brand. Americans justifiably blamed the Republican Party for the debt-ceiling fight and government shutdown, which Standard & Poors said cost the economy about $24 billion. The debacle affected the public's overall opinion of Republicans: Only 32 percent of Americans say they have a favorable impression of the GOP, according to a Washington Post poll, compared to 46 percent for the Democratic Party.

More from NJ: Why Republicans Kill Their Darlings

Beyond the moment, the brinksmanship cut against a core Republican mission: To minimize the importance of government.  While most Americans were not affected by shuttered federal offices, public parks, research projects and community programs, they were reminded of why government matters. They might even appreciate it a bit more.

More from NJ: How Kirsten Gillibrand Shed Her Past on the Way to Liberal Stardom

A second branding problem: Republicans bill themselves as the fiscally responsible governing coalition. That's a hard claim to make when a muscular minority of your party wants to default on the nation's debt.

More from NJ: Buck Stops With Obama on Rocky Rollout of Health Care Plan

Democrats undercut their goal of universal health care coverage and damaged their brand. After decades of advocating for health care reform, the Democratic Party seems incapable so far of implementing it. An online federal marketplace (for people living in states that did not create their own health insurance pools) launched Oct. 1, and it's a bust. Obama and his team are trying to deflect responsibility by blaming others (website developers, the media, the GOP etc.) and minimizing the damage. Their refrain: "Obamacare is more than just a website." But even journalists sympathetic to Obama, such as Ezra Klein of the Washington Post, understand that the website is crucial to the law's success and must be fixed.

Launching a website is the easy part. Democrats still must convince young Americans to buy health insurance they don't think they need -- and deal with blowback from countless Americans who will pay more and get less in the new marketplace.

If Republicans helped Americans appreciate government, Obamacare is causing Americans to question it. The decades-old core argument of the Democratic Party is that government can do good things efficiently. Botching health care reform would be a major setback to that brand.  

NBC News' "First Read" summed up the situation this way: "The Obama White House and Democrats have a political problem when it comes to governing (see the Obamacare website), while Republicans have a political problem because they don't want to govern (see the shutdown). And both sides have used the other party's problems to mask their own."

Voters, meanwhile, are turning against both parties. The public's faith in Congress, the presidency and virtually every political institution is at near-record lows. Sixty-percent of Americans want every member of Congress tossed from office. More people disapprove of Obama's performance than approve.

There is no reason for Americans to think the GOP will decide to govern, or that Democrats will learn to govern well.

More from NJ: